Should I Build It Should I Build It
07 May 2025
Artificial Intelligence E-Commerce Marketing

A shopify app to build automation workflow for merchant using ai first

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Competitive Terrain

While there's clear interest in your idea, the market is saturated with similar offerings. To succeed, your product needs to stand out by offering something unique that competitors aren't providing. The challenge here isn’t whether there’s demand, but how you can capture attention and keep it.

Should You Build It?

Not before thinking deeply about differentiation.

Your are here

Your idea for a Shopify app that uses AI to build automation workflows for merchants is entering a competitive space. There are at least 25 similar products already out there, which indicates both demand and significant competition. This crowded field means you'll need a strong differentiator to stand out. User engagement, measured by the average number of comments on similar products, is moderate. There aren't explicit use signals, but encouragingly, there's a strong buy signal, suggesting that if you can nail the execution, people are willing to pay. Your primary challenge isn't whether merchants need automation, but how you can offer something genuinely unique and better than what's currently available. Don't let the competition scare you, but make sure you bring something new to the table.

Recommendations

  1. First, conduct thorough competitive research focusing on the limitations of existing AI automation apps in the Shopify ecosystem. Many users are seeking increased order value, addressing inaccuracies, and streamlining setup. Your app should address these unmet needs directly.
  2. Next, define your unique value proposition. Don't just be 'another AI automation app.' Focus on a specific niche or offer a feature set that's demonstrably superior. Consider addressing areas like improved accuracy, easier setup, or integrations that competitors lack. Given the comments from similar products, think about how you can make the process more intuitive for non-technical users.
  3. Develop a focused go-to-market strategy. With so many alternatives, you can’t afford to be generic. Target a specific segment of Shopify merchants—perhaps those in a particular vertical (e.g., fashion, home goods) or those with specific pain points (e.g., high cart abandonment, poor customer support response times). Leverage targeted ads and content marketing to reach your ideal users.
  4. Prioritize a seamless user experience. Based on criticisms of similar products, simplify the setup process and ensure intuitive navigation. Provide excellent documentation and support to help users get the most out of your app. Consider offering a free trial or freemium version to lower the barrier to entry.
  5. Actively gather user feedback and iterate. Engage with your early users to understand what's working and what's not. Use their feedback to prioritize feature development and improvements. This iterative approach will help you refine your product and stay ahead of the competition.
  6. Address concerns about unsubstantiated claims. Be transparent about how your AI works and provide concrete examples of how it delivers value. Case studies and testimonials can build trust and demonstrate the effectiveness of your app.
  7. Implement robust data privacy measures and communicate them clearly to your users. Given increasing concerns about data security, make it clear how you protect user data and comply with privacy regulations. Transparency can be a significant differentiator.

Questions

  1. Given the existing solutions, what specific, measurable pain point(s) will your app solve for Shopify merchants that current apps don't effectively address, and how will you validate that your solution is a significant improvement?
  2. Considering the competitive landscape and the need for a unique value proposition, how will you prevent your AI-powered automation from becoming just another 'me-too' app, and what concrete steps will you take to build a defensible moat around your product?
  3. Given the strong buy signal but lack of explicit use signals, how will you design your onboarding process to ensure that merchants not only purchase your app but also actively use it and integrate it into their daily workflows, maximizing their return on investment and fostering long-term retention?

Your are here

Your idea for a Shopify app that uses AI to build automation workflows for merchants is entering a competitive space. There are at least 25 similar products already out there, which indicates both demand and significant competition. This crowded field means you'll need a strong differentiator to stand out. User engagement, measured by the average number of comments on similar products, is moderate. There aren't explicit use signals, but encouragingly, there's a strong buy signal, suggesting that if you can nail the execution, people are willing to pay. Your primary challenge isn't whether merchants need automation, but how you can offer something genuinely unique and better than what's currently available. Don't let the competition scare you, but make sure you bring something new to the table.

Recommendations

  1. First, conduct thorough competitive research focusing on the limitations of existing AI automation apps in the Shopify ecosystem. Many users are seeking increased order value, addressing inaccuracies, and streamlining setup. Your app should address these unmet needs directly.
  2. Next, define your unique value proposition. Don't just be 'another AI automation app.' Focus on a specific niche or offer a feature set that's demonstrably superior. Consider addressing areas like improved accuracy, easier setup, or integrations that competitors lack. Given the comments from similar products, think about how you can make the process more intuitive for non-technical users.
  3. Develop a focused go-to-market strategy. With so many alternatives, you can’t afford to be generic. Target a specific segment of Shopify merchants—perhaps those in a particular vertical (e.g., fashion, home goods) or those with specific pain points (e.g., high cart abandonment, poor customer support response times). Leverage targeted ads and content marketing to reach your ideal users.
  4. Prioritize a seamless user experience. Based on criticisms of similar products, simplify the setup process and ensure intuitive navigation. Provide excellent documentation and support to help users get the most out of your app. Consider offering a free trial or freemium version to lower the barrier to entry.
  5. Actively gather user feedback and iterate. Engage with your early users to understand what's working and what's not. Use their feedback to prioritize feature development and improvements. This iterative approach will help you refine your product and stay ahead of the competition.
  6. Address concerns about unsubstantiated claims. Be transparent about how your AI works and provide concrete examples of how it delivers value. Case studies and testimonials can build trust and demonstrate the effectiveness of your app.
  7. Implement robust data privacy measures and communicate them clearly to your users. Given increasing concerns about data security, make it clear how you protect user data and comply with privacy regulations. Transparency can be a significant differentiator.

Questions

  1. Given the existing solutions, what specific, measurable pain point(s) will your app solve for Shopify merchants that current apps don't effectively address, and how will you validate that your solution is a significant improvement?
  2. Considering the competitive landscape and the need for a unique value proposition, how will you prevent your AI-powered automation from becoming just another 'me-too' app, and what concrete steps will you take to build a defensible moat around your product?
  3. Given the strong buy signal but lack of explicit use signals, how will you design your onboarding process to ensure that merchants not only purchase your app but also actively use it and integrate it into their daily workflows, maximizing their return on investment and fostering long-term retention?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 25
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 6
  • Net use signal: 12.3%
    • Positive use signal: 12.3%
    • Negative use signal: 0.0%
  • Net buy signal: 0.7%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.7%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.0%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Autonomous AI Agents for Online Stores

04 Jan 2024 Artificial Intelligence E-Commerce

Hi folks! I'm Dimitrios Konstantinidis, and I'm really excited to share what our startup has been working on: https://l.algomo.com/9NS3apAlgomo automates online stores' customer service using AI agents. You log in, connect Algomo to your Shopify shop, run a web crawler, and all is ready to work within a few minutes.Here's a demo video: https://l.algomo.com/UKSggbWe believe that most online shop owners want to spend their time doing creative stuff and market their products. Instead, a lot of time at online stores is spent on repetitive customer queries instead.Unlike generic AI agents, our AI agents specialize in customer service for online stores.Customer: "I want black shoes, size 10" AI Agent: Pulls data from Shopify API and presents the best choices with picturesThe agents run modules which include a procedural plan of attack, and execute prompts using RAG (Retrieval-Augmented Generation) to utilize the most up-to-date context to do the job, including documentation and API calls from Shopify, crawled with LangChain and stored in vector DBs. Our agents also escalate and hand-over to humans, do small talk, and potentially can perform tasks like changing a delivery address. The agents can run in our Algomo Cloud, and we plan to also run fully on-premise with self-hosted LLMs.Today, we specialize in e-commerce but we're also building sector agnostic agents that will connect and run on any API, and potentially, we plan to open up Generic Tools to enable the community to build their own modules too by calling any endpoint/API of your choosing.You can try Algomo on any small website for free. For larger websites and stores, we charge based on the number of AI conversations starting from $9/month.Please try it out and let us know what you think. We are obsessed with improving, so please let us know feedback!

LLMs revolutionize customer service with autonomous AI agents.

Avatar
1
1
1
1
Relevance

ReSponse CX - Autonomous customer service agents for Shopify

08 May 2024 E-Commerce

Empower your team with Conversational AI Agents: automate routine customer interaction tasks, including order modifications and subscription changes. Give your CX team the freedom to concentrate on higher-value activities, enhancing efficiency and retention.

Avatar
4
4
Relevance

Shopifinity Engine™ - Fully customized AI solutions designed for Shopify stores

23 Mar 2024 Artificial Intelligence E-Commerce Marketing

Each Shopifinity Engine™ is as unique as the store it powers. Tailored made AI solutions providing brand voice content, a 24/7 Sales and Support chatbot, and deep customer insights.

The comments express excitement and support for the launch of AI tools for Shopify stores. Users consider it a great idea and a great initiative, wishing the project good luck.

Avatar
68
3
3
68
Relevance

I built an AI shopping assistant with 200M Shopify products

10 Apr 2024 Artificial Intelligence E-Commerce

Hi HN! I previously launched Agora, a search engine for e-commerce products, here on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38635695Sticking to the Ancient Greek theme we just released Athena, an AI assistant that helps users find products in a personalized way. Athena gathers context of what you're looking for, asks specific questions about the product category and budget, and then presents a few recommendations.To power Athena we're using text embeddings of the name, description, and tag fields with SBERT. Additionally, we're using LangChain, GPT-3.5, GPUs on Digital Ocean's Paperspace, a Mongo database, and servers on AWS running self-hosted Typesense. Agora currently has a dataset of about 200 million products from stores on Shopify, WooCommerce, Squarespace, and Wix.The vision for Athena is to use AI to help people find any product in the world. I'm continuing to build it for someone like myself: I want to shop from smaller stores around the world but unsure where to start. Still working out a lot of bugs and enhancements before letting Hermes (i.e our aptly named store crawler) index billions of e-commerce products. We'll also feed in more data like reviews, discussion threads, and automated user feedback to improve the recommendation experience.I'd love any feedback!

Users find the concept interesting and the search functionality effective. However, there are issues with product accuracy and slow product page load times.

Users criticized Athena for not returning the correct products and for having slow product page load times.

Avatar
2
2
2
2
Relevance

Buysmart - AI copilot for shopping across all platforms

26 Apr 2023 Search E-Commerce Virtual Assistants

Are you tired of wasting time scrolling through endless shopping websites? Me too. With BuySmart.ai, the world’s first AI-native assistant across all shopping platforms. You can have your own personal shopping assistant help you and make decisions easier.

Users find the product launch helpful and time-saving, especially for online shopping and quickly finding books. The customized product options, based on ingredients users like, is useful. There are congratulations to Stella on the launch from multiple users, including Ronak from MiraclePlus who wants to explore potential synergies. A user also inquired about assistance with size selection.

Avatar
97
8
37.5%
12.5%
8
97
37.5%
12.5%
Relevance

Rep AI: Sales Concierge for eCommerce - Convert more traffic, sell more stuff, and support customers

01 Jun 2023 Artificial Intelligence E-Commerce Sales

We built an AI chatbot for Shopify stores powered by two AIs. First is our Behavioral AI (designed to convert more traffic) and Generative AI (powered by ChatGPT). Average results so far: increase traffic conversions by 13% and sales uplift by 20% on average.

Rep AI's launch on Product Hunt has generated considerable excitement, particularly for its innovative AI-driven shopping solution and personalized AI agents. Users are impressed by its potential to improve online shopping experiences, increase website conversions, and its straightforward approach. Many congratulate the team on the launch and its early success, highlighting the impressive conversion numbers and smart product-market fit. Questions were raised regarding behavioral AI strategies, comparisons to existing chatbots, and handling complex product inquiries.

Users are requesting concrete use cases demonstrating how Rep AI increases order value. There's skepticism about the product making unsubstantiated claims of significant sales increases, similar to other companies making false promises.

Avatar
261
27
25.9%
3.7%
27
261
25.9%
3.7%
Relevance

Blink – AI Shopping Assistant for Shopify Stores

03 Jun 2023 Artificial Intelligence E-Commerce

Hello Hacker News community! I wanted to introduce you to Blink, a powerful AI shopping assistant designed specifically for Shopify stores. With Blink, you can enhance your customers' shopping experience by seamlessly finding, comparing, and analyzing products, all within a user-friendly chat interface.Blink leverages the advanced capabilities of ChatGPT, an AI language model, to understand customer queries and provide personalized product recommendations. It's like having a knowledgeable shopping assistant available 24/7, helping your customers make informed buying decisions.Integrating Blink into your Shopify store is effortless. Just sign up, copy-paste a code snippet, and let Blink automatically gather product information to train its AI assistant for your specific store. In minutes, you can offer your customers a lightning-fast and intuitive shopping experience.Visit our website at mmntm.me/blink to learn more and get started with Blink today. We value your feedback and are excited to engage in discussions about how Blink can revolutionize the way your Shopify store operates.URL: https://mmntm.me/blinkFeel free to ask any questions or share your thoughts about Blink. We're here to support you in transforming your Shopify store into a customer-centric shopping destination.

Avatar
3
3
Relevance

ShopMate AI - AI ChatGPT-powered e-commerce assistant

12 Apr 2023 Artificial Intelligence E-Commerce Tech

Meet ShopMate AI: Enhance your e-commerce store using our ChatGPT virtual assistant. Boost sales, upsell/cross-sell, enjoy 24/7 support, reduce costs, and optimize conversions. Upgrade your store with ShopMate AI today!

The Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with multiple users congratulating the team. Several comments highlighted the tool's potential value for e-commerce businesses. There was also specific interest in Shopify integrations.

Avatar
84
4
4
84
Relevance

ChatBlu - Shopify AI Assistant For Customer Support

12 Nov 2024 Artificial Intelligence E-Commerce API

Increase your E-Commerce Store's conversions with our Trainable AI ChatBot Assistant that can be integrated to your Shopify - fetching data directly from there! Pre-View and personalize your chatbot in an intuitive dashboard

Chatblu is praised for improving customer service and boosting customer conversion rates. Users find it simple, fast, and handy for quick chats. A beta tester highlighted the intuitive user interface, recommending others to try it out.

Avatar
13
3
100.0%
3
13
100.0%
Relevance

Shopmate AI - Where AI meets e-commerce

22 Sep 2023 Artificial Intelligence E-Commerce Marketing

Convert scrollers into buyers with Shopmate, the AI-powered chatbot that offers personalised product recommendations. Say goodbye to cart abandonment and boost your sales effortlessly.

The Product Hunt launch received positive feedback, with users praising the application's usefulness and highlighting its great use of AI in e-commerce. One user congratulated the team.

Avatar
98
2
2
98
Relevance

AI Shopping Assistant

02 Dec 2023 Artificial Intelligence E-Commerce

Hi! My friend and I built an AI Shopping Assistant powered by ChatGPT, called ShopMigo. The primary purpose of this project was to learn more about LLMs, embeddings, and AI in general. This started more as a pet project, but turned into something that we actually find really useful.I’m the kind of person that will take weeks to do research before buying an electronic or an expensive product. ShopMigo helps to guide you through a purchase and aggregates reviews so you don’t have to spend weeks/months doing your due diligence.Try it out! Let us know what you think!

Users are impressed by the realism of modern chat bots and appreciate the neat appearance of the product.

Avatar
4
2
2
4
Relevance

Commerce AI - Shake up e-commerce: turn content into expert salesperson

11 Apr 2024 Artificial Intelligence E-Commerce Bots

Introducing Commerce AI by Arena: Elevate your e-commerce and affiliate sales with our AI chatbot. It transforms your catalog content into a personal product expert, boosting sales with a custom shopping assistant. Monetize your website effectively.

The Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with users congratulating the team and expressing excitement about the product's potential, especially for e-commerce. Users highlighted its ease of chat training, structured data retrieval, personalization, and automation capabilities. The tool is considered beginner-friendly and helpful for e-commerce businesses. Questions were raised regarding setup ease, stock access, item specifics, and German language support. Several users indicated they would evaluate the chatbot for their own or their clients' needs, citing its potential to solve scaling issues in concierge selling.

Users questioned the ease of connecting data sources and the overall setup process. There were concerns about the platform assuming full stock access without considering item specifics. Some also expressed skepticism based on previous chatbots failing to deliver effective concierge selling experiences.

Avatar
205
17
23.5%
17
205
23.5%
Relevance

AI-powered shopping assistant By Algomo - Personalised shopping experience powered by generative AI

05 Feb 2024 Artificial Intelligence E-Commerce Customer Communication

An AI shopping assistant for e-commerce that gives personalised recommendations of products, gives real time updates on your customers' orders, and it can collaborate with human customer support agents over a Live Chat to solve more complex problems.

The Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback. Users repeatedly congratulated the team on the launch and praised the AI shopping assistant as a game-changer, amazing, cool, and useful, especially as a Shopify add-on for stores with many products. Some users inquired about specific integrations like TikTok and how it differs from existing tools like Gorgias. There were also suggestions for improvements, such as more pre-made tags for easier conversations. Many wished the team success.

Users questioned TikTok shopping integration. Criticism included the unnecessary use of AI, suggesting it should serve a clear purpose. The landing page's title description was deemed too long. An AI agent interaction for an upscale brand was considered inappropriate, particularly during the holidays. Users also requested more pre-made tags to facilitate easier conversations with the AI.

Avatar
226
34
5.9%
34
226
5.9%
Relevance

WorkBot - An AI platform for Customer Service and Data Insights

04 Oct 2024 Artificial Intelligence Productivity API

An AI-powered customer service platform that autonomously handles customer communications, automates processes with AI agents, and uncovers deeper insights from customer data.

WorkBot's launch is receiving positive feedback for its privacy-focused automation, centralized knowledge management, and potential to boost productivity. Users appreciate its user-friendly interface and streamlining of workflows. However, there are concerns about its complexity for smaller organizations, the need for improved documentation, customizable dashboards, and data privacy, particularly with external AI integrations. Many are congratulating the team on the launch and expressing interest in testing it for various use cases, including customer service and team support.

Users criticize the lack of automation customization and insufficient documentation, especially for non-technical users. The platform's complexity could hinder adoption by smaller organizations. Data privacy concerns regarding sharing with external AI providers are raised. Customizable dashboards are desired for better visualization of metrics and workflows.

Avatar
119
23
34.8%
23
119
34.8%
Relevance

AdNabu 2.0 - AI-powered Shopify App to optimize Google Shopping Feed

16 Mar 2023 E-Commerce Marketing

Previously, people manually wrote longer product titles or created rules to optimize their product data feed. We are excited to announce the first Shopify app powered by OpenAI that suggests longer and keyword-rich product titles.

AdNabu 2.0's Product Hunt launch is receiving overwhelmingly positive feedback, with users congratulating the team and expressing excitement about its potential to optimize Google Shopping feeds and product titles using AI. Many users highlight its time-saving capabilities and consider it a game-changer for e-commerce store owners. The tool's ability to increase sales, automate processes, and save marketers time and energy is frequently mentioned. Questions were posed about its AI technology and potential marketing channels beyond Google Shopping. Users are eager to try the app and explore its use cases.

Users have expressed concerns regarding the tool's accuracy and are requesting user success stories to validate its performance. Additionally, there is interest in understanding the general statistics regarding the number of edits typically required when using the tool.

Avatar
242
31
19.4%
31
242
19.4%
Top