Should I Build It Should I Build It
01 Jul 2025
Artificial Intelligence Personal Finance

Expense tracker with recurring payments and ai analysis, statement ...

...conversions and saving suggestions

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Swamp

The market has seen several mediocre solutions that nobody loves. Unless you can offer something fundamentally different, you’ll likely struggle to stand out or make money.

Should You Build It?

Don't build it.

Your are here

You're entering a crowded space: expense tracking. We found 16 similar products, which gives us high confidence in understanding the market, but also means you'll face stiff competition. The IDEA CATEGORY is "Swamp", which means the market has seen several mediocre solutions and it will be hard to stand out. Most similar products only get a few comments on launch, indicating low engagement, which suggests it's hard to get traction in this space. On the positive side, there appears to be a hidden demand: although the engagement is low, the average user seems genuinely interested in paying for a product like yours. This suggests that if you can address unmet needs, you might have a shot despite the competition. Focus on differentiation.

Recommendations

  1. Given that the IDEA CATEGORY is a "Swamp", start by thoroughly researching why existing expense trackers haven't fully satisfied users. Dive deep into user reviews, identify pain points, and understand what features are consistently lacking or poorly executed. From the provided similar products, users praise ease of use, AI powered receipt scanning, effective personal finance management, and AI driven reminders. Understand why these apps are successful and what these apps lack.
  2. Instead of trying to be everything to everyone, focus on a specific niche within expense tracking. Are you targeting freelancers, small business owners, or individuals with complex investment portfolios? Tailoring your solution to a specific group allows you to address their unique needs more effectively and stand out from generic trackers. For example, ShowMeMoney was criticized for a time consuming data input process. Can you speed up data entry for certain user groups?
  3. One of the similar products had users concerned about privacy. Perhaps you could build a local version for privacy.
  4. Consider exploring adjacent problems related to personal finance. Instead of just tracking expenses, could you offer automated budgeting tools, personalized financial advice, or investment recommendations based on spending patterns? Expanding your scope might uncover more promising opportunities with less direct competition.
  5. Don't overbuild initially. Focus on the core AI analysis and statement conversion features, and ruthlessly prioritize development based on user feedback. The goal is to quickly validate whether your unique approach resonates with your target audience. The discussions from similar products praise the receipt scanning, but are not always excited about AI if it is not well-implemented.
  6. Given the positive buy signal despite the "Swamp" category, experiment with different pricing models early on. Offer a free tier with limited AI analysis, and premium tiers with more advanced features and personalized saving suggestions. Monitor conversion rates and adjust pricing based on user adoption.
  7. Implement robust analytics to track user behavior and identify areas for improvement. Monitor which AI-powered insights are most valued, and which statement conversions are most frequently used. This data will inform future feature development and help you refine your product to better meet user needs.
  8. Actively seek user feedback through surveys, in-app polls, and direct communication. Engage with your early adopters to understand their pain points, feature requests, and overall satisfaction. This iterative feedback loop is crucial for building a product that truly resonates with your target audience. One user thought the AI was angry.

Questions

  1. Given the prevalence of existing solutions, what specific, unmet need does your AI-powered analysis address that current expense trackers overlook?
  2. How will you acquire early adopters and generate initial traction in a crowded market? What's your go-to-market strategy beyond a standard product launch?
  3. Considering the privacy concerns expressed by users of similar products, how will you ensure data security and user anonymity in your AI-driven analysis?

Your are here

You're entering a crowded space: expense tracking. We found 16 similar products, which gives us high confidence in understanding the market, but also means you'll face stiff competition. The IDEA CATEGORY is "Swamp", which means the market has seen several mediocre solutions and it will be hard to stand out. Most similar products only get a few comments on launch, indicating low engagement, which suggests it's hard to get traction in this space. On the positive side, there appears to be a hidden demand: although the engagement is low, the average user seems genuinely interested in paying for a product like yours. This suggests that if you can address unmet needs, you might have a shot despite the competition. Focus on differentiation.

Recommendations

  1. Given that the IDEA CATEGORY is a "Swamp", start by thoroughly researching why existing expense trackers haven't fully satisfied users. Dive deep into user reviews, identify pain points, and understand what features are consistently lacking or poorly executed. From the provided similar products, users praise ease of use, AI powered receipt scanning, effective personal finance management, and AI driven reminders. Understand why these apps are successful and what these apps lack.
  2. Instead of trying to be everything to everyone, focus on a specific niche within expense tracking. Are you targeting freelancers, small business owners, or individuals with complex investment portfolios? Tailoring your solution to a specific group allows you to address their unique needs more effectively and stand out from generic trackers. For example, ShowMeMoney was criticized for a time consuming data input process. Can you speed up data entry for certain user groups?
  3. One of the similar products had users concerned about privacy. Perhaps you could build a local version for privacy.
  4. Consider exploring adjacent problems related to personal finance. Instead of just tracking expenses, could you offer automated budgeting tools, personalized financial advice, or investment recommendations based on spending patterns? Expanding your scope might uncover more promising opportunities with less direct competition.
  5. Don't overbuild initially. Focus on the core AI analysis and statement conversion features, and ruthlessly prioritize development based on user feedback. The goal is to quickly validate whether your unique approach resonates with your target audience. The discussions from similar products praise the receipt scanning, but are not always excited about AI if it is not well-implemented.
  6. Given the positive buy signal despite the "Swamp" category, experiment with different pricing models early on. Offer a free tier with limited AI analysis, and premium tiers with more advanced features and personalized saving suggestions. Monitor conversion rates and adjust pricing based on user adoption.
  7. Implement robust analytics to track user behavior and identify areas for improvement. Monitor which AI-powered insights are most valued, and which statement conversions are most frequently used. This data will inform future feature development and help you refine your product to better meet user needs.
  8. Actively seek user feedback through surveys, in-app polls, and direct communication. Engage with your early adopters to understand their pain points, feature requests, and overall satisfaction. This iterative feedback loop is crucial for building a product that truly resonates with your target audience. One user thought the AI was angry.

Questions

  1. Given the prevalence of existing solutions, what specific, unmet need does your AI-powered analysis address that current expense trackers overlook?
  2. How will you acquire early adopters and generate initial traction in a crowded market? What's your go-to-market strategy beyond a standard product launch?
  3. Considering the privacy concerns expressed by users of similar products, how will you ensure data security and user anonymity in your AI-driven analysis?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 16
  • Engagement: Low
    • Average number of comments: 1
  • Net use signal: 35.7%
    • Positive use signal: 35.7%
    • Negative use signal: 0.0%
  • Net buy signal: 4.3%
    • Positive buy signal: 4.3%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.0%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Expense AI - Smart expense tracking with AI-powered receipt scanning

12 Dec 2024 Budgeting Fintech Accounting

ExpenseAI simplifies expense management with AI-powered tools. Snap receipts, auto-forward emails, or upload files for seamless tracking. Automate categorization, generate reports and stay on top of budgets effortlessly. Your smarter way to manage finances! 🚀

Users find the product useful and easy to manage, particularly praising its receipt scanning and expense tracking capabilities. The AI-powered features, especially reminders, are highly recommended for transforming personal finance management. The app is noted for its steady feature releases and effectiveness in daily finance tracking.

Avatar
63
7
42.9%
14.3%
7
63
42.9%
14.3%
Relevance

ShowMeMoney - See how much you really spend

23 Aug 2024 Personal Finance Artificial Intelligence Productivity

The expense tracker powered by OpenAI to help you save time and money. Stop wasting your time tracking your expenses and let AI do the legwork—see how much you spend in seconds.

ShowMeMoney's Product Hunt launch garnered excitement, with users highlighting the potential of AI-driven automation for efficient financial management, expense tracking, and budget control. A user inquired about the product's differentiation and features for college students. One commenter congratulated Matt on the launch while also pointing out a possible time issue.

Users question the product's differentiation from existing trackers and suggest UX improvements. A key criticism is the time-consuming process of pasting data, with users requesting a faster, more efficient method for data input.

Avatar
15
5
40.0%
5
15
40.0%
Relevance

ReceiptiX - AI-Powered Expense Tracking for Beginners

12 Aug 2024 Personal Finance Artificial Intelligence Productivity

Easily manage your finances with smart receipt scanning and automatic categorization. Just snap a photo of your receipt and let ReceiptiX do the rest. Supports all currencies. Perfect for beginners in personal finance and travelers.

The Product Hunt launch is receiving positive feedback, particularly for its beginner-friendly approach to financial management. Users express a strong need for the app, congratulating the team on its release. The AI-powered receipt capture feature is simplifying expense tracking and impressing users.

Avatar
17
3
33.3%
3
17
33.3%
Relevance

Rolly: AI Money Tracker - Makes expense tracking simpler and interesting with AI

15 Sep 2024 Android Personal Finance Money

Designed for convenience and accuracy, Rolly harnesses advanced AI technology to automatically record and categorize your expenses and income through simple, intuitive chat interactions.

Users find Rolly innovative and appreciate its unique bot for making expense tracking more engaging. A specific question was raised about whether the app automatically converts currencies when saving expenses.

Avatar
29
2
50.0%
2
29
50.0%
Relevance

Scanio - AI expense tracking - scan, track, and save

18 Oct 2024 Personal Finance Productivity Money

Scanio is your AI-powered expense tracker. Snap a photo or upload a receipt, and Scanio extracts key details instantly. Get monthly summaries, track your spending trends, and discover your highest and lowest expenses—all with no login required.

Users appreciate the AI-powered receipt scanning for saving time and simplifying expense tracking. The app's ease of use in scanning and tracking receipts makes it worthwhile.

Avatar
4
2
100.0%
2
4
100.0%
Relevance

Built an AI Money Tracker as Soloprenuer

13 Sep 2024 Personal Finance Artificial Intelligence Money

Hello everyone, I was always thinking about how I can increase my finances to get out of the rat race. Apart from increasing my income, the other approach I did is to reduce my expenses and hence I started my journey on expense tracking.I have tried a few apps and most of the time these apps are too complicated and I didn't manage to consistently key in my expense. Though there are some apps that provide link to bank account spending but I think that defeats the purpose of expense tracker since I believe only by manually input your spending in, only you'll be aware of your spending.This drives me to have a thought about how can I improve this and I decided to create my own app to make this work. I created Rolly: AI Money Tracker - a new AI expense tracker where you can easily record your transactions just by chatting with our bot Rolly and it will automatically record and categorise the transaction into the most suitable category (you can also create any of your own category and it will also take care of it in consideration). Demo video here. More features like budgeting are on the way, stay tuned!App Store: https://apps.apple.com/au/app/rolly-ai-money-tracker/id66365...Play Store: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.jc.rollymo...Anyone that have any feedback or needs for any new feature, do feel free to let me know and I'm happy to discuss and incorporate it. Thanks.

Cool app, AI seems angry, needs currency conversion.

AI seems angry, needs currency conversion.

Avatar
3
1
1
3
Relevance

Made an AI Money Tracker without any coding experience

28 Sep 2024 Personal Finance Artificial Intelligence Money

Hello everyone,I have created Rolly: AI Money Tracker - a new AI expense tracker where you can easily record your transactions just by chatting with our bot Rolly and it will automatically record and categorise the transaction into the most suitable category (you can also create any of your own category and it will also take care of it in consideration). You can always talk to the AI in any language and your transaction in any currency and it will always convert it into the base currency you've selected earlier. Rolly will also respond to your transaction in a interesting manner to make your expense tracker journey more interesting!App Store: https://apps.apple.com/au/app/rolly-ai-money-tracker/id66365...Play Store: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.jc.rollymo...Anyone that have any feedback or needs for any new feature, do feel free to let me know and I'm happy to discuss and incorporate it. Thanks.

Cool and terrifying. Local version for privacy?

Concern about privacy

Avatar
3
1
1
3
Relevance

Built a an Expense Tracker with Google Document AI and Claude 3 Haiku

01 Dec 2024 Productivity

Hi!More than 20-year backend dev here, trying to dive into mobile development and LLMs :-)I’ve always wanted to explore practical use cases for LLMs and I came up with ReceiptiX. It's a simple expense tracking mobile app. I'm trying to design it to be different from other complex budgeting apps by focusing on simplicity. The main idea is to minimize manual input involved in expense tracking.Main features: - Receipt scanning (this is where I started from) - Voice input - Telegram integration (you can send your expenses to a bot)The app is built with Flutter and Firebase. I use Google Document AI for OCR and then send the extracted text to Claude 3 Haiku for parsing and categorization. This is cheaper than giving an LLM an image as is.Right now I’m struggling a lot with traction. ASO is a nightmare :-) I think the niche I chose is very saturated, which was probably my biggest mistake. Still I want to keep going :-)Please try the app. It’s free for the first 5 receipts. You can even delete old receipts to stay under the 5-receipt limit and use the app for free indefinitely :-)

Avatar
3
3
Top