Act the app as a time jar, you spending to app and it tracking and ...

...monitor it for you

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Competitive Terrain

While there's clear interest in your idea, the market is saturated with similar offerings. To succeed, your product needs to stand out by offering something unique that competitors aren't providing. The challenge here isn’t whether there’s demand, but how you can capture attention and keep it.

Should You Build It?

Not before thinking deeply about differentiation.


Your are here

Your idea of an app that acts as a "time jar," tracking and monitoring your spending habits, falls into the 'Competitive Terrain' category. This means there's already a significant number of similar time-tracking and productivity apps on the market (n_matches=28, signifying high confidence but also high competition). While there isn't explicit use or buy feedback available, the average engagement on similar products is medium (avg n_comments = 9), indicating that there is user interest in such applications. Therefore, to succeed, your app needs a unique angle that sets it apart from the competition. The critical question is: what will make users choose your app over the many others already available?

Recommendations

  1. Begin with thorough market research. Analyze existing time-tracking apps to identify their strengths and weaknesses. Focus on user reviews and feedback (like the summaries provided from similar product launches) to pinpoint unmet needs or pain points within the current solutions.
  2. Based on your market research, pinpoint a niche or unique feature that differentiates your app. Could it be a specific integration, a unique visualization of spending habits, or a focus on a particular user group (e.g., freelancers, students)? Consider incorporating elements like goal-setting, as users often request this in time-tracking apps.
  3. Prioritize a user-friendly design and intuitive interface. Many similar apps receive criticism for being too complex or having a busy UI (as seen in the 'timing.is' criticisms). Strive for simplicity and ease of use, perhaps inspired by the praised minimal design of 'Trace'.
  4. Develop a clear value proposition that resonates with your target audience. What problem does your app solve better than existing solutions? Address concerns about data privacy and security, as highlighted in criticisms of apps like 'Time Tag', especially if you implement a no-sign-up feature.
  5. Start with a Minimum Viable Product (MVP) that showcases your core differentiation. Launch it to a small group of target users and gather feedback. Iterate quickly based on their input, focusing on the features that provide the most value and address their specific needs.
  6. Pay close attention to the subscription model, the similar products' launch discussions highlight auto-subscription requirements, so ensure transparent pricing. Consider a freemium model with clear benefits for paying users to encourage upgrades (integration with other apps or more advanced features).
  7. Plan for cross-platform availability, starting with iOS and adding an Android version as soon as possible. Many similar apps receive requests for Android versions, indicating a significant potential user base on that platform.

Questions

  1. Given the existing concerns about data privacy in similar apps, how will your app ensure user data is secure and protected, particularly if you're considering a 'no-sign-up' approach?
  2. Considering the feedback on manual time tracking being a hurdle, how can you automate the time tracking process or make it more seamless and less intrusive for the user?
  3. With the market saturated with time-tracking apps, what specific user segment or niche will your app target to establish a strong foothold and differentiate itself from the competition?

Your are here

Your idea of an app that acts as a "time jar," tracking and monitoring your spending habits, falls into the 'Competitive Terrain' category. This means there's already a significant number of similar time-tracking and productivity apps on the market (n_matches=28, signifying high confidence but also high competition). While there isn't explicit use or buy feedback available, the average engagement on similar products is medium (avg n_comments = 9), indicating that there is user interest in such applications. Therefore, to succeed, your app needs a unique angle that sets it apart from the competition. The critical question is: what will make users choose your app over the many others already available?

Recommendations

  1. Begin with thorough market research. Analyze existing time-tracking apps to identify their strengths and weaknesses. Focus on user reviews and feedback (like the summaries provided from similar product launches) to pinpoint unmet needs or pain points within the current solutions.
  2. Based on your market research, pinpoint a niche or unique feature that differentiates your app. Could it be a specific integration, a unique visualization of spending habits, or a focus on a particular user group (e.g., freelancers, students)? Consider incorporating elements like goal-setting, as users often request this in time-tracking apps.
  3. Prioritize a user-friendly design and intuitive interface. Many similar apps receive criticism for being too complex or having a busy UI (as seen in the 'timing.is' criticisms). Strive for simplicity and ease of use, perhaps inspired by the praised minimal design of 'Trace'.
  4. Develop a clear value proposition that resonates with your target audience. What problem does your app solve better than existing solutions? Address concerns about data privacy and security, as highlighted in criticisms of apps like 'Time Tag', especially if you implement a no-sign-up feature.
  5. Start with a Minimum Viable Product (MVP) that showcases your core differentiation. Launch it to a small group of target users and gather feedback. Iterate quickly based on their input, focusing on the features that provide the most value and address their specific needs.
  6. Pay close attention to the subscription model, the similar products' launch discussions highlight auto-subscription requirements, so ensure transparent pricing. Consider a freemium model with clear benefits for paying users to encourage upgrades (integration with other apps or more advanced features).
  7. Plan for cross-platform availability, starting with iOS and adding an Android version as soon as possible. Many similar apps receive requests for Android versions, indicating a significant potential user base on that platform.

Questions

  1. Given the existing concerns about data privacy in similar apps, how will your app ensure user data is secure and protected, particularly if you're considering a 'no-sign-up' approach?
  2. Considering the feedback on manual time tracking being a hurdle, how can you automate the time tracking process or make it more seamless and less intrusive for the user?
  3. With the market saturated with time-tracking apps, what specific user segment or niche will your app target to establish a strong foothold and differentiate itself from the competition?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 28
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 9
  • Net use signal: 22.8%
    • Positive use signal: 23.8%
    • Negative use signal: 1.0%
  • Net buy signal: 0.0%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.8%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.7%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Trace - A time tracker that visualizes your app activity

Trace is a time-tracking app that helps you understand how you spend your time. It monitors your device activity and presents a color-coded & easy-to-digest timeline of your app usage.

Trace's Product Hunt launch garnered positive feedback, with users praising its minimal design, color-coded timeline, and focus on privacy. Many highlighted its usefulness for time management, understanding app usage, and enhancing productivity. Users inquired about features like excluding apps/time, goal-setting, browser tracking, timeline customization, and system performance impact. There were requests for a Windows version and the ability to hide the timer. Several users lauded the app's sleek design and intuitive timeline, with excitement expressed for the daily/monthly overview it provides.

Users expressed concerns about system performance and privacy. Feature requests include alerts/reminders, customizable color-coded timelines and views, session renaming, and the ability to track other apps. There's a desire for a Windows version in addition to the Mac version. Users are also curious about local storage motivation and future feature handling, and suggest gamification and a mobile app version.


Avatar
235
31
35.5%
31
235
35.5%
Relevance

actiTIME Time Management Assistant - Extension to take back control of your time

Track all your online activities automatically to see exactly how much time you spend on each platform, see where your time truly goes and optimize your day for peak efficiency

Several users congratulated the launch of actiTIME Time Management Assistant and expressed interest in trying it. One user highlighted the tool's automatic tracking feature for identifying time drains and suggested adding goal-setting functionality. A marketer recognized the tool as a valuable asset for staying ahead.

The primary criticism revolves around the absence of a goal-setting feature to aid in time management. Users suggest integrating this functionality to enhance the product's utility.


Avatar
28
7
42.9%
7
28
42.9%
Relevance

SaveMyTime for iOS - Track time effortlessly and get rid of wasted time

SaveMyTime is a one-click time tracking app that helps you to be aware of how time is being spent, get rid of wasted time, and save it for what is important to you. Now also available for iPhone, with the ability to track directly from the Lock/Home Screen.

Users are overwhelmingly positive about the iOS launch of the SaveMyTime app. Several users congratulated the team and Pawel, specifically praising the clever implementation of hijacking the locked screen. Long-time users appreciate the app's ability to optimize habits and its ease of use. Many highlight the app's contribution to improved productivity by understanding time usage. Overall, the comments convey excitement and satisfaction with the iOS version of this time-tracking app.

The primary criticism is that the product's perceived quality and design don't align with its potential, leading to a perception of being cheap or underdeveloped. This suggests a need for improvements in aesthetics and user experience to better match the product's capabilities and market expectations.


Avatar
79
8
37.5%
12.5%
8
79
37.5%
12.5%
Relevance

AppTimer an open source tool to limit app usage and boost productivity

27 Aug 2024 Productivity

Hi HN, I’ve created AppTimer, a simple cli tool made to help you manage your time more effectively by limiting how long you use specific applications. If you’ve ever found yourself losing track of time while using an app or want to improve your focus during work, this might be helpful for you.Features:- Launch any application from the CLI and set a time limit. - Automatically terminates the application after the specified time. - Simple and lightweight, built with Go.Use Cases- Curbing screen time addiction by setting limits on entertainment apps. - Enhancing focus by controlling distractions during work hours.I’d love to hear your feedback, suggestions, or ideas for improvement. Contributions are also welcome This is my first ever solo project so help would be reallyyy appreciated

Improve GitHub, add homepage, Twitter. AppTimer not a big hit.

AppTimer not a big hit.


Avatar
2
1
-100.0%
-100.0%
1
2
Relevance

ScreenTime+ - Automatic time tracking app for mac

ScreenTime+ is a productivity app designed for Mac users running macOS 13.0 or later. It automatically tracks and analyzes how you spend your time on your computer, providing valuable insights to help you optimize your productivity.

ScreenTime+ is a helpful Mac app for tracking and analyzing computer usage to boost productivity. Users appreciate its value as a self-monitoring tool, particularly the long-term usage history tracking feature. The general sentiment is positive, with users expressing thanks.


Avatar
19
4
25.0%
25.0%
4
19
25.0%
25.0%
Relevance

TimeStamp - Time Tracking App

TimeStamp ⏳ is a versatile time tracker app that lets you create timers to monitor your habits, addictions, or general time management. You can log relapses, view detailed statistics 📊, and gain insights into your progress—all without any ads 🚫.

The Product Hunt launch received congratulations from users. Shubham was specifically mentioned in the positive feedback.


Avatar
2
2
2
2
Relevance

Hours Tracker - Minimal time tracker iOS app to improve your focus

With one click you can start an activity timer or explore your activity's overview & get a report of the time spent on every activity, for the current day, last 7 days, or last month

The Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback. Users congratulated the team on the launch and praised the product's concept, execution, and impressive features. Many expressed excitement to try it out, highlighting its potential usefulness for creators and activity management. The landing page design and user interface also received commendation, along with the overall realistic approach of the product. Several users indicated they needed such a tool and expressed appreciation for the team's work.

The primary criticism is that the product is perceived as overly realistic. This suggests that users may find the product unsettling or lacking the desired level of abstraction or stylization.


Avatar
108
23
17.4%
23
108
17.4%
Relevance

We created Pomodoro and Infinite Time-Tracker in one app

Hey, HN!Today we are happy to share with you our project - a time management app called TRACKERUS, which will help you to be productive all day long.With Trackerus: → Switch between Pomodoro & Infinite modes in 1 tap → Track & focus without distractions with Minimalistic design → Analyse Statistics by Periods or Tasks → Prepare invoices based on your Statistics pageGot any questions, feedback, or feature requests? We're all ears!Let's become productive together!Best wishes, Product Designer Rustam & Flutter Developer Vladislav


Avatar
3
3
Relevance

timing.is - A next gen personal time management app for iOS

A next-generation personal time management tool focusing on hyper-customization, insights and reflection.

The Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with many users congratulating the team. Users praised the app's UI details, animations, simplicity, and integrative features for calendar management. Long-time users highlighted the improved UX and smooth experience. Several users expressed excitement about future releases and new features. Some users requested an Android version and inquired about time tracking/analysis capabilities. One user suggested adding a mental health category. While predominantly positive, one user felt the UI was busy and needed cleanup.

Users criticize the product's busy UI, suggesting it needs simplification. The lack of an Android version is also a point of concern. One user, despite acknowledging the product's power, mentioned still seeking alternatives, implying potential usability or feature gaps.


Avatar
238
29
31.0%
29
238
31.0%
Relevance

TimeWise - Discover your phone usage story

19 Dec 2024 Android Productivity

Your ultimate digital well-being companion, designed to help you reflect on your phone habits over the past year. Inspired by the concept of yearly recaps, this app provides a unique, engaging, and insightful look at how you’ve spent time on your device


Avatar
11
11
Relevance

Minute - Open source time tracking app for individuals

Minute is an open-source time tracking app designed for personal use, helping you increase meaningful time and reduce less meaningful time. Organize your tracked time with a folder structure, and create charts to see if your time is being used ideally.

Minute's Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with users praising its straightforward design, folder structure, and time analysis features. Many highlighted its usefulness for personal time tracking, time management, and increasing productivity. The open-source nature and uncluttered interface were also frequently commended. Users expressed interest in mobile app availability, data visualization, integrations, local persistent storage, and task prioritization tips. Some users asked about goal setting and requested assistance accessing the git repository. Several users congratulated the team on the launch and wished them good luck.

Users are requesting a mobile app and pre-set templates to improve the initial user experience. Some users are also seeking calendar integration and goal-setting features to enhance productivity. A major pain point is the inability to access private repositories due to permission issues. Additionally, some users express dissatisfaction with the new time tracking functionality.


Avatar
344
31
41.9%
31
344
41.9%
Relevance

Heydai - Know where your time goes

Daily planner & time tracker with a touch of AI

Users express positive feedback on Heydai's launch, praising its simplicity, UI, and potential for time and priority management. Many congratulate the team and express excitement to use the app. Key interests include the availability of an Android version, AI personalization, and integrations with platforms like Google Calendar, Notion, and JIRA. Some users find the signup process frustrating due to mandatory auto-subscription. Suggestions include automatic activity monitoring, quick add/log features, and converting content into day plans. The history visualization is appreciated, but manual tracking is seen as a hurdle.

Users criticize the manual recording process and request automatic monitoring, similar to competitors. Several users find the design misleading regarding the auto-subscription requirement. There is a demand for an Android version and integrations with tools like Trello or Asana to avoid manually re-entering tasks. The site also needs more detail before signup, quick add and log features for reduced friction, and consideration for behavior change challenges through user segmentation.


Avatar
269
42
19.0%
-2.4%
42
269
21.4%
Relevance

Turnip - Time tracking for freelancers

Reclaim your time with the time tracking app designed for freelancers and small businesses. Turnip makes it easy to track your time as you work, and automatically syncs with the services you already use.

Turnip is receiving positive feedback for its ability to simplify tasks, particularly time tracking for freelancers and small businesses. Users praise its minimalist design, flawless syncing, and potential to prevent burnout. The app is described as a game-changer and a life-saver for hourly billing, addressing specific needs of freelancers. There's interest in the app's UI, integrations, and future expansion. Users are sharing the app with their freelancer networks and congratulating the developers on a successful launch.

The main criticism revolves around the product's integration capabilities with commonly used daily tools. Users are questioning the extent and seamlessness of these integrations, implying a potential gap in functionality or compatibility that needs to be addressed. The absence of strong integration may hinder adoption.


Avatar
187
16
18.8%
16
187
18.8%
Relevance

Paymo Track - Automatically track and register time spent on desktop apps

Paymo Track is a complete time-tracking solution for your MAC, Windows, or Linux computer. It offers a stopwatch, an automatic tracker, and a Pomodoro timer. The tracked time can be linked to your tasks and registered in your daily timesheet.

Paymo's Product Hunt launch received numerous congratulations. Users highlighted its helpfulness for hourly/remote job seekers and praised it as a cool and amazing personal productivity tool. The automated tracking feature was specifically mentioned as exciting. Positive feedback included its ease of use, clean UI, and comprehensive features such as time tracking, project management, invoicing, and expense tracking, with the added benefit of Linux support. One user inquired about its unique value proposition compared to existing Mac features.

The main criticism is the lack of clear differentiation from existing Mac features. Users need a better understanding of the tool's unique value proposition compared to functionalities already available on macOS.


Avatar
120
9
66.7%
9
120
66.7%
Relevance

Time Tag - Simple time tracking: Tag, filter, and analyze your day,

Effortlessly track time with tags and notes. Filter blocks, view totals, and export data. No sign-up required—data stays local. Sync across devices optional. Made by a solo developer to solve real pain points.

Users are inquiring about Time Tag's features, particularly syncing across devices, project management, collaboration, and integration with other productivity tools. There are concerns about data security and reliability due to the no-sign-up feature. Some users find the tool basic but useful for personal time tracking. Others suggest improvements like customization, voice command, and gamification. The app's ability to track time on specific apps or pages is also of interest. Data privacy is a recurring concern, along with the need for integration with existing workflows.

Users criticize the app for being too basic, lacking essential features like collaboration, integrations with other productivity tools, and app/web page tracking. Concerns about security, data privacy, and reliability, particularly given the solo developer status, are prominent. Doubts exist about whether the app solves new problems and offers sufficient value compared to existing time tracking solutions. Questions about data syncing between devices and the absence of a signup process raise additional worries.


Avatar
122
13
7.7%
13
122
15.4%
Relevance

Activity Journey - Simple activity tracking app that enhances your daily life.

Track, earn, and transform with ease! Our app makes it simple to monitor your daily activities, earn rewards, and track your journey to self-improvement. Make every day count towards becoming your best self!

The app is appreciated for its custom rewards system, which makes self-improvement more achievable and enjoyable for users. Additionally, the app's clean interface was commended. Congratulations were offered for the launch.


Avatar
15
3
33.3%
3
15
33.3%
Relevance

Habit Tracker: Daily routine - Privacy focus app to build habits and achieve your goals

16 Feb 2024 Health iOS Productivity

Habit Tracker aims to be an easy-to-use app iOS, macOS and watchOS without a lot of frills. It has the essential information you need to track your progress and reach your goals. In just a few steps it allows you to create a new habit and mark your progress.

The Product Hunt launch is receiving positive feedback, with users expressing excitement and offering support. A key highlight is the update from live widgets being a game-changer. A recurring request is for an Android version of the app. Several users wished the launch good luck and asked for support in return.

The Product Hunt launch faces criticism for implicitly expecting reciprocal support, which is perceived as transactional. Users are also requesting an Android version, highlighting the platform's current unavailability on Android devices.


Avatar
81
5
20.0%
5
81
20.0%
Relevance

Analytics for Your Life

Notification based tracking app I've been working on.Lets you track whatever you want by responding directly to the notification, on your phone or watch.Also provides general analytics and measures experiments effects (how do time periods with new behaviors affect your tracking).Have been using it myself for a while now, and will soon post further about my own learnings from it.

Users commented on a notification-based tracking app, showing interest in its appearance and functionality. One user inquired about data export capabilities, while another sought a comparison with the Daylio app, which was noted to have all the mentioned features. The overall reaction was positive, with compliments on the app's aesthetics.

Users noted the lack of an export feature and identified areas where the app could be improved.


Avatar
9
6
16.7%
6
9
16.7%
Relevance

Boring - Daily habit tracker, yet so simple

16 Jan 2023 Lifestyle

Boring app that helps you track and record your daily activities and habits. You just need to select the content and complete the record, everything is designed and experienced for your convenience.

The product launch was met with congratulations and positive feedback, especially regarding the habit tracker's design. Users appreciated the timeline visualization. A common request was for the addition of reminders. Some users found the new activity creation process challenging, suggesting a need for onboarding improvements. The logo was also well-received.

Users criticized the product launch for having a challenging and non-obvious process for creating a new activity type.


Avatar
89
4
25.0%
4
89
25.0%
Relevance

Habit-tracking app with GitHub-style grids

24 Jul 2024 Productivity

Hi HN! After ~9 months of development, I published my very first app to the App Store. It's called Checker, a habit/goal-tracking app that uses GitHub-style calendar grids to visualize your progress. It's relatively simple for now but I'll be adding quite a few features in the coming months, like board color themes, Apple Health integration, more widget styles, etc.Hope you give it a try, and if you do, please let me know if you have any feedback.

Users appreciate the product's beauty and are curious about its inspiration from Github. They are also inquiring about the availability of an Android version and whether the app operates locally or on the cloud.


Avatar
11
2
50.0%
2
11
50.0%
Top