Should I Build It Should I Build It
22 Aug 2025
Artificial Intelligence Startup Lessons

my startup would provide recommendation about the user ideas startutp.

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Run Away

Multiple attempts have failed with clear negative feedback. Continuing down this path would likely waste your time and resources when better opportunities exist elsewhere.

Should You Build It?

Don't build it.

Your are here

Your startup idea, which revolves around providing recommendations for other users' startup ideas, falls into a challenging category. Our analysis indicates that similar ventures have faced significant hurdles, leading to a "Run Away" classification. This category is characterized by multiple failed attempts and clear negative feedback. With 9 similar products already identified, the competitive landscape is crowded, and the likelihood of success without significant differentiation and value proposition is low. Given this context, it's crucial to carefully consider whether pursuing this path aligns with your goals and resources. You need to understand what problems you are solving, and if you're solving them in a novel way!

Recommendations

  1. Thoroughly analyze the criticism from similar products, especially regarding the ineffectiveness of AI, concerns about idea theft, and the perception of idea harvesting. Understand the core reasons behind their struggles. Delve deep into the negative feedback to identify recurring themes and specific pain points that users experienced with these existing platforms. This involves not just reading the comments, but also trying to understand the underlying frustrations and unmet needs.
  2. Pivot your skills to address a related but distinct problem within the startup ecosystem. Instead of directly validating ideas, consider focusing on specific aspects like market research, competitor analysis, or go-to-market strategy. For example, can you create a tool that helps founders identify their ideal customer profile or validate their pricing strategy? This targeted approach may offer a clearer value proposition and reduce the risk of being perceived as a generic idea validator.
  3. If you've already developed any technology for your initial idea, explore alternative applications for it. Perhaps the core algorithms or data analysis techniques could be repurposed for a different industry or problem domain. This is especially important if you have IP/code already developed. For instance, if you created an AI algorithm to analyze startup ideas, explore alternative use cases for this tool.
  4. Reach out to individuals who have experimented with similar idea validation platforms to gain first-hand insights into their needs and frustrations. Understand what they were hoping to achieve, what they liked or disliked about existing solutions, and what they believe is missing from the market. Talking with real users is incredibly helpful, as reading comments and summaries only conveys so much.
  5. Based on your learnings, formulate a fresh startup idea that addresses a specific unmet need in the startup space. Focus on creating a solution that is differentiated, provides clear value, and resonates with your target audience. Consider focusing on the long term goal of where you see the startup ecosystem and how you fit inside. As you consider this new idea, make sure it's defensible from AI.

Questions

  1. Considering the negative feedback surrounding idea theft and the perception of idea harvesting in similar products, how will you ensure the confidentiality and security of users' ideas on your platform?
  2. Given the criticism of AI's ineffectiveness in idea validation, what unique approach or methodology will you employ to provide valuable and insightful recommendations to founders?
  3. With the competitive landscape already crowded, how will you differentiate your startup from existing idea validation platforms and establish a clear value proposition that resonates with your target audience?

Your are here

Your startup idea, which revolves around providing recommendations for other users' startup ideas, falls into a challenging category. Our analysis indicates that similar ventures have faced significant hurdles, leading to a "Run Away" classification. This category is characterized by multiple failed attempts and clear negative feedback. With 9 similar products already identified, the competitive landscape is crowded, and the likelihood of success without significant differentiation and value proposition is low. Given this context, it's crucial to carefully consider whether pursuing this path aligns with your goals and resources. You need to understand what problems you are solving, and if you're solving them in a novel way!

Recommendations

  1. Thoroughly analyze the criticism from similar products, especially regarding the ineffectiveness of AI, concerns about idea theft, and the perception of idea harvesting. Understand the core reasons behind their struggles. Delve deep into the negative feedback to identify recurring themes and specific pain points that users experienced with these existing platforms. This involves not just reading the comments, but also trying to understand the underlying frustrations and unmet needs.
  2. Pivot your skills to address a related but distinct problem within the startup ecosystem. Instead of directly validating ideas, consider focusing on specific aspects like market research, competitor analysis, or go-to-market strategy. For example, can you create a tool that helps founders identify their ideal customer profile or validate their pricing strategy? This targeted approach may offer a clearer value proposition and reduce the risk of being perceived as a generic idea validator.
  3. If you've already developed any technology for your initial idea, explore alternative applications for it. Perhaps the core algorithms or data analysis techniques could be repurposed for a different industry or problem domain. This is especially important if you have IP/code already developed. For instance, if you created an AI algorithm to analyze startup ideas, explore alternative use cases for this tool.
  4. Reach out to individuals who have experimented with similar idea validation platforms to gain first-hand insights into their needs and frustrations. Understand what they were hoping to achieve, what they liked or disliked about existing solutions, and what they believe is missing from the market. Talking with real users is incredibly helpful, as reading comments and summaries only conveys so much.
  5. Based on your learnings, formulate a fresh startup idea that addresses a specific unmet need in the startup space. Focus on creating a solution that is differentiated, provides clear value, and resonates with your target audience. Consider focusing on the long term goal of where you see the startup ecosystem and how you fit inside. As you consider this new idea, make sure it's defensible from AI.

Questions

  1. Considering the negative feedback surrounding idea theft and the perception of idea harvesting in similar products, how will you ensure the confidentiality and security of users' ideas on your platform?
  2. Given the criticism of AI's ineffectiveness in idea validation, what unique approach or methodology will you employ to provide valuable and insightful recommendations to founders?
  3. With the competitive landscape already crowded, how will you differentiate your startup from existing idea validation platforms and establish a clear value proposition that resonates with your target audience?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 9
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 4
  • Net use signal: -20.6%
    • Positive use signal: 4.9%
    • Negative use signal: 25.4%
  • Net buy signal: -17.7%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.0%
    • Negative buy signal: 17.7%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

I'm building an app where you can validate your startup ideas

24 Aug 2024 Tech

I've launched two other startups this year, without validating the idea or requesting feedback on them. Got 0 interest as a result, they failed flat on their face.This experience led me to learn more about startup product validation, but I had a problem: where do I find the users of my product and how can I contact them?Why shouldn't this be easy, why not have a centralized platform that can connect the person with the idea with potential users and get validation before committing.The startup is called PitchPeers. It's work in progress, but you can join the waitlist.If you have any feedback, I would love to hear it. Thanks!

Avatar
3
3
Relevance

I made a tool to help collect and validate startup ideas

14 Aug 2024 Artificial Intelligence Productivity

Hey HN, I’m Kyrylo. I recently created a small tool that lets you gather, refine, and validate SaaS/startup ideas using AI. I used to jot down my product ideas in a note apps, but it wasn’t very practical for collecting feedback or refining them. So, I built this tool to make the process easier.Here’s how it works:1. Enter a brief description of your idea. 2. The app uses AI to generate project details. 3. Share your idea via a link that includes a feedback form.It’s pretty straightforward, and I’d love to hear your thoughts or any suggestions!

Users commented on a variety of Show HN products/services, from FuneralDash for funeral planning to WeatherBet for weather betting. Some expressed skepticism about AI and preferred human validation or existing tools like Google Docs. There were concerns about age limitations, licensing, and the effectiveness of some ideas. Innovative concepts like Antimatter warp engines and video conferencing toilets were mentioned, as well as a crowdfunding platform for political lobbying. Users also discussed the potential of IdeaCapturePro and AdPaw Hat for monetization. The landing page and Pieter Levels were praised, while some comments were sarcastic or protective of their ideas.

Users expressed skepticism about AI's effectiveness for the service, likened it to Google Docs, and questioned its originality and clarity in solving problems. Concerns about idea theft, arbitrary restrictions, and the platform's tone were noted. The 'world domination' goal was criticized as unclear and inappropriate. Users found the Q&A format unsuitable for brainstorming and were puzzled by the public nature of the platform. Criticisms also included a lack of features, differentiation, and creativity, as well as issues with idea rejection and selection criteria. The sign-up process was faulted for not saving initial ideas.

Avatar
38
32
-25.0%
-18.8%
32
38
3.1%
Relevance

I built an app to help you get good startup ideas

28 Nov 2024 Startup Lessons Artificial Intelligence

After spending months building an AI chatbot no one used, I experienced myself first hand why most side projects fail: they solve problems no one has. Inspired by Paul Graham’s essay on getting startup ideas https://www.paulgraham.com/startupideas.html, I decided to stop chasing new technologies and wanted to start focusing on solving real problems I experience daily.To make this process easier, I built FireUp. It’s a simple app that lets you log your daily annoyances and includes an AI to turn them into actionable startup ideas. By logging your daily annoyances you can easily spot recurring patterns and start side projects that solve them. The integrated AI feature let’s you select a certain annoyance and the AI will suggest potential MVPs, feasible for solo founders, and provides a starting point for validating ideas. You can also add new startup ideas manually if you don’t want to use any AI features.As this is my first app, I’d love to hear your thoughts. Here’s the link: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/fireup-ai-startup-generator/id...If I notice many people are interested in this I will also launch an android version soon

Avatar
2
2
Relevance

I made the home page for my new SaaS idea

01 Aug 2024 SaaS

Hi, I came up with this idea and am going to be launching soon and have worked on the technical feasibility of the SaaS which is essentially an idea tracker for business ideas with the ability to validate whether they would be good in the market by looking at competitors weaknesses. I have worked on this tool for a while now and have just made the MVP but it isn't launched yet. You can subscribe to the email if you want to but any thoughts on whether you would use this would be great. If you wouldn't that's fine, I just hope it is useful for someone. The idea came from my own annoyance at organising ideas for SaaS projects and am planning on adding many more features. Anyway, thanks for reading my mini manifesto. Hope you like it, Dan

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

I made tool to let founders to research their idea through SEO keyword

03 Jun 2024 SEO Productivity

Since i always waste time to build app that nobody wants, i have made this free tool to let Start up founders to research their idea through SEO keyword before wasting 3 to 6 months building start up nobody wants. I hope it helps everyone here.

Users have noted that the tool has a modal pop-up that obstructs the screen and asks for money. Additionally, the tool is designed to focus on long-tail keywords in English markets.

Users criticized the product for feeling like idea harvesting and found the initial pop-up disturbing.

Avatar
2
2
0.0%
-50.0%
2
2
50.0%
Relevance

I made a site to save you 6 months before building your startup

11 Jun 2024 Productivity Marketing

Hello,I've launched about 13 startups now, and all of them failed because I was trying to solve problems that didn't exist.Thus, I've come up with an idea: every time I start a new venture, I'll check my idea with SEO keywords to see if people are searching for the problem or not.Would like to know your thought about the product.

Avatar
3
3
Relevance

EntreQuick - Everything starts with an idea

03 Mar 2025 Productivity

Everything starts with an idea. Use EntreQuick to document, vet, and organize all your new business ideas. Forecast start-up funding, revenue, and profit. Your own personal new business idea incubator.

Avatar
4
4
Top