Should I Build It Should I Build It
02 Jun 2025
Security

32. Dark Web Leak Scanner for SMBs User enters domains, emails, or ...

...keywords. The tool scrapes known leak sites, marketplaces, and Telegram channels to find compromised credentials or mentions of their brand. Target Users: Small security-conscious orgs, solopreneurs Why It’s Underserved: Most breach detection is either DIY or very enterprise-level.

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Freemium

People love using similar products but resist paying. You’ll need to either find who will pay or create additional value that’s worth paying for.

Should You Build It?

Build but think about differentiation and monetization.

Your are here

You're entering a market with a moderate amount of competition (n_matches = 11) in the "Freemium" category. This means many similar products exist, indicating there's a need, but also that differentiation and monetization are key challenges. The category description suggests that users appreciate these types of tools but are often hesitant to pay for them upfront. Since we don't have use/buy signals for similar products, you'll need to carefully identify how you can provide real value in the free version while motivating users to upgrade. The engagement is medium (avg n_comments = 4), implying reasonable user interest, but it is still crucial to address concerns around security, privacy, and ease of use, as reflected in the discussions around competitor products. A critical aspect, as pointed out by competitors, is avoiding the unintentional exposure of sensitive data during scanning.

Recommendations

  1. Begin by offering a genuinely useful free tier that provides tangible value. Focus the free version on a limited number of scans or a subset of features to attract a broad user base while preserving premium features for paying customers. Emphasize the value and peace of mind that the scanner provides, positioning it as an essential tool rather than a nice-to-have.
  2. Identify which users derive the most benefit from the free version. Analyze usage patterns and gather feedback to understand their specific needs and pain points. This will inform the development of premium features tailored to those users' specific workflows, justifying the upgrade.
  3. Develop premium features that significantly enhance the value proposition for SMBs. This could include more comprehensive scanning, faster results, priority support, historical data analysis, or integration with other security tools. Consider features like compliance reporting or automated remediation suggestions.
  4. Explore offering team-based pricing instead of individual subscriptions. SMBs often have multiple employees who need access to security tools, making a team-based model more attractive and easier to justify the cost. Position the scanner as a collaborative security solution for the entire organization.
  5. Offer personalized onboarding, training, or consulting services as a premium add-on. Some SMBs may lack the internal expertise to effectively utilize the scanner and interpret the results. Providing expert guidance can increase the value and stickiness of the product.
  6. Implement robust security measures to protect user data and prevent accidental exposure of sensitive information. Focus on data anonymization, encryption, and secure storage practices. Be transparent about your security protocols and obtain relevant certifications to build trust with users. Address concerns proactively, as highlighted by negative feedback related to similar tools.
  7. Address common user concerns by providing detailed error messages, clear documentation, and responsive customer support. Ensure the tool is easy to use and understand, even for non-technical users. Consider adding features for automation, like report generation.
  8. Test different pricing strategies with small groups of users before implementing them across the board. Experiment with various price points, feature bundles, and subscription models to find the optimal balance between revenue and user adoption.

Questions

  1. Given the security concerns around similar products, how will you ensure the tool itself doesn't become a source of leaks or vulnerabilities for your users, and what proactive steps will you take to communicate your security measures?
  2. Considering the freemium model, what specific metrics will you track to identify users most likely to convert to paying customers, and how will you personalize the upgrade path to address their unique needs?
  3. How will you differentiate your leak scanner from existing solutions, especially in terms of accuracy, speed, and ease of use for SMBs, who may have limited technical expertise?

Your are here

You're entering a market with a moderate amount of competition (n_matches = 11) in the "Freemium" category. This means many similar products exist, indicating there's a need, but also that differentiation and monetization are key challenges. The category description suggests that users appreciate these types of tools but are often hesitant to pay for them upfront. Since we don't have use/buy signals for similar products, you'll need to carefully identify how you can provide real value in the free version while motivating users to upgrade. The engagement is medium (avg n_comments = 4), implying reasonable user interest, but it is still crucial to address concerns around security, privacy, and ease of use, as reflected in the discussions around competitor products. A critical aspect, as pointed out by competitors, is avoiding the unintentional exposure of sensitive data during scanning.

Recommendations

  1. Begin by offering a genuinely useful free tier that provides tangible value. Focus the free version on a limited number of scans or a subset of features to attract a broad user base while preserving premium features for paying customers. Emphasize the value and peace of mind that the scanner provides, positioning it as an essential tool rather than a nice-to-have.
  2. Identify which users derive the most benefit from the free version. Analyze usage patterns and gather feedback to understand their specific needs and pain points. This will inform the development of premium features tailored to those users' specific workflows, justifying the upgrade.
  3. Develop premium features that significantly enhance the value proposition for SMBs. This could include more comprehensive scanning, faster results, priority support, historical data analysis, or integration with other security tools. Consider features like compliance reporting or automated remediation suggestions.
  4. Explore offering team-based pricing instead of individual subscriptions. SMBs often have multiple employees who need access to security tools, making a team-based model more attractive and easier to justify the cost. Position the scanner as a collaborative security solution for the entire organization.
  5. Offer personalized onboarding, training, or consulting services as a premium add-on. Some SMBs may lack the internal expertise to effectively utilize the scanner and interpret the results. Providing expert guidance can increase the value and stickiness of the product.
  6. Implement robust security measures to protect user data and prevent accidental exposure of sensitive information. Focus on data anonymization, encryption, and secure storage practices. Be transparent about your security protocols and obtain relevant certifications to build trust with users. Address concerns proactively, as highlighted by negative feedback related to similar tools.
  7. Address common user concerns by providing detailed error messages, clear documentation, and responsive customer support. Ensure the tool is easy to use and understand, even for non-technical users. Consider adding features for automation, like report generation.
  8. Test different pricing strategies with small groups of users before implementing them across the board. Experiment with various price points, feature bundles, and subscription models to find the optimal balance between revenue and user adoption.

Questions

  1. Given the security concerns around similar products, how will you ensure the tool itself doesn't become a source of leaks or vulnerabilities for your users, and what proactive steps will you take to communicate your security measures?
  2. Considering the freemium model, what specific metrics will you track to identify users most likely to convert to paying customers, and how will you personalize the upgrade path to address their unique needs?
  3. How will you differentiate your leak scanner from existing solutions, especially in terms of accuracy, speed, and ease of use for SMBs, who may have limited technical expertise?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 11
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 4
  • Net use signal: 5.0%
    • Positive use signal: 11.0%
    • Negative use signal: 6.0%
  • Net buy signal: 0.0%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.0%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.0%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Vuxep - Know where your data is leaked and which passwords to change

28 Jul 2024 Data Privacy Security

Vuxep is an automatic crawler of the Dark Web, Hacking forums and Telegram groups, Looking for stealer log leaked data, Unlike database breaches, stealer logs data also contains Urls (websites) in addition of the Usernames / Emails & Passwords.

The Product Hunt launch received positive feedback, with users congratulating the team, particularly @its_ophen, on launching Vuxep. The cybersecurity project, focusing on Dark Web monitoring, was considered impressive, with special mention of the free email leak check feature. One user expressed excitement about Vuxep enhancing cybersecurity, while another thanked the team for building the product and requested more details on the report.

Avatar
108
5
40.0%
5
108
40.0%
Relevance

Secretsnitch, a fast, modular secret scanner in Golang

01 Nov 2024 Developer Tools

this is a tool i wrote in golang that combines a set of practices i learned over the years in finding secrets that developers commit all the time. it has easy-to-use features like modules and caching that can generate a continuous stream of data to be used for security analysis purposes (such as attack surface monitoring).part of my work involves finding exposed secrets for organizations. this tool helps you find several exposed production urls, tokens etc. on services like github and on websites. the craziest one was a leaked github personal access token from a renowned car company, and the latest one was a leaked payment gateway key from an insurance company.

Avatar
2
2
Relevance

Online security scanner for vulns and misconfigs based on domain recon

28 Apr 2024 Developer Tools Security

Hi HN,i have my first sideproject online. It's an automated security tool that checks your it infrastructure, checks CVEs, passwordleaks and misconfigurations based on your domain name.The first scan of your domain is for free - so you can test it - if you want. All i need is the domain + email (to notify you when the scan is done). It is also possible to scan other domains if you verify them via DNS-record or with a TXT-file.There is an example scan report: https://www.hackerattack.de/reports.html#exampleI'm not a native english speaker. The translation of the website could have flaws. ;)Alex

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Nosey Parker, a fast and low-noise secrets detector for textual data

03 Mar 2023 Developer Tools

Nosey Parker is an Apache-licensed command-line tool that finds secrets and sensitive information in textual data. It's useful both for offensive and defensive security testing.The big idea: textual content in, hardcoded secrets out. These include things like API keys and passwords.It should do a reasonable job on any textual input. It will recursively scan any directories it is pointed at. It also has special support for scanning the complete contents of Git repositories.The default rules in Nosey Parker have been carefully chosen to minimize false positives. Many API tokens these days have well-specified formats that are amenable to precise matching with regular expressions, and these are the kind of things that the default rules detect. Additionally, its findings are deduplicated. Together, these give much higher signal-to-noise compared to similar tools.Nosey Parker is fast: it can scan 100GB of Linux kernel commit history in just over a minute on my laptop. This speed comes from several factors, but most significantly from using the amazing Hyperscan library for simultaneous matching of all regex rules in a single pass. In comparison with similar tools on large inputs, Nosey Parker is usually 1-3 orders of magnitude faster.Nosey Parker was originally created to help construct a labeled dataset of secrets for machine learning purposes. But it proved surprisingly useful on its own. In the past year, an internal, proprietary version (with added machine learning capabilities) has been regularly used in security engagements at Praetorian.In late 2022, Nosey Parker was reimplemented in Rust, released as open-source, and presented at Black Hat Arsenal.It now supports enumeration and scanning of GitHub repositories by providing just usernames or organization names. It also recently got support for SARIF output, which several other tools understand.

Users are curious about finding serial numbers in old drives and checking if private keys are saved in GitHub. They also discuss product key schemes using encoding and checksums. Additionally, one user praises the author's choice of name.

The product has been criticized for accidentally exposing private keys in a public repository, which is a significant security risk.

Avatar
65
4
4
65
Relevance

HasMySecretLeaked - Check if your secrets and API keys have leaked on GitHub.

29 Nov 2023 Development Developer Tools Security

HasMySecretLeaked helps developers check if their secrets (API keys, credentials) have been compromised by searching across 20+ million leaks in public GitHub repositories, gists, and issues.

GitGuardian launched HasMySecretLeaked, a tool to check for leaked secrets on GitHub. The launch received numerous congratulations and positive feedback. Users find the service useful, particularly its focus on Git. Some express relief regarding API keys and curiosity about the tool's functionality. A question was raised about the need to reveal secrets to check for leaks and another user asked about best practices after a secret key leak is discovered.

A user expressed concerns about revealing sensitive information despite GitGuardian's established reputation, indicating a potential hesitancy to fully trust the platform with confidential data.

Avatar
153
16
0.0%
16
153
6.2%
Relevance

I build a new website vulnerability scanner

16 Oct 2024 Developer Tools

i have build a new website vulnerability scanner that aims to search and find security related problems and vulnerabilities from diffirent severity, this scanner can detect a wide range of vulnerabilities including owasp top 10 and others using both active and passive scanning. in the active scanning, the scanner interact directly to the live website endpoints by sending multiple http requests with special payloads, in passive scanning, the scanner fetch data from various source like the Wayback Machine. the scanner also scan the subdomains to discover hidden or forgotten endpoint which may be outdated and vulnerable.The scanner will be launched soon, if you are interested in getting early access, leave your contact information at: https://forms.gle/dqvC2G5UVK1xopo18 or contact me at: aimedguendouz@gmail.com

Show HN is for ready-to-try projects.

Post when more readily available.

Avatar
2
1
1
2
Top