Users provided mixed feedback on the Show HN product, with some praising its potential for improving study efficiency and others noting issues with AI quality and lab session integration. The use of flashcards, both AI-generated and traditional, was a common topic, with discussions on their effectiveness and a market for selling sets. Questions about identifying AI hallucinations and concerns about copyright and data handling were raised. TikTok was referenced as a comparison in learning social cues and user data interaction. Minor technical issues were mentioned, and there was interest in the product's setup and demo.

Users criticized the AI's quality, noting it's better suited for teachers with tools, and that it causes hand cramps and hallucinations, impacting study time. Concerns about unclear hallucination detection, copyright issues, data handling, and cheating were raised. The marketplace's obscurity, issues with scrolling, file management, and lack of response after quizzes were also mentioned. Some see it as just a demo with redundant content.

Edily's Product Hunt launch garnered positive feedback, with users praising its innovative approach to education, particularly its blend of TikTok-style videos and Khan Academy's learning structure. Users are excited about its potential to make learning fun, engaging, and more efficient, especially for Gen Z. Many appreciate the app's design and the concept of learning maps. There's enthusiasm for converting unproductive screen time into productive learning. Some users are curious about content sourcing and suggest focused feeds for other platforms. Several users congratulated the team and wished them success.

Users criticized the lack of content examples on the website/app and found the launch video to be too reliant on stock footage, failing to showcase specific features. Some expressed concerns about the impact of short-form entertainment on the long-form educational video market. Distracting notifications were also mentioned as a hindrance to learning. Users also want the platform to extend it's availability to other social media platforms such as LinkedIn, Facebook and Instagram.

JustLearn's Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback. Users are excited about the concept of transforming idle scrolling into productive learning through bite-sized videos and quizzes, drawing comparisons to a guilt-free TikTok. Many congratulated the creator on addressing the 'wasted time' problem and praised the user-friendly design. There's a strong interest in using it for language learning and skill improvement. Multiple Android users are seeking the app on the Play Store, with one requesting a direct link. Overall, users find JustLearn engaging, accessible, and a much-needed solution for utilizing fragmented time.

The Product Hunt launch received criticism regarding the app's availability, as users reported it couldn't be found in the app store. There were concerns about the product's ability to overcome the chicken-and-egg problem. Additionally, questions were raised about maintaining content quality and accuracy as the platform scales.

EduTik's Product Hunt launch garnered congratulations and excitement, especially regarding its potential for Gen Z learning in the MENA region. Users view it as a good idea and a smart platform. Some see it as a welcome alternative to doomscrolling, praising the videos. However, concerns were raised about the current availability of only Urdu videos and the need for more educational content ('EduTiks') rather than TikTok-like content. Suggestions were made regarding content categories, similarities to other platforms were noted, and questions were asked about ensuring the educational value of the videos.

The Product Hunt launch received criticism for its content. Users expressed a desire for less time-wasting material and more educational content. A significant concern was the limited language availability, with content primarily in Urdu, hindering accessibility for a broader, international audience.

Comment Deleted

Users expressed initial skepticism regarding the product's immediate availability, with some questioning its launch status and seeking clarity on its functionality beyond email subscriptions. There's strong interest in participating and trying the product, fueled by the perception of its potential perfection. Some are curious about video sources and their authenticity. The concept of informative learning through social media is seen as inspiring and beneficial.

The Product Hunt launch received criticism for not being a fully-fledged product and being unready for the platform. Concerns were raised regarding the nature of the video source (PGC/UGC) and the assurance of its authenticity. The main criticism appears to be that the submission is too premature for Product Hunt.

The Product Hunt launch features articles collected via the Wikipedia API, offering a randomization feature similar to Wikipedia's random article function. Users suggest that it's a good idea, particularly for those who enjoy scrolling and discovering new content. A prominent request among users is the addition of a search bar to enhance the discovery and navigation experience.

Users are requesting a search bar to more easily find specific knowledge within the platform. This feature would improve the user experience by allowing for more targeted content discovery.