10 Jul 2025
Marketing

so its an app basically only for content creators, it would be a ...

...monthly payable thing but also based on commission.

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Freemium

People love using similar products but resist paying. You’ll need to either find who will pay or create additional value that’s worth paying for.

Should You Build It?

Build but think about differentiation and monetization.


Your are here

Your idea for a content creator app with monthly and commission-based payments falls into the "Freemium" category. This means you're on the right track, but face the challenge of convincing users to pay for something they might expect for free. With 6 similar products already out there, competition is noticeable, meaning you need to stand out. These existing platforms have decent engagement with an average of 17 comments, meaning there is signal and some demand. To succeed, you'll need to understand what makes your app uniquely valuable and who is most willing to pay for those features. This might involve a laser focus on a specific niche of creators or offering premium tools that significantly boost their income or efficiency. Differentiation and a solid monetization strategy are key to your success.

Recommendations

  1. Start by deeply understanding your target users. July, a similar platform, received positive feedback for streamlining brand deals and simplifying workflows for creators. Focus your initial efforts on identifying the pain points that are not adequately addressed by existing platforms like July and Barter. What specific tasks or workflows do content creators struggle with that your app can solve better or more efficiently?
  2. Identify the content creators who receive the most value from free versions of similar platforms. Who are they, what do they do, and what are their biggest needs? Then, create premium features tailored to those high-value users. Consider, for example, advanced analytics, automated content scheduling, or collaborative tools for larger teams that would justify a premium subscription.
  3. Consider charging teams or agencies instead of individual creators. This can provide a higher revenue stream and also incentivize more usage of the platform overall. Focus on features that are valuable for teams working on collaborative projects to improve monetization.
  4. Explore personalized help or consulting as a premium offering. Some creators may struggle with specific aspects of content creation, such as optimizing content for different platforms or developing a content strategy. Offering personalized guidance can be a valuable upsell that differentiates you from competitors.
  5. Iterate and refine your pricing model. It seems a commission plus a monthly subscription may be too much to ask for early adopters, so start with one or the other. Test different pricing approaches with small groups of users to find the optimal balance between value and affordability. Focus on identifying the price point that maximizes user acquisition while still generating sustainable revenue.
  6. Closely examine the criticisms leveled against similar platforms. The comments regarding the July launch show that filtering mechanisms are important. This can help you proactively address potential issues and build a better user experience. Learn from their missteps to ensure that your app is perceived as fair, transparent, and beneficial for creators.
  7. Prioritize building a robust and user-friendly platform. Many users of Barter reported bugs, so invest in rigorous testing and quality assurance to ensure a seamless experience. Address any technical issues promptly and gather user feedback to continuously improve the platform's performance.

Questions

  1. Given that similar platforms have faced concerns about exploitation of creators, how will your app ensure fair and transparent commission rates and prevent potential conflicts of interest?
  2. Considering the high engagement levels on existing platforms, what strategies will you employ to attract and retain users, and how will you foster a sense of community and collaboration within your app?
  3. In what specific ways will your app empower creators to grow their businesses and increase their income, and how will you measure and communicate the value proposition to potential users?

Your are here

Your idea for a content creator app with monthly and commission-based payments falls into the "Freemium" category. This means you're on the right track, but face the challenge of convincing users to pay for something they might expect for free. With 6 similar products already out there, competition is noticeable, meaning you need to stand out. These existing platforms have decent engagement with an average of 17 comments, meaning there is signal and some demand. To succeed, you'll need to understand what makes your app uniquely valuable and who is most willing to pay for those features. This might involve a laser focus on a specific niche of creators or offering premium tools that significantly boost their income or efficiency. Differentiation and a solid monetization strategy are key to your success.

Recommendations

  1. Start by deeply understanding your target users. July, a similar platform, received positive feedback for streamlining brand deals and simplifying workflows for creators. Focus your initial efforts on identifying the pain points that are not adequately addressed by existing platforms like July and Barter. What specific tasks or workflows do content creators struggle with that your app can solve better or more efficiently?
  2. Identify the content creators who receive the most value from free versions of similar platforms. Who are they, what do they do, and what are their biggest needs? Then, create premium features tailored to those high-value users. Consider, for example, advanced analytics, automated content scheduling, or collaborative tools for larger teams that would justify a premium subscription.
  3. Consider charging teams or agencies instead of individual creators. This can provide a higher revenue stream and also incentivize more usage of the platform overall. Focus on features that are valuable for teams working on collaborative projects to improve monetization.
  4. Explore personalized help or consulting as a premium offering. Some creators may struggle with specific aspects of content creation, such as optimizing content for different platforms or developing a content strategy. Offering personalized guidance can be a valuable upsell that differentiates you from competitors.
  5. Iterate and refine your pricing model. It seems a commission plus a monthly subscription may be too much to ask for early adopters, so start with one or the other. Test different pricing approaches with small groups of users to find the optimal balance between value and affordability. Focus on identifying the price point that maximizes user acquisition while still generating sustainable revenue.
  6. Closely examine the criticisms leveled against similar platforms. The comments regarding the July launch show that filtering mechanisms are important. This can help you proactively address potential issues and build a better user experience. Learn from their missteps to ensure that your app is perceived as fair, transparent, and beneficial for creators.
  7. Prioritize building a robust and user-friendly platform. Many users of Barter reported bugs, so invest in rigorous testing and quality assurance to ensure a seamless experience. Address any technical issues promptly and gather user feedback to continuously improve the platform's performance.

Questions

  1. Given that similar platforms have faced concerns about exploitation of creators, how will your app ensure fair and transparent commission rates and prevent potential conflicts of interest?
  2. Considering the high engagement levels on existing platforms, what strategies will you employ to attract and retain users, and how will you foster a sense of community and collaboration within your app?
  3. In what specific ways will your app empower creators to grow their businesses and increase their income, and how will you measure and communicate the value proposition to potential users?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 6
  • Engagement: High
    • Average number of comments: 17
  • Net use signal: 21.6%
    • Positive use signal: 21.6%
    • Negative use signal: 0.0%
  • Net buy signal: 0.0%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.0%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.0%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

July - Automate your entire creator business

July is the only platform that automates brand deals, so creators can focus on what matters: creating great content. Streamline your outreach, negotiations, media kit, and payments all in one place.

The Product Hunt launch of July received overwhelmingly positive feedback. Users express excitement for the platform's ability to empower creators, streamline brand deals, and simplify workflows. Many congratulate the team, particularly Wells, on their hard work and the product's potential to revolutionize the creator economy. Users highlight the platform's ease of use, time-saving features, and positive impact on helping creators grow their businesses. Some users shared their success using the platform already. The all-in-one nature of the product is also appreciated. Some inquired about future plans and brand focus.

Criticism centers on potential exploitation of creators by managers or agencies. There are concerns about the platform's filtering mechanisms for incoming pitches from creators, and the potential for the system to be overwhelmed, which may impact the quality of the platform. The structure may cause too much noise.


Avatar
357
85
22.4%
85
357
22.4%
Relevance

Barter - The ultimate app for creators

Barter makes working together with content creators as easy as ordering pizza. Our automated platform enables companies to collaborate with content creators without an agency or high costs. Creators apply for their offers directly through our app.

Barter's Product Hunt launch garnered positive feedback, with users loving the concept of empowering creators to monetize skills and expand networks. Many congratulated the team and wished them luck. The streamlining of collaborations was seen as a breath of fresh air. Suggestions included adding a rating system and influencer information. Despite some reported bugs, users expressed a positive experience and wished for continued growth and success.

Users suggest implementing a rating system to assess quality and reliability. There's a need for more detailed information and examples of influencers within the platform. Matching brand ethos with creator vibes to improve collaboration is a crucial suggestion. While users have reported bugs, the overall experience remains positive.


Avatar
122
14
35.7%
14
122
35.7%
Top