Should I Build It Should I Build It
11 Apr 2025
Developer Tools

"Should I Build it” Idea Generator for Devs that can help

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Run Away

Multiple attempts have failed with clear negative feedback. Continuing down this path would likely waste your time and resources when better opportunities exist elsewhere.

Should You Build It?

Don't build it.

Your are here

You're venturing into the crowded space of "Should I Build It" idea generators, specifically tailored for developers. Our analysis reveals high competition (n_matches=25) in this area, indicating numerous attempts to solve a similar problem. Engagement, gauged by the average number of comments on similar products, is medium (avg n_comments=4), suggesting some level of interest but not widespread enthusiasm. Critically, there aren't enough signals for use or buy from the similar products, meaning these metrics are neutral. Based on all this, the category is "Run Away". There's a lot of noise and it's difficult to determine product-market fit. Don't build it unless you have a very specific and concrete reason for why your product is better than the existing ones.

Recommendations

  1. Carefully review the negative feedback from similar product launches. The discussion and criticism summaries highlight recurring issues such as accuracy and relevance of generated ideas, the perceived lack of unique value in GPT wrappers, and user skepticism regarding the effectiveness of AI in this domain. Understanding these pain points is crucial before proceeding.
  2. Consider whether your skills and insights could be applied to solve a related but different problem for developers. Perhaps focus on a specific niche within development where idea generation is particularly challenging, or pivot towards tools that aid in validating and refining existing ideas rather than generating them from scratch.
  3. If you've already developed a functional prototype, explore whether the underlying technology can be repurposed for a different application. Could the code be adapted to assist with debugging, code optimization, or documentation generation? Think about adjacent problems you can tackle more successfully.
  4. Conduct in-depth interviews with at least three developers who have used similar idea generation tools. Focus on understanding their specific needs, frustrations, and desired features. What are they actually struggling with, and how can your solution directly address those pain points?
  5. Based on your learnings, shift your focus to a new idea that addresses a more pressing need in the developer community. Prioritize solutions that offer tangible value, solve specific pain points, and differentiate themselves from existing tools. Consider offering your tool for free as an initial experiment to drive traffic, get feedback and signal, and measure its potential for success.
  6. Rethink your business model. The discussion summary suggests that users don't like email requirements. You could explore other ways to monetize the product such as targeted advertising or partnerships with relevant SaaS services.
  7. Consider specializing in a specific niche, such as AI, machine learning, or web3 development, where the need for innovative project ideas is high but the competition is more focused.

Questions

  1. Given the criticisms around the accuracy and relevance of AI-generated ideas, how will you ensure that your tool provides actionable and valuable suggestions that developers can realistically pursue?
  2. How will you differentiate your tool from existing solutions and address the concerns regarding the perceived lack of unique value in GPT wrappers? Are you leveraging proprietary data, algorithms, or methodologies that set your product apart?
  3. Considering the skepticism around the effectiveness of startup idea generator tools, what specific metrics will you use to measure the success of your product and demonstrate its value to developers? How will you iterate on your product based on user feedback and performance data?

Your are here

You're venturing into the crowded space of "Should I Build It" idea generators, specifically tailored for developers. Our analysis reveals high competition (n_matches=25) in this area, indicating numerous attempts to solve a similar problem. Engagement, gauged by the average number of comments on similar products, is medium (avg n_comments=4), suggesting some level of interest but not widespread enthusiasm. Critically, there aren't enough signals for use or buy from the similar products, meaning these metrics are neutral. Based on all this, the category is "Run Away". There's a lot of noise and it's difficult to determine product-market fit. Don't build it unless you have a very specific and concrete reason for why your product is better than the existing ones.

Recommendations

  1. Carefully review the negative feedback from similar product launches. The discussion and criticism summaries highlight recurring issues such as accuracy and relevance of generated ideas, the perceived lack of unique value in GPT wrappers, and user skepticism regarding the effectiveness of AI in this domain. Understanding these pain points is crucial before proceeding.
  2. Consider whether your skills and insights could be applied to solve a related but different problem for developers. Perhaps focus on a specific niche within development where idea generation is particularly challenging, or pivot towards tools that aid in validating and refining existing ideas rather than generating them from scratch.
  3. If you've already developed a functional prototype, explore whether the underlying technology can be repurposed for a different application. Could the code be adapted to assist with debugging, code optimization, or documentation generation? Think about adjacent problems you can tackle more successfully.
  4. Conduct in-depth interviews with at least three developers who have used similar idea generation tools. Focus on understanding their specific needs, frustrations, and desired features. What are they actually struggling with, and how can your solution directly address those pain points?
  5. Based on your learnings, shift your focus to a new idea that addresses a more pressing need in the developer community. Prioritize solutions that offer tangible value, solve specific pain points, and differentiate themselves from existing tools. Consider offering your tool for free as an initial experiment to drive traffic, get feedback and signal, and measure its potential for success.
  6. Rethink your business model. The discussion summary suggests that users don't like email requirements. You could explore other ways to monetize the product such as targeted advertising or partnerships with relevant SaaS services.
  7. Consider specializing in a specific niche, such as AI, machine learning, or web3 development, where the need for innovative project ideas is high but the competition is more focused.

Questions

  1. Given the criticisms around the accuracy and relevance of AI-generated ideas, how will you ensure that your tool provides actionable and valuable suggestions that developers can realistically pursue?
  2. How will you differentiate your tool from existing solutions and address the concerns regarding the perceived lack of unique value in GPT wrappers? Are you leveraging proprietary data, algorithms, or methodologies that set your product apart?
  3. Considering the skepticism around the effectiveness of startup idea generator tools, what specific metrics will you use to measure the success of your product and demonstrate its value to developers? How will you iterate on your product based on user feedback and performance data?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 25
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 4
  • Net use signal: -4.0%
    • Positive use signal: 7.8%
    • Negative use signal: 11.8%
  • Net buy signal: -8.4%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.0%
    • Negative buy signal: 8.4%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Built a SaaS Idea Generator to Find Unique, Non-Saturated Startup Ideas

09 Oct 2024 SaaS

I built a tool that helps you generate unique SaaS and Startups ideas based on your specific skills, knowledge, interests, and desired keywords/topics.Here's how it works: You input your expertise, what you're passionate about, and any specific areas you want to explore. You get tailored ideas as the generator analyzes your input and combines it with related market problems and requests to suggest relevant solutions.Each idea comes with a description of the problem to solve, use case example and marketing angles to help you validate and refine the concept.I built it because I was personally frustrated with the lack of tools for generating truly unique and viable SaaS ideas. Existing resources often felt generic and didn't consider my strengths and interests.Please give me your thoughts on things like idea quality, if you find generated ideas truly unique and potentially valuable, what additional features would be helpful for validating and developing these SaaS concepts, etc.Try it out and let me know what you think: https://maze.do/saas-ideasThanks,Eric

Avatar
3
3
Relevance

ideator.dev - Your new brainstorming assistant

28 Aug 2023 Artificial Intelligence SaaS Productivity

A powerful tool for generating high-quality, structured ideas for your next project or business. Just supply a seed idea, or let ideator generate one for you. Grow your idea into a full-fledged project using the AI-assisted idea tree.

The Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with users congratulating the team and praising the product's neat design, simplicity, and potential. Many users highlighted its effectiveness in generating AI-powered ideas. Suggestions for improvement included automation features, code snippet sharing, collaboration tools, expanded use cases, and personalized learning paths based on user skills and goals. The general sentiment indicates excitement and anticipation for the product's future development.

Users desire greater automation within the product. There are also suggestions for improvements to the features. Finally, the subscription-based pricing model has been mentioned as well.

Avatar
129
13
23.1%
13
129
23.1%
Relevance

IdeaPicker - Generates startup ideas with AI by scanning Reddit for pain

24 Apr 2024 Artificial Intelligence Business

I created this tool for myself, then wanted to make it public and free. IdeaPicker generates startup ideas by scanning Reddit conversations for pain points of people. 25000+ startup ideas generated from 250+ subreddit.

IdeaPicker's launch on Product Hunt is generating positive buzz. Users appreciate the AI-powered tool for generating startup ideas from Reddit and doing market research. One user specifically loves that it does research for them. Gratitude is expressed for keeping the product free. A query regarding the tool's relevancy and accuracy was raised, referencing subreddit pain points.

The primary criticism revolves around the accuracy and relevance of the startup ideas generated by the product. Users question whether the suggestions are practical or well-suited for the current market.

Avatar
20
5
20.0%
5
20
20.0%
Relevance

I built a SaaS idea generator that uses LLMs to generate business ideas

05 Sep 2024 SaaS

I got tired of folks complaining they couldn't think up a SaaS idea, so I whipped up a quick web page that generates 75 SaaS ideas per day.You can vote on your favorite, and each day's winner and loser will show up at the bottom of the page the next day. You can also sign up for the newsletter to get the ideas, winners and losers sent to your inbox for free!This was a fun couple hours of coding that honestly just served as a fun distraction from other projects. Let me know if you have any recommendations!(PS: the prompts for the AI models that generate the ideas will need some tweaking. That's what the voting system is for)

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

I built a 100% free startup idea generator

02 May 2024 Productivity

The comments reflect a mix of insights on startups, emphasizing the importance of people, the challenge of finding product-market fit, and the difficulty of execution over idea generation. There's skepticism about the effectiveness of startup idea generator tools, with some users questioning methods and others suggesting improvements like a problem generator tool. Positive feedback was given to concepts like HealthWealth Analytics and people-centric networking solutions. There's also mention of a humorous PlayStation 6 idea and a health app for rating poop photos, indicating a range of creative thinking.

Users criticized the Show HN product for copying ideas without success, overlooking the human aspect in business, and potentially exploiting people. There's skepticism about its effectiveness and market fit, with concerns about competition and solving non-issues. The payment system was noted as difficult, and the prioritization of people over protocols was unclear. Doubts were raised about its ability to generate profitable ideas, and it was seen as just a marketing tool. Healthcare startups were mentioned as needing more than what's offered.

Avatar
51
29
0.0%
-3.4%
29
51
6.9%
Relevance

A forum for sharing and discovering project ideas

23 Jun 2024 Productivity

It often happens that one has a brilliant idea for a project, but not the willpower and personal alignment to bring it to life. There's plenty of lists online that evidence this (for example, [1], [2], and [3]).It also often happens that when one does venture out to find ideas to pursue that would fit well with them, one finds none. Good ideas are drowned amidst the million other discussions on social media. Some ideas take too long, some don't arouse enough interest, and others are just... outdated. Hence the flood of people building things that already exist, doing things that even they themselves know won't make a real difference in the world.I've built a solution: a forum exclusively dedicated for project ideas. Share things you want to see happen in the world, discover things you actually want to do. For now, there's just some handy filters and features, with more to come as the number of ideas grows. What do you think?PS: I'm also reachable via email: ys2256[at]cornell[dot]edu[1]: https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/K5R35pgPFk3DcGyRp/... [2]: https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/MsNpJBzv5YhdfNHc9/... [3]: https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/9AEEqDR8zcQv2XmsB/...

Interesting!

Avatar
5
1
1
5
Relevance

I made a tool to help collect and validate startup ideas

14 Aug 2024 Artificial Intelligence Productivity

Hey HN, I’m Kyrylo. I recently created a small tool that lets you gather, refine, and validate SaaS/startup ideas using AI. I used to jot down my product ideas in a note apps, but it wasn’t very practical for collecting feedback or refining them. So, I built this tool to make the process easier.Here’s how it works:1. Enter a brief description of your idea. 2. The app uses AI to generate project details. 3. Share your idea via a link that includes a feedback form.It’s pretty straightforward, and I’d love to hear your thoughts or any suggestions!

Users commented on a variety of Show HN products/services, from FuneralDash for funeral planning to WeatherBet for weather betting. Some expressed skepticism about AI and preferred human validation or existing tools like Google Docs. There were concerns about age limitations, licensing, and the effectiveness of some ideas. Innovative concepts like Antimatter warp engines and video conferencing toilets were mentioned, as well as a crowdfunding platform for political lobbying. Users also discussed the potential of IdeaCapturePro and AdPaw Hat for monetization. The landing page and Pieter Levels were praised, while some comments were sarcastic or protective of their ideas.

Users expressed skepticism about AI's effectiveness for the service, likened it to Google Docs, and questioned its originality and clarity in solving problems. Concerns about idea theft, arbitrary restrictions, and the platform's tone were noted. The 'world domination' goal was criticized as unclear and inappropriate. Users found the Q&A format unsuitable for brainstorming and were puzzled by the public nature of the platform. Criticisms also included a lack of features, differentiation, and creativity, as well as issues with idea rejection and selection criteria. The sign-up process was faulted for not saving initial ideas.

Avatar
38
32
-25.0%
-18.8%
32
38
3.1%
Relevance

AI Project Specification Generator

31 Aug 2023 Design Tools Artificial Intelligence

AI project specification generator. Suggests a specification and helps to choose a tool to build the projectNo registration, no lead form, no ads. Curious to hear your thoughts

Users have mixed reactions to the product. Some suggest improvements like threaded chat, faster responses, and a better description generator. Others question the necessity of a non-GPT wrapper. There are concerns about AI taking over jobs, while some find the tool useful for project management. One user feels the comment section is inactive.

Users criticized the description generator for being unhelpful and slow in its responses. They questioned the necessity of using a non-GPT wrapper and expressed concerns about AI taking over jobs.

Avatar
10
5
0.0%
-20.0%
5
10
20.0%
Relevance

Innovatize – AI Startup Idea Generator

05 Apr 2024 Artificial Intelligence

Ever wanted to create a startup but couldn't think of an idea? I'm doing a test launch for part of my MVP and would really appreciate any feedback, or if you could join my discord server: https://discord.gg/s9GtVNx7hfI'm a 16 year old entrepreneur with the goal of making startups easier to make for others.

Users suggest improving the value proposition for lead generation. There is criticism regarding the email requirement at the end, with some finding it unclassy and others simply noting it as an email grab. One user had an indifferent reaction.

The main criticisms are that the GPT wrapper lacks unique value, the requirement to provide an email is seen as unclassy and an email grab, and overall, users are unimpressed with the product.

Avatar
8
4
-25.0%
-25.0%
4
8
Relevance

I made a tool to help collect and validate SaaS ideas

13 Aug 2024 Artificial Intelligence SaaS Productivity

Hey HN, I’m Kyrylo. I recently created a small tool that lets you gather, refine, and validate SaaS/startup ideas using AI.I used to jot down my product ideas in a note apps, but it wasn’t very practical for collecting feedback or refining them. So, I built this tool to make the process easier.Here’s how it works:1. Enter a brief description of your idea. 2. The app uses AI to generate project details. 3. Share your idea via a link that includes a feedback form.It’s pretty straightforward, and I’d love to hear your thoughts or any suggestions!

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Idea Spark - The ultimate resource for brainstorming and idea generation

06 Jan 2023 User Experience Productivity Marketing

Interactive template with scientifically proven exercises will help you generate new and innovative ideas for any project. With prompts and exercises like freewriting, word association and the "What if?" game, you'll never run out of ideas.

The user expresses initial positive sentiment, indicated by liking the product. They mention needing brainstorming to address blank page paralysis, suggesting a need for tools or features that facilitate idea generation and overcome creative blocks.

Avatar
94
2
50.0%
2
94
50.0%
Relevance

I made an AI-powered idea tracker to validate your projects early

12 Aug 2024 Artificial Intelligence

Hey HN, I'm Kyrylo, a solo indie developer.Backstory: I recently spent two years working on a project that gained me zero users because I didn’t gather enough early feedback during the idea phase.That experience inspired me to create "Keep My Idea" — an AI-powered tool to help collect, refine, and validate your future project ideas before development.Here’s how it works: 1. Enter a brief description of your idea. 2. The app uses AI to generate basic project details. 3. Share the generated link with built-in feedback form.I’d love to hear your thoughts and feedback. Thanks for checking it out!

Avatar
5
5
Top