Your are here

You're entering a market with very little existing activity, falling into the "Minimal Signal" category. This means that the problem you're trying to solve with your fishing social app, while potentially interesting to you, might not be broadly recognized as a critical need by others or it's perhaps a very niche space. With only one similar product found, our confidence in this assessment is low, which means more validation is needed before heavy investment. Engagement for similar products is also low. Currently, the key is to determine if a real demand exists for your idea before dedicating significant time and resources. Don't get discouraged, but proceed with caution and validation as your top priority.

Recommendations

1. Start by posting in online communities, forums, or social media groups where fishing enthusiasts gather. Specifically ask about their current methods for sharing fishing locations, data, and experiences, and gauge their interest in a dedicated social app for this purpose. This will give you a good qualitative sense of the demand.
2. Offer to manually curate and share fishing data (lake information, species, etc.) with a small group of potential users (2-3 anglers). This will help you understand what data is most valuable to them, what features they would find useful, and how you might differentiate your app. It's also a great way to build early relationships and get feedback.
3. Create a short, engaging explainer video showcasing the core features and benefits of your fishing social app. Highlight how it simplifies data sharing, connects anglers, and enhances the overall fishing experience. Track how many people watch the video fully as an indicator of genuine interest.
4. Implement a waiting list and ask for a small, non-binding deposit to join. This can be a simple 'reserve your spot' system. This tactic can show how many people are truly interested in using your app, not just passively liking the idea.
5. Based on these validation efforts, set a clear goal: to find at least 5 genuinely interested people within the next 3 weeks. If you consistently struggle to reach this number, reconsider the viability of your idea in its current form or pivot towards a more validated need within the fishing community.
6. Research the one similar product that was identified. What are its strengths and weaknesses? What is the user feedback like? Identify areas where you can provide a superior experience or a unique value proposition.

Questions

1. What specific problem(s) are anglers currently facing when trying to share fishing location data, and how does your app solve these problems in a significantly better way than existing solutions (e.g., general-purpose social media groups, note apps, etc.)?
2. Given the low initial signal, what are your contingency plans if you fail to find enough traction with your initial target audience? Are there alternative user segments or complementary features you could explore to broaden your app's appeal?
3. How will you differentiate your app from existing fishing apps or general social media platforms? What is your unique value proposition, and how will you communicate this to potential users to attract them to your platform?