cut youtube videos for shorts from full videos for vlogers
Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal
Idea type: Competitive Terrain
While there's clear interest in your idea, the market is saturated with similar offerings. To succeed, your product needs to stand out by offering something unique that competitors aren't providing. The challenge here isn’t whether there’s demand, but how you can capture attention and keep it.
Should You Build It?
Not before thinking deeply about differentiation.
Your are here
Your idea to cut YouTube videos into shorts for vloggers places you in a highly competitive market. There are already many similar tools available, as indicated by the 20 matching products we found. This means that while there's a clear need for such a service, standing out from the crowd will be crucial. Engagement with these existing tools is medium, with an average of 4 comments per product. Without any significant buy or use signals, it's difficult to determine whether people are truly willing to pay for such a tool, or actively use it. Therefore, to succeed, you'll need to offer something truly unique or significantly better than what's already out there. Focus on very specific niche and then expand.
Recommendations
- Begin by thoroughly analyzing the existing solutions in the market. Identify their shortcomings in terms of features, user experience, pricing, or specific user needs. The discussions and criticism from similar product launches highlight common pain points like cumbersome workflows, limited editing capabilities, and a lack of visual demonstrations. Focus on solving those issues.
- Define your unique value proposition. What specific problem are you solving better than anyone else? Consider specializing in a particular niche, such as vloggers who create educational content or gaming videos. Tailoring your tool to a specific audience can help you stand out and attract loyal users.
- Develop a marketing strategy that clearly communicates your unique value proposition. Highlight the specific benefits that your tool offers to vloggers, such as time savings, improved video quality, or increased engagement. Use compelling visuals and testimonials to showcase your tool's capabilities.
- Prioritize user experience. Make your tool as intuitive and easy to use as possible. Pay attention to details like clear instructions, responsive design, and helpful tutorials. Address any bugs or glitches promptly to ensure a smooth user experience.
- Actively solicit feedback from your early users. Use their feedback to iterate on your product and improve its features. Engage with your users on social media and forums to build a community around your tool.
- Consider offering a freemium model to attract new users. Allow users to try your tool for free with limited features, and then offer a paid subscription for access to premium features. This can help you build a user base and generate revenue.
- Explore integrations with other popular video editing and social media tools. This can help you streamline the workflow for vloggers and make your tool more valuable. Consider integrating with platforms like Adobe Premiere Pro, Final Cut Pro, and YouTube Analytics.
- Pay very close attention to AI integration. Some users of similar products expected AI-driven responses/features, so try to implement this into your video editing tool. Similarly, some users liked the idea of faceless shorts so explore this avenue as well.
Questions
- Given the high competition, what specific, unique features will your tool offer that aren't already available in existing solutions? How will you ensure these features are truly valuable and not just gimmicks?
- How will you identify and target your ideal customer segment within the broader vlogger market? What are their specific pain points and how will your tool address them in a way that competitors don't?
- What is your plan for continuous innovation and improvement to stay ahead of the competition in the long term? How will you adapt to changing trends and user needs?
Your are here
Your idea to cut YouTube videos into shorts for vloggers places you in a highly competitive market. There are already many similar tools available, as indicated by the 20 matching products we found. This means that while there's a clear need for such a service, standing out from the crowd will be crucial. Engagement with these existing tools is medium, with an average of 4 comments per product. Without any significant buy or use signals, it's difficult to determine whether people are truly willing to pay for such a tool, or actively use it. Therefore, to succeed, you'll need to offer something truly unique or significantly better than what's already out there. Focus on very specific niche and then expand.
Recommendations
- Begin by thoroughly analyzing the existing solutions in the market. Identify their shortcomings in terms of features, user experience, pricing, or specific user needs. The discussions and criticism from similar product launches highlight common pain points like cumbersome workflows, limited editing capabilities, and a lack of visual demonstrations. Focus on solving those issues.
- Define your unique value proposition. What specific problem are you solving better than anyone else? Consider specializing in a particular niche, such as vloggers who create educational content or gaming videos. Tailoring your tool to a specific audience can help you stand out and attract loyal users.
- Develop a marketing strategy that clearly communicates your unique value proposition. Highlight the specific benefits that your tool offers to vloggers, such as time savings, improved video quality, or increased engagement. Use compelling visuals and testimonials to showcase your tool's capabilities.
- Prioritize user experience. Make your tool as intuitive and easy to use as possible. Pay attention to details like clear instructions, responsive design, and helpful tutorials. Address any bugs or glitches promptly to ensure a smooth user experience.
- Actively solicit feedback from your early users. Use their feedback to iterate on your product and improve its features. Engage with your users on social media and forums to build a community around your tool.
- Consider offering a freemium model to attract new users. Allow users to try your tool for free with limited features, and then offer a paid subscription for access to premium features. This can help you build a user base and generate revenue.
- Explore integrations with other popular video editing and social media tools. This can help you streamline the workflow for vloggers and make your tool more valuable. Consider integrating with platforms like Adobe Premiere Pro, Final Cut Pro, and YouTube Analytics.
- Pay very close attention to AI integration. Some users of similar products expected AI-driven responses/features, so try to implement this into your video editing tool. Similarly, some users liked the idea of faceless shorts so explore this avenue as well.
Questions
- Given the high competition, what specific, unique features will your tool offer that aren't already available in existing solutions? How will you ensure these features are truly valuable and not just gimmicks?
- How will you identify and target your ideal customer segment within the broader vlogger market? What are their specific pain points and how will your tool address them in a way that competitors don't?
- What is your plan for continuous innovation and improvement to stay ahead of the competition in the long term? How will you adapt to changing trends and user needs?
- Confidence: High
- Number of similar products: 20
- Engagement: Medium
- Average number of comments: 4
- Net use signal: 37.3%
- Positive use signal: 37.3%
- Negative use signal: 0.0%
- Net buy signal: 1.4%
- Positive buy signal: 1.4%
- Negative buy signal: 0.0%
Help
This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.
The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.
The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.
The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.
Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.
The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.
The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.
The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.
Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.
Similar products
Relevance
trimmr.ai - Turn your long videos into shorts
Trimmr is an AI-powered application that shortens long YouTube videos into shareable clips by identifying the most interesting or relevant segments of a video. It helps content creators produce viral videos that capture viewers' attention.
Impressive, promotes website wikigpt3.com, offers app listing in AI directories.
Unsolicited self-promotion, potentially spam.
76
1
1
76
Relevance
Slick - Create viral YT Shorts from videos in minutes
Upload a video or input YouTube video url and we'll automagically select interesting short-worthy clips, generate subtitles and create slick looking shorts. 100% customisable via the editor.
The Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with many users congratulating the team and expressing excitement to try the tool. Several users highlighted its potential to save time and money for video content creators, particularly those on YouTube, by eliminating the need for manual video editing. The tool's ability to create engaging content with customizable subtitles and its smooth functioning were also praised. Some users suggested improvements to the name, while others are eager to provide further feedback after using the product.
The primary criticism revolves around the product name, which users feel should be a descriptive noun rather than an adjective.
162
19
52.6%
5.3%
19
162
52.6%
5.3%
Relevance
Snapcut.ai - Repurpose long videos into viral shorts with AI
We’re making video repurposing effortless. Imagine an AI platform that cuts your editing time by 90%, delivers 15 short clips in one click, and costs up to 65 times less than hiring an editor. Focus on creating, and let Snapcut take care of the boring part 🫰
Snapcut.ai is receiving overwhelmingly positive feedback for its ability to quickly and cost-effectively create short-form videos from longer content, saving users significant time. Its intuitive UI and accessibility are particularly praised, making it suitable for smaller media teams and beginners. Users are excited about its potential for repurposing content, especially podcasts, with multilingual support including Vietnamese. Suggestions include improvements to video editing, UI and performance for high usage scenarios. Several users are congratulating the team on the launch and expressing eagerness to try the product.
Users criticize the product for including unnecessary, cumbersome tasks that should be removed to streamline the workflow. The simple video editing feature experiences lag, hindering user experience. There are also requests for more control over clip lengths during video editing to allow for greater customizability and precision.
56
17
35.3%
17
56
35.3%
Relevance
UseShorts - Automagically clip & post YouTube Shorts every day
UseShorts is an automated tool that converts your YouTube videos into engaging YouTube Shorts. Just connect your YouTube channel, and UseShorts will automatically create viral clips with subtitles and post them daily to YouTube Shorts, all on autopilot.
UseShorts received overwhelmingly positive feedback on its Product Hunt launch, with users congratulating the team and praising the tool's potential for YouTube creators. Key interests include the AI-powered Shorts creation, video editing features, and automation capabilities. Users inquired about its differentiation from competitors. Several users highlighted the increase in views and subscribers. One user reported an issue of not having Shorts created after 30 hours of linking their YouTube account. Suggestions were made to incorporate video and user-generated content. Many users expressed excitement and intent to use the tool.
Users criticize the website for lacking visual demonstrations, such as videos or GIFs, to effectively showcase Use Shorts' capabilities. Additionally, some users report encountering issues with the product not generating shorts after successfully linking their YouTube accounts, leading them to seek assistance.
154
18
38.9%
18
154
38.9%
Relevance
Turn long videos into short videos
Hey! I've been working with some friends on Bolt Foundry, a tool to help people upload long videos and download short clips to share on social platforms.It's free to use for transcription, and you can preview the clips it generates.
Users find the tool neat and useful for creating YouTube shorts. There are questions about WASM and encoding speed, and some users expected AI to summarize videos automatically. There is also a mention of Opus doing something similar.
Users expected AI-driven responses but were disappointed to find human intervention instead.
5
4
4
5
Relevance
Nice Shorts: Short Video Maker - Create consistently engaging short videos fast.
Make engaging short videos fast. AI-powered templating creates takes made to connect with your audience. It's a simple to use editor with AI features to make awesome conistently awesome short-form video content.
Comment Deleted
2
1
1
2
Relevance
Trim any part of a YouTube video quickly and seamlessly
I have created a tools that allow you to cut and trim any part of a YouTube video. I always want only part of certain youtube video for archiving and viewing as reference point quickly.
1
1
Relevance
Magic Shorts - Faceless Videos - Auto Create & Upload Videos to Your Youtube Channel Everyday
Use AI to create stunning videos without showing your face. Perfect for YouTube Shorts, TikTok, and Instagram Reels. Select from topics or create your own custom prompts. Automate your channel and grow your audience effortlessly
Users are excited about the tool, particularly for creating videos without needing to be on camera, which is appealing to introverts and content creators who prefer not to show their face. One user inquired about the possibility of tweaking videos after they have been generated, expressing anticipation to test the tool's capabilities.
5
3
66.7%
3
5
66.7%
Relevance
ShortLab - Create viral shorts in seconds
Create viral shorts for YouTube Shorts, TikTok, Facebook and Instagram Reels with ShortLab. Edit, customize and share your videos easily. Scale them to +26 languages
5
5
Relevance
Clip Cuts - Here to make the best content for you
We are a short-form content agency, where we will create as many videos as you want on a subscription basis.
4
4
Relevance
Super Shorts - Create faceless short videos for YouTube and Instagram
Effortlessly craft engaging short videos without showing your face, perfect for captivating YouTube and Instagram audiences.
The Product Hunt launch received congratulations and positive feedback, with users highlighting its potential as a game-changer. Many users are interested in using the platform to create content, especially videos, without appearing on camera. The Vijay template was specifically praised. Questions arose regarding the platform's unique selling points compared to competitors, its inspiration, and video editing capabilities, as well as its utility as a privacy tool for content creators.
46
5
40.0%
5
46
40.0%
Relevance
video bulk fast! - Upload a video and some text and each line will be a clip
I’ve been automating my short-form content and decided to share it with everyone through http://videobulk.pro ! Just create a TXT list(I use ChatGPT) and pick a background for your shorts. DEMO: https://twitter.com/Itsmecoutoo/status/1813286005518311897
Comment Deleted
8
1
1
8
Relevance
aicut - Text to short form video content in minutes
generate viral shortvideocontent from any text in minutes publish to Tiktok, Youtube, Instagram with zero editing effort
6
6
Relevance
Short Kings - Never run out of content ideas.
Breaking Down Viral Videos to Inform Your Short Form Content Strategy
1
1
Relevance
Blinkcuts - Transform your short video into next viral sensation
Blink Cuts: Trim, Highlight and burn captions in videos with ease. Enhance engagement with diverse templates, from Mr. Beast's dynamism to clear financial styles. Elevate your content today!
Blinkcuts is receiving positive feedback for its speed, simplicity, and ease of use, particularly praising its accurate transcriptions and automatic subtitle integration. Users appreciate the intuitive UI and the responsiveness of the developer. Suggestions include listing the app on AI directories like wikigpt3.com and adding more features to enhance its capabilities. The overall sentiment indicates strong support for the product and wishes for a successful launch.
Users criticized the product for limited resolution support (only 1920x1080), causing issues with square videos. There are requests for more font templates and a dark mode option to enhance user experience. A bug was also reported where demo text overlapped with original subtitles during playback.
36
5
40.0%
5
36
40.0%