Should I Build It Should I Build It
19 Apr 2025
Social Media

a system where the user places links to articles or videos that he ...

...liked and generates posts for him on X and LinkedIn once a day

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Competitive Terrain

While there's clear interest in your idea, the market is saturated with similar offerings. To succeed, your product needs to stand out by offering something unique that competitors aren't providing. The challenge here isn’t whether there’s demand, but how you can capture attention and keep it.

Should You Build It?

Not before thinking deeply about differentiation.

Your are here

Your idea of automatically generating social media posts from liked articles and videos puts you in a competitive terrain. There are over 20 similar products already available, indicating a validated need but also a crowded space. The engagement for similar products is medium, suggesting users are actively looking for solutions but also discerning. Since we don't have use or buy signals for this specific idea, it's difficult to say whether people explicitly want or would pay for the product, so this is something we will need to discover. Given the number of competitors, your product needs a strong unique selling point to stand out. Differentiation is key to capturing and retaining user attention in this saturated market.

Recommendations

  1. Start by thoroughly researching the existing solutions. Focus on understanding their strengths and weaknesses. Look at what users are saying about these tools in online communities and reviews to identify unmet needs or pain points. The Product Hunt discussions from similar products highlight common concerns such as generic content, unclear pricing, and technical issues. Understanding these issues is the first step in designing a better product.
  2. Based on your competitive research, pinpoint 2-3 key areas where you can differentiate your product. Can you offer a more personalized content generation experience? Perhaps focus on a specific niche (e.g., AI, Web3, Marketing) that isn't well-served by existing tools? Or, explore more innovative formats such as carousels. Your unique selling proposition (USP) will be crucial for standing out.
  3. Since there are a lot of LinkedIn and X content generators already in the market, think about targeting a specific niche within the broader market. For example, you could focus on generating content specifically for B2B SaaS companies, or for individuals in the marketing industry. This focus allows you to tailor your product and marketing efforts more effectively.
  4. Given the competition, focus on building a strong brand and marketing message. What is the core value you provide to users? How can you communicate this value in a clear and compelling way? Invest in creating high-quality content and engaging with your target audience on social media. Also, clearly outline your pricing strategy upfront as this was called out in competitor criticism.
  5. Prioritize gathering feedback from your early users and iterate rapidly on your product. Use surveys, interviews, and analytics to understand how users are engaging with your product and what improvements they would like to see. This iterative approach will help you refine your product and build a loyal user base. Ensure that you address technical issues like login problems and confusing features as reported by users of similar tools.
  6. Consider focusing on content authenticity. Several similar products have been criticized for generating generic, AI-like content. Explore ways to make the generated posts more unique and personalized to the user's voice and style. Perhaps incorporate features that allow users to edit and refine the AI-generated content to ensure it aligns with their brand.

Questions

  1. Given the criticism that similar tools generate generic content, how will you ensure that your AI creates authentic and engaging posts that reflect the user's unique voice and style?
  2. How will you incorporate user feedback into the product development process to address reported issues with similar tools, such as login problems, unclear pricing, and confusing features?
  3. What specific niche or target audience will you focus on to differentiate your product from the crowded market of social media content generators, and how will you tailor your features and marketing efforts to meet their unique needs?

Your are here

Your idea of automatically generating social media posts from liked articles and videos puts you in a competitive terrain. There are over 20 similar products already available, indicating a validated need but also a crowded space. The engagement for similar products is medium, suggesting users are actively looking for solutions but also discerning. Since we don't have use or buy signals for this specific idea, it's difficult to say whether people explicitly want or would pay for the product, so this is something we will need to discover. Given the number of competitors, your product needs a strong unique selling point to stand out. Differentiation is key to capturing and retaining user attention in this saturated market.

Recommendations

  1. Start by thoroughly researching the existing solutions. Focus on understanding their strengths and weaknesses. Look at what users are saying about these tools in online communities and reviews to identify unmet needs or pain points. The Product Hunt discussions from similar products highlight common concerns such as generic content, unclear pricing, and technical issues. Understanding these issues is the first step in designing a better product.
  2. Based on your competitive research, pinpoint 2-3 key areas where you can differentiate your product. Can you offer a more personalized content generation experience? Perhaps focus on a specific niche (e.g., AI, Web3, Marketing) that isn't well-served by existing tools? Or, explore more innovative formats such as carousels. Your unique selling proposition (USP) will be crucial for standing out.
  3. Since there are a lot of LinkedIn and X content generators already in the market, think about targeting a specific niche within the broader market. For example, you could focus on generating content specifically for B2B SaaS companies, or for individuals in the marketing industry. This focus allows you to tailor your product and marketing efforts more effectively.
  4. Given the competition, focus on building a strong brand and marketing message. What is the core value you provide to users? How can you communicate this value in a clear and compelling way? Invest in creating high-quality content and engaging with your target audience on social media. Also, clearly outline your pricing strategy upfront as this was called out in competitor criticism.
  5. Prioritize gathering feedback from your early users and iterate rapidly on your product. Use surveys, interviews, and analytics to understand how users are engaging with your product and what improvements they would like to see. This iterative approach will help you refine your product and build a loyal user base. Ensure that you address technical issues like login problems and confusing features as reported by users of similar tools.
  6. Consider focusing on content authenticity. Several similar products have been criticized for generating generic, AI-like content. Explore ways to make the generated posts more unique and personalized to the user's voice and style. Perhaps incorporate features that allow users to edit and refine the AI-generated content to ensure it aligns with their brand.

Questions

  1. Given the criticism that similar tools generate generic content, how will you ensure that your AI creates authentic and engaging posts that reflect the user's unique voice and style?
  2. How will you incorporate user feedback into the product development process to address reported issues with similar tools, such as login problems, unclear pricing, and confusing features?
  3. What specific niche or target audience will you focus on to differentiate your product from the crowded market of social media content generators, and how will you tailor your features and marketing efforts to meet their unique needs?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 22
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 9
  • Net use signal: 31.8%
    • Positive use signal: 32.3%
    • Negative use signal: 0.5%
  • Net buy signal: 2.0%
    • Positive buy signal: 2.0%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.0%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Linkedin Posts Generator - Generate LinkedIn posts in seconds from articles

03 Jan 2023 Artificial Intelligence LinkedIn Productivity

This tool takes an URL as input and convert the learnings from the article into LinkedIn Statuses. It's ideal when you want are out of ideas to share your article on LinkedIn or are just inspired by something you read.

The Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with users congratulating the team and praising the product's usefulness as a time-saver, especially for solo social media managers. Several users expressed interest in the product's functionality and end results. However, some users want examples before logging in with their personal emails and others reported issues with the 'Buy Credits' feature and general login/registration functionality. One user inquired about purchasing more credits, and another plans to share the product with their team after their vacation.

Users criticized the product launch for several functional issues. The login/registration process and the 'Buy Credits' feature are reportedly not working correctly. Users also expressed concern about being asked for their email before seeing examples of the product's functionality. Furthermore, the login popup fails to redirect properly after clicking the generate button.

Avatar
177
16
12.5%
6.2%
16
177
18.8%
6.2%
Relevance

I built an app that turns long-form articles into LinkedIn posts

02 Nov 2024 LinkedIn

Hey,Ever felt Linkedin was overwhelmed with marketing and corpo posts everywhere?That was me.So I decided to post educational content on Linkedin with some AI assistance.Problem: this takes a lot of time. Really.And the existing post generators suck in science and engineering communication. They are tailored for marketers and for telling life stories, etc.I needed something tailored for engineers and tech entrepreneurs.I needed an app where we can ingest research papers, generating good drafts for compelling linkedin posts.So...I built it.I have just a few users, and want to launch a public beta.So here it is. - 20 credits to try for everyone who joins.It's my first product as indie hacker - feedback would be amazing.

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Growfol - Create LinkedIn content effortlessly and grow your audience.

24 Sep 2024 SaaS Social Media LinkedIn

Create high quality LinkedIn content effortlessly with AI. Get hundreds of post ideas, posts generated from articles, Images, Quora Answers, Youtube videos with a single click. Comment, Schedule posts, Generate a month of content with just 1 hour of effort.

Growfol's Product Hunt launch received positive feedback, with users congratulating Devansh and wishing the tool success. Users highlight Growfol's utility for LinkedIn content creation and account growth, praising its features such as UI, content ideas, templates, and scheduling capabilities. Several users emphasized its helpfulness for LinkedIn users seeking to grow their accounts and simplify content creation amid busy schedules.

The sole criticism expressed is a general dislike for products that generate content, without specifying particular issues.

Avatar
45
11
9.1%
11
45
9.1%
Relevance

ContentRadar - Transform your best writing and podcasts into LI and X posts

12 Sep 2024 Social media marketing Social Networking Marketing

As a founder, you wear many hats 🤹‍♀️. Consistent LinkedIn and X presence is a crucial task, but it's just one of many. We help you convert any piece of content into LinkedIn posts and carousel with 1 click, allow you to schedule, cross-post and collaborate.

ContentRadar's launch on Product Hunt has been met with overwhelmingly positive feedback, with users praising its ability to simplify content creation and repurposing across multiple platforms, especially LinkedIn and X. Key features highlighted include automated content conversion, AI-powered post generation, scheduling, and a user-friendly interface. Many users emphasize the time-saving benefits and efficiency gained, while some suggest improvements like enhanced analytics, multi-account support, more platform integrations (e.g., Web3), and AI tone matching, with numerous users congratulating the team and expressing excitement for the tool's potential.

Users expressed concerns about unclear pricing, particularly feature allocation across plans, and the pricing table's responsiveness on smaller screens. There are questions regarding AI accuracy, adaptability to niche markets, and maintaining content relevance across platforms. Users requested support for more platforms (including Web3 networks like Farcaster), post-generation editing capabilities, and more books. They want deeper analytics integration (including cross-platform tracking) and customizability of AI templates for different brand voices. Some are curious about potential features, such as AI comment generation, despite the challenges it might entail.

Avatar
1050
120
43.3%
2.5%
120
1050
43.3%
2.5%
Relevance

HeroPost - Generate LinkedIn posts in 1 click from any YouTube video

01 Jul 2024 Writing Social Media LinkedIn

What if you never spent more than 5 minutes writing a LinkedIn post? HeroPost helps you brainstorm, structure your ideas, write, edit & publish your posts, so you can grow on LinkedIn without spending hours writing content.

The Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with users praising the product's ability to quickly generate good content, particularly for LinkedIn and YouTube. Users find it helpful and well-made, with some specifically mentioning its usefulness in overcoming writer's block and saving time on LinkedIn posts. There is excitement about the product's potential and congratulations to the team for a straightforward and helpful tool. One user inquired about video snippet selection.

A user inquired about the possibility of incorporating video snippets into the tool's functionality in the future.

Avatar
34
10
30.0%
10
34
30.0%
Relevance

I made a simple tool that writes your social media posts

25 Jun 2024 Social Media

i’m still building my personal brand. i’ve invested in coaching and courses, but they didn’t bring the success i wanted.i learned it’s key to build an active community, especially on linkedin. so i tried posting regularly, but no big wins, mostly because i wasn’t consistent. lack of time and creativity didn’t help either.to fix this, i made an ai tool that asks me daily questions based on my industry and role. i just answer, and it generates a linkedin post. this way, content creation is easier, and i can focus on other stuff.it is not perfect yet, but helps a lot i think.any questions or feedback? thanks

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

I made a LinkedIn creators based app for growing your audience easier

24 Apr 2024 Social Media LinkedIn Productivity

LinkedIn is a very useful tool for professionals.Since I don't have time for dedicating to promote my developer services, I created Sparkin, a place where you can create LinkedIn content in a faster, easier and nicer way.Currently, you can:- Generate from pre-made prompts. - Generate info or conversion focused posts. - More AI powered tools. - Edit your post in a wider and more visual friendly interphase.Developed in Next.js and with help of supabase.

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Hushl: AI-driven content creation for LinkedIn

16 May 2023 Artificial Intelligence Social Media LinkedIn

Hushl is a newly launched GPT-4 powered tool designed to help users create social media content easily.

Users have reported facing significant technical and design challenges with the product. These issues include bugs, poor user interface design, and difficulties in navigation. The overall user experience is negatively impacted, leading to frustration and dissatisfaction among users.

Avatar
3
2
2
3
Relevance

LinkedIn Post Generator

27 Feb 2023 Social Media LinkedIn

Hi HN! I made a LinkedIn post generator on top of the GPT-3 API. It works quite well, depending on how high you set the bar for your LinkedIn content. It’s also quite good at generating “absurd” posts like the infamous “I interviewed a dog” one from a few years ago.I’d love to hear your feedback!

Works great, generates LinkedIn-like posts.

LinkedIn posts look AI-generated.

Avatar
4
1
1
4
Relevance

Viralify AI - Unlimited personalized LinkedIn content in 30 seconds

15 Mar 2024 Productivity

Unlimited Personalized LinkedIn Content & Ideas in 30 Seconds Generate personalized content ideas and LinkedIn posts that drive engagement and sales. Save time and boost your personal & professional brand with Viralify AI.

Viralify AI's Product Hunt launch garnered positive feedback, with users congratulating the team and expressing excitement to try the LinkedIn content generation tool. Several users highlighted the innovative features and usefulness for LinkedIn, with interest in the 'ideas generation' function. Questions arose regarding user growth numbers using Viralify, future plans, and potential integration with other social media platforms. Content creators value the tool for its ability to enhance engagement. Overall, the response indicates interest and anticipation for Viralify AI's capabilities.

Users criticized the tool for generating generic, unoriginal sales content, similar to other existing tools. A key concern was ensuring content uniqueness, especially given LinkedIn's large user base, to avoid repetitive and unengaging material.

Avatar
115
14
42.9%
14
115
42.9%
Relevance

An "AI wrapper" that creates beautiful LinkedIn Carousels

07 May 2024 Artificial Intelligence

Hey HN, I'm Ankit, Founder Dottypost (https://twitter.com/ankit_saas)I've been writing content on LinkedIn for almost 2 years.But, the struggle to do consistent posting is real.So I built an AI SaaS that helps with LinkedIn content creation effortlessly.We'd love to get your feedback on the product and anything else that comes to your mind. It would be super useful for us. Thank you!

Avatar
5
5
Top