Should I Build It Should I Build It
22 Jul 2025
Artificial Intelligence

I wanto to build garden planner with ai assistance and it wil have ...

...chat and garden design editor

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Swamp

The market has seen several mediocre solutions that nobody loves. Unless you can offer something fundamentally different, you’ll likely struggle to stand out or make money.

Should You Build It?

Don't build it.

Your are here

You're entering a "Swamp" category, where many have tried and few have truly succeeded in the AI-assisted garden planning space. The existence of 10 similar products signals high competition. While an AI garden planner with chat and design editor sounds appealing, the challenge lies in offering something fundamentally different from the existing solutions. Most of these solutions have low engagement (avg of 3 comments), so it's safe to assume that the current offers out there are not addressing a specific need well enough. This means you'll need a laser focus on a niche within gardening or a game-changing feature to stand out. Before diving in, let's realistically assess why others haven't fully bloomed. Don't build it, unless you are absolutely certain you can address a true pain point or provide significant differentiation.

Recommendations

  1. Thoroughly research existing garden planning solutions, paying close attention to user reviews and identifying the pain points that current products fail to address. Analyze HomeGardenAI's feedback—users appreciate simplicity and plant identification, but accuracy and handling uncommon plants were concerns. Focus on how you can surpass these existing products.
  2. If you decide to proceed, identify a specific niche or group of gardeners you want to serve such as balcony gardeners, permaculture enthusiasts, or native plant advocates. Tailor the AI assistance and features to their unique needs. Think carefully about how you can incorporate community feedback into your product development process.
  3. Consider providing AI-powered tools for existing gardening providers (nurseries, landscapers) rather than directly competing with them. This could involve AI-driven plant recommendations for customers or automated design tools for landscaping professionals, creating a B2B revenue stream.
  4. Given the competitive landscape, explore adjacent problems in the broader gardening or landscaping space that might be more promising. Could you offer AI-powered soil analysis, pest and disease detection, or hyperlocal weather forecasting tailored to gardening needs?
  5. Focus on your AI's ability to accurately identify a wide range of plants, including uncommon species. Build a comprehensive database and incorporate user feedback to continuously improve the AI's accuracy and knowledge base. Address the criticism seen in similar products: ensure the plant identifications are not just accurate but also informative.
  6. Consider a freemium model where basic features are free, and advanced AI assistance and design capabilities are offered as a paid subscription. This allows users to experience the value of your product before committing financially.
  7. Given Yard AI's focus on visualization, prioritize creating a design editor that's intuitive and easy to use, even for non-designers. Offer a library of plants and landscape elements that users can drag and drop into their designs. Ensure the designs are not only visually appealing but also feasible from a horticultural perspective.
  8. Given the discussion around ArchitectAI being better than Google SketchUp, emphasize the ease of use and rapid design capabilities of your AI-powered editor. Clearly differentiate your product from existing design tools by showcasing its AI-driven features and benefits.

Questions

  1. How can you guarantee the AI's recommendations are tailored to specific microclimates and regional variations, avoiding generic advice that may not be applicable to all gardeners?
  2. What steps will you take to ensure that your AI's plant recommendations consider factors like soil type, sun exposure, and water availability, preventing users from selecting plants that are unsuitable for their garden conditions?
  3. Given the privacy concerns surrounding AI-powered tools, how will you ensure that user data (garden layouts, plant preferences, personal information) is protected and used responsibly?

Your are here

You're entering a "Swamp" category, where many have tried and few have truly succeeded in the AI-assisted garden planning space. The existence of 10 similar products signals high competition. While an AI garden planner with chat and design editor sounds appealing, the challenge lies in offering something fundamentally different from the existing solutions. Most of these solutions have low engagement (avg of 3 comments), so it's safe to assume that the current offers out there are not addressing a specific need well enough. This means you'll need a laser focus on a niche within gardening or a game-changing feature to stand out. Before diving in, let's realistically assess why others haven't fully bloomed. Don't build it, unless you are absolutely certain you can address a true pain point or provide significant differentiation.

Recommendations

  1. Thoroughly research existing garden planning solutions, paying close attention to user reviews and identifying the pain points that current products fail to address. Analyze HomeGardenAI's feedback—users appreciate simplicity and plant identification, but accuracy and handling uncommon plants were concerns. Focus on how you can surpass these existing products.
  2. If you decide to proceed, identify a specific niche or group of gardeners you want to serve such as balcony gardeners, permaculture enthusiasts, or native plant advocates. Tailor the AI assistance and features to their unique needs. Think carefully about how you can incorporate community feedback into your product development process.
  3. Consider providing AI-powered tools for existing gardening providers (nurseries, landscapers) rather than directly competing with them. This could involve AI-driven plant recommendations for customers or automated design tools for landscaping professionals, creating a B2B revenue stream.
  4. Given the competitive landscape, explore adjacent problems in the broader gardening or landscaping space that might be more promising. Could you offer AI-powered soil analysis, pest and disease detection, or hyperlocal weather forecasting tailored to gardening needs?
  5. Focus on your AI's ability to accurately identify a wide range of plants, including uncommon species. Build a comprehensive database and incorporate user feedback to continuously improve the AI's accuracy and knowledge base. Address the criticism seen in similar products: ensure the plant identifications are not just accurate but also informative.
  6. Consider a freemium model where basic features are free, and advanced AI assistance and design capabilities are offered as a paid subscription. This allows users to experience the value of your product before committing financially.
  7. Given Yard AI's focus on visualization, prioritize creating a design editor that's intuitive and easy to use, even for non-designers. Offer a library of plants and landscape elements that users can drag and drop into their designs. Ensure the designs are not only visually appealing but also feasible from a horticultural perspective.
  8. Given the discussion around ArchitectAI being better than Google SketchUp, emphasize the ease of use and rapid design capabilities of your AI-powered editor. Clearly differentiate your product from existing design tools by showcasing its AI-driven features and benefits.

Questions

  1. How can you guarantee the AI's recommendations are tailored to specific microclimates and regional variations, avoiding generic advice that may not be applicable to all gardeners?
  2. What steps will you take to ensure that your AI's plant recommendations consider factors like soil type, sun exposure, and water availability, preventing users from selecting plants that are unsuitable for their garden conditions?
  3. Given the privacy concerns surrounding AI-powered tools, how will you ensure that user data (garden layouts, plant preferences, personal information) is protected and used responsibly?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 10
  • Engagement: Low
    • Average number of comments: 3
  • Net use signal: 38.1%
    • Positive use signal: 38.1%
    • Negative use signal: 0.0%
  • Net buy signal: 0.0%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.0%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.0%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

AIGardenPlanner – AI-driven personalized planting recommendations

22 May 2023 Artificial Intelligence

Hello HN community, I'm excited to share a project that's been a labor of love for meAs an enthusiast in both tech and gardening, I often found it difficult to get the right guidance that would cater to my specific gardening conditions and personal preferences. Furthermore, living in a small country, localized gardening advice was hard to come by.That's when I thought - why not use technology to solve this? Thus, AIGardenPlanner was born - an online tool leveraging AI to provide tailored gardening advice. It simplifies gardening decisions about what to plant, when, and where, regardless of your geographical location. Whether you're a beginner or an experienced gardener, it's designed to guide you towards a flourishing garden.All you have to do is fill in a brief form about your gardening ambitions, preferences, and available space. The tool then generates a personalized plan suitable for your specific situation.We've launched a free version that you can try out. However, for those interested in more detailed reports, we have a Pro version as well.I believe this tool could be a great help for all gardening enthusiasts, and I'm eager to hear what the HN community thinks about it. Your feedback and suggestions will be invaluable in improving and growing this project.

Avatar
2
2
Relevance

HomeGardenAI - Transforming plant care with AI: your green thumb assistant

02 Aug 2024 Artificial Intelligence Home Automation Internet of Things

HomeGardenAI: Transform your home garden with smart plant care powered by AI. Diagnose plant diseases, receive personalized care recommendations, and maintain a thriving garden with ease.

HomeGarden AI is praised for simplifying plant care with its intuitive design, plant identification, and customized advice on watering and growth conditions. Users find the app helpful for both beginners and enthusiasts, appreciating features like the 'next watering' notification. The app's speed is noted as fantastic. Some users inquire about accuracy, handling uncommon plants, and integration with smart home systems. Overall, the launch is met with excitement and congratulations, with many believing garden enthusiasts will find the product valuable for improving plant health.

Users suggest feature enhancements like growth tracking and content sharing, and propose a progressive web app for direct image uploads. Concerns were raised about the app's accuracy, particularly for uncommon plants, with questions about data sources and testing. One experienced gardener found the plant identifications uninformative, possibly indicating a need to improve the app's database and identification capabilities to surpass existing solutions.

blankwebdev

Wow, @new_user___214202459a7ca68a600364b , this sounds like an incredible tool for gardening enthusiasts! The integration of AI to provide personalized care recommendations is definitely a game changer in the home gardening space. It’s awesome that it can diagnose plant diseases too—this will save so many plants from the brink! I'm really intrigued by the smart watering schedules concept as well; it's something so many of us struggle with. Have you considered adding a feature for tracking growth over time or perhaps user-generated content for sharing tips? Would love to see how HomeGardenAI can help community building as well. Excited to see this launch—wishing you tons of success on PH! Keep up the great work!

kathyyy6

I'm visiting my Mum this weekend and she's a keen gardener, so I tried this on a couple of her plants :) it identified them correctly (apparently) but didn't tell her anything she didn't already know... I suppose it's something beginner gardeners could really use. Mum said she could really use plant remedy suggestions for dying plants if the app could also find those products and order delivery:)

crebuh

@new_user___214202459a7ca68a600364b This is definitely what I need 🤣 When I get a new plant, I only need a few days or weeks and something is wrong 🙈. Would be nice if you could take advantage of progressive web apps so that users can take a picture of the plant directly instead of having to upload it from a notebook or phone. Congrats on the launch 🚀

tish_

This app looks like it will make keeping my plants healthy much simpler.

tariq_waseem

I love gardening, and this product is really helpful for me!

jayanthr

Congratulations on the launch. Mainly been using google lens for plant id a lot. Tried a bunch of apps but hey weren't very good. Yours seems to be more well thought out with the calendar and ideal growth conditions, will definitely give it a try. Thanks for the tool!

aruzhan_kubenova

fantastic tool for plant enthusiasts! app's intuitive interface and smart care tips make it easy to keep my plants healthy and happy. It's like having a gardening expert in my pocket!

sahirmaharaj

Congrats on the release, @new_user___214202459a7ca68a600364b ! The app’s speed is fantastic, and I can’t wait to see how it integrates with what I’m already using.

realrubyyyy

Great! Finally, I would have the courage to grow a plant LOL. Очень хорошо Upvoted!

roopreddy

Thanks team, HomeGardenAI has completely changed the way I care for my plants. I used to struggle with keeping them healthy, always guessing what they needed. But now, with AI-powered advice, it’s like I have a green thumb assistant guiding me every step of the way. My garden has never looked better!

Avatar
161
19
52.6%
19
161
52.6%
Relevance

Yard AI - Envision your dream yard. Your yard with pool, deck & more

30 Jan 2025 Outdoors Artificial Intelligence Home

Discover endless backyard ideas with Yard AI. From deck designs to small backyard landscaping, easily envision your dream outdoor space—no technical skills needed! Generate personalized backyard designs in seconds.

Tool helps interior designer visualize exterior spaces and brainstorm ideas.

Avatar
20
1
100.0%
1
20
100.0%
Relevance

ArchitectAI - AI instant makeover for your home

29 Jun 2023 Artificial Intelligence Interior design Home

ArchitectAI™ , world's first AI architecture + interior + landscape designer (all-in-one) transform photos and sketches to a new design style. Generate outstanding concepts. Visualise with stunning photo realism. Save time & money on design.

Users have reacted positively to the launch, with some calling it "fabulous" and "wonderful". It's considered better than existing solutions like Google SketchUp for flat design. There's interest in ensuring design quality and feasibility with ArchitectAI. One user promoted wikigpt3.com and offered a directory listing for the app, while another thanked the creator for sharing the interesting solution.

Avatar
92
6
6
92
Relevance

Gardin Genie - Your AI Gardening Companion

08 Jun 2024 Food & Drink Bots Messaging

Built during a hackathon, Garden Genie is a data-efficient chatbot on LINE that helps users grow their own food. It offers expert gardening advice, real-time weather, YouTube tutorials, and local resources, making gardening accessible to everyone.

Avatar
5
5
Top