07 May 2025
API

automation workflow using node http request to crawl data website

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Freemium

People love using similar products but resist paying. You’ll need to either find who will pay or create additional value that’s worth paying for.

Should You Build It?

Build but think about differentiation and monetization.


Your are here

You're venturing into the realm of automation workflows using Node.js for web crawling, a space where numerous similar products exist. With an n_matches of 25, expect a competitive landscape, but also a wealth of potential users. This puts you in the 'Freemium' category. The good news is engagement is moderate. The challenge will be effectively monetizing your tool, since the freemium idea category assumes people are reluctant to pay. Many similar tools exist, so differentiation is key. You'll need to find a way to offer compelling value that users are willing to pay for, especially if they can already accomplish similar tasks with free alternatives.

Recommendations

  1. First, identify the users who derive the most value from the free aspects of your Node.js web crawling automation. Understanding their specific needs will help you tailor premium features that address those needs more effectively. Look into open source projects, check the issues/PRs and the associated discussions, they're ripe with feature requests!
  2. Develop premium features that significantly enhance the capabilities for those high-value users. Focus on features like advanced data extraction, scheduled crawls, or integration with other platforms. According to the comments and discussions we analyzed, handling dynamic content and bypassing anti-scraping measures are key pain points, so focus on these!
  3. Consider offering team-based pricing plans rather than focusing solely on individual users. Web crawling automation often benefits teams working on data analysis, marketing, or research. A team plan can justify a higher price point and provide more value.
  4. Offer personalized support, consulting, or custom script development services as part of your premium offerings. Some users, especially those less technical, will pay for expert guidance and hands-on help in setting up and maintaining their web crawling workflows.
  5. Experiment with different pricing models to determine the optimal balance between free and premium features. Run A/B tests with small user groups to see which pricing strategies yield the best conversion rates and revenue. A common user complaint is pricing compared to alternative solutions, so you need to test!
  6. Address ethical concerns related to web scraping. Be transparent about your tool's data collection practices and ensure compliance with relevant regulations. Implement responsible data collection practices, and clearly communicate these practices to users. Some users raised concerns about ethical data collection, transparency, and compliance.
  7. Focus on ease of use and intuitive flow-building. Many potential users are non-technical, so a user-friendly interface is critical. Prioritize a drag-and-drop interface or visual workflow builder to simplify the process.
  8. Provide comprehensive documentation, tutorials, and examples. Help users quickly understand how to use your tool and its features. According to our similar product analysis, users reported inadequate documentation.
  9. Offer pre-built templates for common use cases, such as e-commerce scraping or LinkedIn data extraction. Templates can help users quickly get started and demonstrate the value of your tool.

Questions

  1. Given the existing competition in Node.js web crawling tools, what specific niche or industry will your automation workflow target to differentiate itself and attract paying customers?
  2. Considering the freemium model, what metrics will you track to determine the conversion rate from free users to paying customers, and what strategies will you implement to optimize this conversion?
  3. How will you balance the need for powerful web scraping capabilities with the ethical considerations and legal compliance requirements associated with data collection?

Your are here

You're venturing into the realm of automation workflows using Node.js for web crawling, a space where numerous similar products exist. With an n_matches of 25, expect a competitive landscape, but also a wealth of potential users. This puts you in the 'Freemium' category. The good news is engagement is moderate. The challenge will be effectively monetizing your tool, since the freemium idea category assumes people are reluctant to pay. Many similar tools exist, so differentiation is key. You'll need to find a way to offer compelling value that users are willing to pay for, especially if they can already accomplish similar tasks with free alternatives.

Recommendations

  1. First, identify the users who derive the most value from the free aspects of your Node.js web crawling automation. Understanding their specific needs will help you tailor premium features that address those needs more effectively. Look into open source projects, check the issues/PRs and the associated discussions, they're ripe with feature requests!
  2. Develop premium features that significantly enhance the capabilities for those high-value users. Focus on features like advanced data extraction, scheduled crawls, or integration with other platforms. According to the comments and discussions we analyzed, handling dynamic content and bypassing anti-scraping measures are key pain points, so focus on these!
  3. Consider offering team-based pricing plans rather than focusing solely on individual users. Web crawling automation often benefits teams working on data analysis, marketing, or research. A team plan can justify a higher price point and provide more value.
  4. Offer personalized support, consulting, or custom script development services as part of your premium offerings. Some users, especially those less technical, will pay for expert guidance and hands-on help in setting up and maintaining their web crawling workflows.
  5. Experiment with different pricing models to determine the optimal balance between free and premium features. Run A/B tests with small user groups to see which pricing strategies yield the best conversion rates and revenue. A common user complaint is pricing compared to alternative solutions, so you need to test!
  6. Address ethical concerns related to web scraping. Be transparent about your tool's data collection practices and ensure compliance with relevant regulations. Implement responsible data collection practices, and clearly communicate these practices to users. Some users raised concerns about ethical data collection, transparency, and compliance.
  7. Focus on ease of use and intuitive flow-building. Many potential users are non-technical, so a user-friendly interface is critical. Prioritize a drag-and-drop interface or visual workflow builder to simplify the process.
  8. Provide comprehensive documentation, tutorials, and examples. Help users quickly understand how to use your tool and its features. According to our similar product analysis, users reported inadequate documentation.
  9. Offer pre-built templates for common use cases, such as e-commerce scraping or LinkedIn data extraction. Templates can help users quickly get started and demonstrate the value of your tool.

Questions

  1. Given the existing competition in Node.js web crawling tools, what specific niche or industry will your automation workflow target to differentiate itself and attract paying customers?
  2. Considering the freemium model, what metrics will you track to determine the conversion rate from free users to paying customers, and what strategies will you implement to optimize this conversion?
  3. How will you balance the need for powerful web scraping capabilities with the ethical considerations and legal compliance requirements associated with data collection?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 25
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 8
  • Net use signal: 2.2%
    • Positive use signal: 7.3%
    • Negative use signal: 5.0%
  • Net buy signal: -1.6%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.7%
    • Negative buy signal: 2.3%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Yomuco – A simple web crawling library for Node.js

12 May 2024 Developer Tools

Users expressed confusion about whether the product is related to Bun or Node.js based on the title and instructions. Additionally, some users felt that the library might be unnecessary if it only consists of 92 lines of code.

Users criticized the product for having a mismatch between the title and instructions, and for including an unnecessary library.


Avatar
23
2
-50.0%
-50.0%
2
23
Relevance

Nimble API - Crawl, parse & scale web data seamlessly

Nimble API offers a powerful solution for real-time web data streaming. With AI-powered crawling, modern proxies, and zero-effort data structuring, Nimble ensures high accuracy and reliability. Perfect for #SEO, #Ecommerce, #AI, and more.

Nimble API's Product Hunt launch garnered positive feedback, with users praising its free trial, API access, and ease of use for data scraping. Several users expressed interest in using it for web crawling and automating CRM workflows. Questions were raised about legal and ethical considerations, compliance, and responsible data collection. Users also inquired about pricing compared to alternatives like Jina and the product's development timeline. Many congratulated the team on the launch and expressed eagerness to try the API.

Users expressed concerns regarding the product's data collection practices and requested more transparency. The pricing was also criticized, with some users finding it expensive compared to alternatives like Jina Reader. These were the primary areas of concern raised during the Product Hunt launch.


Avatar
174
10
20.0%
-10.0%
10
174
20.0%
Relevance

FlowScraper - Powerful web scraper with intuitive flow-builder

FlowScraper is a powerful web scraper with an intuitive FlowBuilder, enabling effortless website automation and data extraction without coding. Its customizable AI actions and automatic anti-bot protection ensure efficient and flexible web automation.

FlowScraper's Product Hunt launch garnered positive feedback, with users calling it a game-changer, especially for non-technical users. Key discussion points included inquiries about API availability, accessing generated code, and anti-bot measures on complex sites like React websites. Users requested e-commerce and LinkedIn templates and guides. There were also questions about Datadome compatibility, lifetime access, self-deployment, and the sophistication of anti-bot protection beyond existing solutions.

Users criticize the use of Unreal Engine blueprints for web scraping. They also suggest improvements, such as adding e-commerce templates, a LinkedIn page, and offering a free year. Furthermore, some users reported that the anti-bot measures are insufficient, with some sites failing when using puppeteer-extra-plugin-stealth.


Avatar
331
18
16.7%
5.6%
18
331
22.2%
5.6%
Relevance

Painless Data Extraction and Web Automation

Forget fragile XPath or DOM selectors. AI-powered AgentQL finds elements reliably, even as websites change

The Show HN submission for AgentQL, an AI-powered semantic framework for web interaction, has received minimal engagement, with no substantive content available in the comments. The majority of comments have been flagged and are pending review, indicating either spam, inappropriate content, or other violations of community guidelines.


Avatar
11
10
10
11
Relevance

LLM Scraper – turn any webpage into structured data

20 Apr 2024 Data

Users appreciate the tool, highlighting its usefulness in transforming webpages into structured data and suggesting improvements like handling JavaScript-heavy sites and adding Markdown output. Concerns about cost and efficiency are noted, with suggestions for reusable scripts and compatibility with OpenAI's API. Some users report specific use cases like CSS selector generation and structured data extraction with LLMs. Challenges such as antibot measures and captchas are mentioned, as well as a curiosity about the tool's prompt and capabilities like instruction following and screenshot parsing.

Users criticized the Show HN product for lacking a reusable script for LLM, high costs associated with calling LLM each time and scaling content size, and concerns about cost and hallucination frequency. Other issues include difficulty with information hidden in text, the need for handling JavaScript sites, lack of Markdown output, and latency issues with web LLMs. Users also suggested solving underlying problems such as antibots and captchas.


Avatar
88
18
5.6%
-5.6%
18
88
5.6%
Relevance

Crawl a modern website to a zip, serve the website from the zip

10 Jun 2024 GitHub

I'm a big fan of modern JavaScript frameworks, but I don't fancy SSR, so have been experimenting with crawling myself for uploading to hosts without having to do SSR. This is the result

Users appreciate the Show HN product for its ability to package assets into a single binary, similar to RedBean and Pocketbase, and its cross-platform functionality. There's interest in single-file webpages, with comparisons to .mht files and SingleFile extension. Some discuss the effectiveness on static sites and issues with subsites. The conversation includes technical suggestions like status codes and command-line options, and there's a request for license addition, with MIT and BSD mentioned. Users also discuss the tool's utility for website impersonation, backup, and static hosting, with some confusion about deployment and SSR. A spam link and a dead comment are noted.

Users criticized the product for its lack of support for multiple browsers (Firefox, Safari) and formats (MHT, PDF, .riv files), unclear functionality and benefits, and potential copyright issues. There were also concerns about privacy risks with HAR files, inefficiency with large files, and incorrect error handling. The product's slow performance, error messages, and lack of clear documentation on saving/restoring tasks and deployment were also noted. Some users were concerned about the tool being useful to scammers, while others questioned the necessity of the tool for copying websites.


Avatar
223
52
3.8%
-3.8%
52
223
11.5%
Relevance

Crawlee for Python – a web scraping and browser automation library

09 Jul 2024 Developer Tools

Hey all,This is Jan, the founder of Apify (https://apify.com/) — a full-stack web scraping platform. After the success of Crawlee for JavaScript (https://github.com/apify/crawlee/) and the demand from the Python community, we're launching Crawlee for Python today!The main features are:- A unified programming interface for both HTTP (HTTPX with BeautifulSoup) & headless browser crawling (Playwright)- Automatic parallel crawling based on available system resources- Written in Python with type hints for enhanced developer experience- Automatic retries on errors or when you’re getting blocked- Integrated proxy rotation and session management- Configurable request routing - direct URLs to the appropriate handlers- Persistent queue for URLs to crawl- Pluggable storage for both tabular data and filesFor details, you can read the announcement blog post: https://crawlee.dev/blog/launching-crawlee-pythonOur team and I will be happy to answer here any questions you might have.

Users discuss Crawlee's usability, comparing it to Scrapy, Selenium, and other scraping tools. They praise its easy setup, performance, and configurability, but note documentation issues and a lack of examples. Some inquire about specific features like web scraping opt-out, 2FA handling, and anti-blocking. Others question the ethics of scraping and the respect for host settings. There's interest in Python support and requests for code snippets in documentation. The tool is noted to be free, open-source, and Python-compatible, with some users planning to try it for projects.

Users criticized the product for inadequate documentation, particularly missing test case snippets and unclear feature descriptions. The coding style and lack of unique features were also noted. Concerns about ethical considerations, such as web scraping opt-out protocols and bot detection avoidance, were raised. Technical issues mentioned include insufficient type hint coverage, customization difficulties, and inadequate handling of proxies, caching, and 2FA. Comparisons with Scrapy and Crawlee suggest confusion about the product's unique value proposition, and there were requests for better automation and examples, especially for dynamic sites and non-HTML content.


Avatar
254
52
3.8%
0.0%
52
254
9.6%
1.9%
Relevance

Flyscrape – A standalone and scriptable web scraper in Go

11 Nov 2023 Developer Tools

Users have expressed concerns about Flyscrape's effectiveness in scraping real-world sites, particularly those with anti-scraping measures like Cloudflare. There's a demand for more features, dynamic settings, and examples of advanced web-scraping. Comparisons with other tools like Colly and Playwright are requested, and there's interest in handling dynamic content and site changes. Some users find the tool potentially useful and plan to test it, while others have moved to different technologies. There are also technical questions about specific functions and suggestions for improvements, including opening the core for feedback.

Users criticized the product for its inability to handle real-world scraping challenges such as dynamic content, JavaScript rendering, and anti-scraping measures. The lack of examples, broken documentation links, and the need for clearer methods were also mentioned. Some noted the inefficiency of Python compared to UNIX utilities and the necessity to spoof user agents. The product's inability to handle iframes, shadow elements, and the absence of programmatic extensibility for custom browser control were highlighted. Users also pointed out the risk posed by gatekeeping technologies like Cloudflare and Akamai.


Avatar
208
42
-7.1%
42
208
4.8%
Relevance

flyscrape – An expressive and elegant web scraper

13 Oct 2023 Productivity

Users are interested in the product, with one asking about async handling similar to waitFor in puppeteer. Another user compares it to colly, expressing satisfaction but openness to improvements. A third user appreciates the neat approach but initially missed that it's written in JavaScript.

The main criticism is the lack of information on asynchronous handling in the readme. Additionally, there is a general openness to improvements.


Avatar
14
3
3
14
Relevance

I made a platform to build background workflows via Node.js

26 Apr 2024 GitHub Developer Tools

The idea was to make the development and deployment of background workflows as easy as possible. (Think of some long-running AI processing, generating PDF reports, and similar).I believe this could be a game-changer for many developers out there who need to manage background processes without the usual hassle.Your feedback will be invaluable in helping me refine TurboQ and make it even better for our dev community.Thanks so much for your time and thoughts!


Avatar
1
1
Top