Should I Build It Should I Build It
02 Jul 2025
GitHub

screenshot storing app which manage and store screenshot in well ...

...defined manner

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Freemium

People love using similar products but resist paying. You’ll need to either find who will pay or create additional value that’s worth paying for.

Should You Build It?

Build but think about differentiation and monetization.

Your are here

Your idea for a screenshot storing and management app falls into the 'Freemium' category, meaning users appreciate these tools but often hesitate to pay. With 5 similar products already out there, you're entering a moderately competitive space. These existing products have garnered medium engagement, averaging around 8 comments per product, which indicates some level of user interest and interaction. To succeed, you'll need to find a way to either identify the specific users that derive immense value from these products and are therefore most likely to pay, or create additional premium features that make paying a no-brainer. Differentiation will be key, and your monetization strategy needs careful consideration.

Recommendations

  1. Begin by deeply understanding which user segments benefit most from free screenshot management. Are they developers, designers, customer support teams, or something else? Knowing this will help you tailor your premium features and marketing efforts. Analyze existing products like Camp 2.0 and ScreenDust for insights.
  2. Develop premium features that significantly enhance the experience for your target users. Consider features like advanced OCR, automated tagging, secure cloud storage with version control, integrations with popular productivity tools (Slack, Notion, Jira), or team collaboration features. One user of a similar product mentioned the OCR-based text copy feature was helpful.
  3. Explore pricing strategies that target teams rather than individual users. Businesses are often more willing to pay for tools that improve team collaboration and productivity. Offer tiered plans based on the number of users or storage capacity.
  4. Offer personalized help or consulting services to enterprise clients who need help setting up and optimizing their screenshot management workflow. This could include custom integrations, training sessions, and dedicated support. This high-touch approach can justify a premium price point.
  5. Before launching widely, test different pricing models and feature sets with small, targeted groups of users. Gather feedback on what they value most and what they're willing to pay for. Iterate based on their responses. Many users of similar apps want cloud sync.
  6. Address common criticisms found in similar products. Many users dislike having to pay for minor upgrades; ensure your free tier offers substantial value and that premium upgrades are genuinely worth the cost. Make sure the app is easy to understand; some users in the market of this idea found it confusing and broken.
  7. Improve your landing page and marketing materials to build credibility and trust. Clearly articulate the value proposition of your app and showcase its key features with compelling visuals. As a similar product user indicated, a more convincing landing page is needed to build credibility.
  8. Focus on creating a seamless and intuitive user experience. Address technical issues promptly and ensure the app is stable and reliable. Several users reported issues with similar screenshot apps.

Questions

  1. Given that freemium users often resist paying, what unique value proposition can you offer that would compel them to upgrade to a paid plan? How can you demonstrate this value early in the user journey?
  2. Considering the existing competition, what specific niche or user segment will you target initially to gain traction and establish a foothold in the market? What unmet needs can you address for this audience?
  3. How will you balance offering enough value in the free tier to attract users while still incentivizing them to upgrade to a paid plan? What metrics will you use to track the effectiveness of your freemium strategy?

Your are here

Your idea for a screenshot storing and management app falls into the 'Freemium' category, meaning users appreciate these tools but often hesitate to pay. With 5 similar products already out there, you're entering a moderately competitive space. These existing products have garnered medium engagement, averaging around 8 comments per product, which indicates some level of user interest and interaction. To succeed, you'll need to find a way to either identify the specific users that derive immense value from these products and are therefore most likely to pay, or create additional premium features that make paying a no-brainer. Differentiation will be key, and your monetization strategy needs careful consideration.

Recommendations

  1. Begin by deeply understanding which user segments benefit most from free screenshot management. Are they developers, designers, customer support teams, or something else? Knowing this will help you tailor your premium features and marketing efforts. Analyze existing products like Camp 2.0 and ScreenDust for insights.
  2. Develop premium features that significantly enhance the experience for your target users. Consider features like advanced OCR, automated tagging, secure cloud storage with version control, integrations with popular productivity tools (Slack, Notion, Jira), or team collaboration features. One user of a similar product mentioned the OCR-based text copy feature was helpful.
  3. Explore pricing strategies that target teams rather than individual users. Businesses are often more willing to pay for tools that improve team collaboration and productivity. Offer tiered plans based on the number of users or storage capacity.
  4. Offer personalized help or consulting services to enterprise clients who need help setting up and optimizing their screenshot management workflow. This could include custom integrations, training sessions, and dedicated support. This high-touch approach can justify a premium price point.
  5. Before launching widely, test different pricing models and feature sets with small, targeted groups of users. Gather feedback on what they value most and what they're willing to pay for. Iterate based on their responses. Many users of similar apps want cloud sync.
  6. Address common criticisms found in similar products. Many users dislike having to pay for minor upgrades; ensure your free tier offers substantial value and that premium upgrades are genuinely worth the cost. Make sure the app is easy to understand; some users in the market of this idea found it confusing and broken.
  7. Improve your landing page and marketing materials to build credibility and trust. Clearly articulate the value proposition of your app and showcase its key features with compelling visuals. As a similar product user indicated, a more convincing landing page is needed to build credibility.
  8. Focus on creating a seamless and intuitive user experience. Address technical issues promptly and ensure the app is stable and reliable. Several users reported issues with similar screenshot apps.

Questions

  1. Given that freemium users often resist paying, what unique value proposition can you offer that would compel them to upgrade to a paid plan? How can you demonstrate this value early in the user journey?
  2. Considering the existing competition, what specific niche or user segment will you target initially to gain traction and establish a foothold in the market? What unmet needs can you address for this audience?
  3. How will you balance offering enough value in the free tier to attract users while still incentivizing them to upgrade to a paid plan? What metrics will you use to track the effectiveness of your freemium strategy?

  • Confidence: Medium
    • Number of similar products: 5
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 8
  • Net use signal: 22.8%
    • Positive use signal: 24.9%
    • Negative use signal: 2.1%
  • Net buy signal: -4.0%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.0%
    • Negative buy signal: 4.0%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Clean Stash – Start Organizing Your Screenshots (Testflight App)

17 Aug 2023 Productivity

Hi HN! Today I'm launching Clean Stash - an iPhone app to organize your screenshots, as an open beta (Testflight).Here's why I built it:I take a lot of screenshots. Like a lot, and of all different use cases. Sometimes of smart marketing copy that I want to use myself, a visual I want to use in a future mood board, a sneaker I want to buy, a linkedIn post I want to quickly reference, places I want to travel...you get the point.In reality, these get lost in my phone's "Screenshots" folder. Now over 2,3k of them. I've even found myself taking screenshots of screenshots only to have them surface as more recent as I scroll. I probably have more screenshots than pictures of my kids (pls don't judge).I wanted a keep all these screenshots in one place, and given back to me in an actionable way. That's why I spent a few weeks building a solution, and today I think it's ready enough for you to use.I'd love to hear how you find this app useful, and what you'd like to have next. Feel free to add your comments below.

Interested but screen sharing shows blank gray pop up.

Screen sharing shows blank gray pop up.

Avatar
3
1
1
3
Relevance

Camp 2.0 - Let AI understand and organize your screenshots

17 Jan 2024 iOS Artificial Intelligence Productivity

Screenshots are one of the easiest ways to save content on your phone. Camp supercharges your screen capture flow by automatically detecting and extracting information you care about.

Users express excitement about Camp AI's screenshot organization capabilities, particularly with location saving and clearing junk from photo libraries. Many are eager to try it, praising the landing page and concept. Some users inquire about AI models used and iCloud sync. Feature requests include saving screenshots to the iPhone gallery and a PC version. One user reported a 500 error on the website and another found the app confusing and broken. Others praise the tool and congratulate the team on the launch.

Users criticized the separate screenshot app as unnecessary friction. There are requests for Google Maps/Apple Maps integration and a more convincing landing page to build credibility. Concerns were raised about iCloud/phone syncing and potential job displacement due to automation. Technical issues were reported, including a website internal server error and a broken app with confusing functions and the inability to delete categories. The app's core functionality and user experience need improvement.

lrueger

This looks really cool, I just downloaded the app. I understand that you want to keep it all in your app but as a user it feels like an extra friction to have the organized screenshots in a seperate app. Is there a way to save / alter the screenshots to the iPhone gallery?

sara_with_h

I think that's a great thing!! I mean, everyone knows it. We take screenshots of everything that seems important to us and then have no overview at all. I'm really looking forward to trying out the app and will definitely give my feedback. Personally, I often take screenshots of things I want to buy. I also find it fascinating that locations are also saved. Is it possible to link this map to Google Maps or to the Apple map?

alvarovillalb_

Screenshots are a great pain for me. But I'm no fan of downloading new apps(it's been a frustrating waste of time lately). Maybe a more convincing landing page could help build credibility and eliminate this friction to download apps. Either way, I'm using it right away! Congrats for the launch @guard_if 😎

saswat_singh

Amazing tool. Landing page looks cool will try out definitely.

eugeneyarovoii

@guard_if Congratulations on your launch! I literally was dreaming about some kind of a solution to gather and organize my screenshots! Followed you on Twitter :)

pamsny

Very cool product! I was just thinking of starting to organize them manually but I have 28 thousand! How does the sync work with our current icloud/ phone? I would actually love to delete them off my phone and be able to have them separately than my pictures. thanks!

nicole_rose_balsamo

WOW, awesome!!! I've *always* wanted to manually do this but never get around to it. Downloading!!!

yash_moondhra

Awesome! Really excited to see something that will help me clear my photo library of all the junk I have accumulated lol

vanadian

Wow, you read my mind, this is exactly what I needed but how I can save images in my phone gallery

invstor

oh this is cool!! trying it out, congrats on your launch!

abhilash_chowdhary

Congrats team Camp 2.0 on your launch. Excited to try it.

Avatar
143
20
50.0%
-5.0%
20
143
55.0%
Relevance

Powerful Screenshot tool for Mac without a paywall

22 Sep 2024 Mac Productivity

Hey HN! I am Adi, One of the builders of Zipshot(https://zipshot.co/) and a FAANG engineer.Zipshot is a power packed screenshot app for individuals and teams. Screenshots are essential for communication and information sharing with people, whether it's with friends or colleagues. While every operating systems support capturing screenshots natively, it is not as easy and straightforward to share screenshots or edit them or add your comments on top. Also, OS does a poor job in naming the screenshot files and it ends up cluttering desktop for most people while being a pain to search later on.Zipshot address all these problem and more: * Cloud storage & sharable link * Sharing settings and making images private * Annotations, Comments, and a Powerful editor * Dashboard and auto-naming of screenshots. * Private, Encrypted, & One click data download. ## Why we built itMost of the decent screenshot tools out there are paid, and we found the UX to be lacking. As someone who grew up during the early days of the internet, I really dislike how even the simplest tools require a subscription now — even if you use them infrequently. With Zipshot, our goal to keep it free for individual users forever.## How we plan to do it * Our backend is designed to be lightweight enough to handle a large user base on the free tier. * Screenshots older than 3 months are automatically deleted (you can download them anytime beforehand) to avoid indefinite storage costs. * If we need to monetize, we can explore creative options like an enterprise plan, SaaS newsletter ads (without spamming your images!), or something equally non-intrusive. ## What’s nextToday Zipshot is used by a tiny number of users and they love it. We have new stuff on our roadmap like. * OCR-based text copy from screenshots * Google Drive integration so you can fully own your data * Full-page scrolling screenshots * Editor tools to prettify your screenshots for social media * A Windows app is in the works! ## What we needYour support and constructive feedback. Download and try the mac app or the chrome extension or both (Mac app is more powerful). We are improving the app everyday.

One user intends to test the product in a team setting but is uncertain about its value. The OCR-based text copy feature was highlighted as helpful. The majority of comments are either deleted or contain no content.

Users are frustrated with having to pay for minor upgrades.

Avatar
18
15
6.7%
-6.7%
15
18
6.7%
Relevance

ScreenDust - Effortless knowledge base screenshot management

21 Mar 2024 Productivity Customer Success

A streamlined solution designed to automate and simplify the management of screenshots in knowledge bases. This tool is for all those in the B2B sector who know the struggle of keeping visual documentation up-to-date with ever-changing software interfaces.

The Product Hunt launch received positive feedback, with users praising its usefulness for creating knowledge bases, especially for new recruits, and its clean, intuitive UI. The concept was well-received, and users wished the product success. One user noted that organizing pictures in folders on a desktop is not ideal.

The user's feedback suggests that the current method of organization may not be optimal, implying a need for improvement in the structure or categorization of the product's elements.

Avatar
118
7
7
118
Top