Should I Build It Should I Build It
07 May 2025
Personal Finance Fintech Money

AI personal finance tracking app expense money management assistant ...

...automatic

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Swamp

The market has seen several mediocre solutions that nobody loves. Unless you can offer something fundamentally different, you’ll likely struggle to stand out or make money.

Should You Build It?

Don't build it.

Your are here

The idea of an AI-powered personal finance tracking app falls into a crowded space, which we categorize as a 'Swamp'. There are numerous existing solutions, but none have achieved widespread love, suggesting a market filled with mediocre offerings. With 30 similar products already identified, competition is high. However, the fact that similar products have achieved very strong buy signals (top 5% of all products) suggests that there is definitely room for an innovative solution that people would want to use and pay for. However, with low average engagement (3 comments per product), you have to make sure to design a superior product to gain traction in this crowded space.

Recommendations

  1. Given the crowded market, your first step is to deeply research why existing AI personal finance tracking apps haven't resonated with users. Analyze their shortcomings in terms of user experience, features, pricing, and marketing. Look closely at the criticism from the similar products to learn from the failures of others.
  2. Instead of directly competing with established players, consider finding a specific niche or underserved group within the personal finance market. This could be focusing on freelancers, students, or individuals with specific financial goals like debt management or investment planning. For example, the concerns about data privacy are high, so it might be interesting to start with a privacy-first angle that targets a specific niche and underserved group within the personal finance market.
  3. Explore the possibility of building tools or features that integrate with existing personal finance platforms rather than creating a standalone app. This could involve developing AI-powered modules for expense categorization, fraud detection, or personalized financial advice that can be added to existing software.
  4. Critically assess whether the core problem you're trying to solve is the most pressing one in personal finance. Are there adjacent problems, such as financial literacy or access to financial services, that might present a more promising opportunity for innovation and impact? Perhaps tools that give users insight into their current spending habits, so they can improve their overall financial literacy.
  5. Several similar products had feedback related to the need for multi-currency support and integration with budgeting tools. Focus on these features to gain a competitive advantage. Providing a seamless experience for users dealing with multiple currencies or those who actively use budgeting apps can significantly enhance the value proposition of your app.
  6. Carefully consider your monetization strategy. Users are often wary of hidden fees or intrusive advertising. Focus on creating a transparent and value-driven freemium model or explore alternative revenue streams such as premium features, personalized financial advice, or partnerships with financial institutions.
  7. Don't make the same mistake that other products are making; have landing pages lack details and pricing information. Providing comprehensive details and clear information ensures users can easily understand the value and functionality of your product.
  8. Address concerns about data security, especially if integrating with AI platforms like OpenAI. Be transparent about how user data is handled, and provide assurances that financial information is protected.

Questions

  1. Given the existing solutions, what fundamentally different approach will your AI personal finance app take to truly stand out and capture users' attention and loyalty? Will you focus on a particular market segment or target a specific niche?
  2. How will you address user concerns about data privacy and security, especially in light of integrating with AI platforms like OpenAI? What specific measures will you implement to ensure the confidentiality and protection of sensitive financial information?
  3. Many similar products receive feedback about lack of features, such as multi-currency support, and integration with budgeting tools. How will your product differentiate itself and ensure the functionality of your product exceeds user's expectations?

Your are here

The idea of an AI-powered personal finance tracking app falls into a crowded space, which we categorize as a 'Swamp'. There are numerous existing solutions, but none have achieved widespread love, suggesting a market filled with mediocre offerings. With 30 similar products already identified, competition is high. However, the fact that similar products have achieved very strong buy signals (top 5% of all products) suggests that there is definitely room for an innovative solution that people would want to use and pay for. However, with low average engagement (3 comments per product), you have to make sure to design a superior product to gain traction in this crowded space.

Recommendations

  1. Given the crowded market, your first step is to deeply research why existing AI personal finance tracking apps haven't resonated with users. Analyze their shortcomings in terms of user experience, features, pricing, and marketing. Look closely at the criticism from the similar products to learn from the failures of others.
  2. Instead of directly competing with established players, consider finding a specific niche or underserved group within the personal finance market. This could be focusing on freelancers, students, or individuals with specific financial goals like debt management or investment planning. For example, the concerns about data privacy are high, so it might be interesting to start with a privacy-first angle that targets a specific niche and underserved group within the personal finance market.
  3. Explore the possibility of building tools or features that integrate with existing personal finance platforms rather than creating a standalone app. This could involve developing AI-powered modules for expense categorization, fraud detection, or personalized financial advice that can be added to existing software.
  4. Critically assess whether the core problem you're trying to solve is the most pressing one in personal finance. Are there adjacent problems, such as financial literacy or access to financial services, that might present a more promising opportunity for innovation and impact? Perhaps tools that give users insight into their current spending habits, so they can improve their overall financial literacy.
  5. Several similar products had feedback related to the need for multi-currency support and integration with budgeting tools. Focus on these features to gain a competitive advantage. Providing a seamless experience for users dealing with multiple currencies or those who actively use budgeting apps can significantly enhance the value proposition of your app.
  6. Carefully consider your monetization strategy. Users are often wary of hidden fees or intrusive advertising. Focus on creating a transparent and value-driven freemium model or explore alternative revenue streams such as premium features, personalized financial advice, or partnerships with financial institutions.
  7. Don't make the same mistake that other products are making; have landing pages lack details and pricing information. Providing comprehensive details and clear information ensures users can easily understand the value and functionality of your product.
  8. Address concerns about data security, especially if integrating with AI platforms like OpenAI. Be transparent about how user data is handled, and provide assurances that financial information is protected.

Questions

  1. Given the existing solutions, what fundamentally different approach will your AI personal finance app take to truly stand out and capture users' attention and loyalty? Will you focus on a particular market segment or target a specific niche?
  2. How will you address user concerns about data privacy and security, especially in light of integrating with AI platforms like OpenAI? What specific measures will you implement to ensure the confidentiality and protection of sensitive financial information?
  3. Many similar products receive feedback about lack of features, such as multi-currency support, and integration with budgeting tools. How will your product differentiate itself and ensure the functionality of your product exceeds user's expectations?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 30
  • Engagement: Low
    • Average number of comments: 3
  • Net use signal: 34.4%
    • Positive use signal: 38.2%
    • Negative use signal: 3.8%
  • Net buy signal: 2.6%
    • Positive buy signal: 5.1%
    • Negative buy signal: 2.5%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Expense AI - Smart expense tracking with AI-powered receipt scanning

12 Dec 2024 Budgeting Fintech Accounting

ExpenseAI simplifies expense management with AI-powered tools. Snap receipts, auto-forward emails, or upload files for seamless tracking. Automate categorization, generate reports and stay on top of budgets effortlessly. Your smarter way to manage finances! 🚀

Users find the product useful and easy to manage, particularly praising its receipt scanning and expense tracking capabilities. The AI-powered features, especially reminders, are highly recommended for transforming personal finance management. The app is noted for its steady feature releases and effectiveness in daily finance tracking.

Avatar
63
7
42.9%
14.3%
7
63
42.9%
14.3%
Relevance

Built an AI Money Tracker as Soloprenuer

13 Sep 2024 Artificial Intelligence Personal Finance Money

Hello everyone, I was always thinking about how I can increase my finances to get out of the rat race. Apart from increasing my income, the other approach I did is to reduce my expenses and hence I started my journey on expense tracking.I have tried a few apps and most of the time these apps are too complicated and I didn't manage to consistently key in my expense. Though there are some apps that provide link to bank account spending but I think that defeats the purpose of expense tracker since I believe only by manually input your spending in, only you'll be aware of your spending.This drives me to have a thought about how can I improve this and I decided to create my own app to make this work. I created Rolly: AI Money Tracker - a new AI expense tracker where you can easily record your transactions just by chatting with our bot Rolly and it will automatically record and categorise the transaction into the most suitable category (you can also create any of your own category and it will also take care of it in consideration). Demo video here. More features like budgeting are on the way, stay tuned!App Store: https://apps.apple.com/au/app/rolly-ai-money-tracker/id66365...Play Store: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.jc.rollymo...Anyone that have any feedback or needs for any new feature, do feel free to let me know and I'm happy to discuss and incorporate it. Thanks.

Cool app, AI seems angry, needs currency conversion.

AI seems angry, needs currency conversion.

Avatar
3
1
1
3
Relevance

Rolly: AI Money Tracker - Makes expense tracking simpler and interesting with AI

15 Sep 2024 Personal Finance Android Money

Designed for convenience and accuracy, Rolly harnesses advanced AI technology to automatically record and categorize your expenses and income through simple, intuitive chat interactions.

Users find Rolly innovative and appreciate its unique bot for making expense tracking more engaging. A specific question was raised about whether the app automatically converts currencies when saving expenses.

Avatar
29
2
50.0%
2
29
50.0%
Relevance

MonAi - AI powered expense tracker

20 Jun 2023 Artificial Intelligence Fintech User Experience

MonAI revolutionizes how you track your daily expenses with a fun, easy, and beautiful interface. Enter your expenses just like a voice message and it will automatically track it for you. No login required, all saved securely in your personal iCloud.

MonAI's Product Hunt launch received positive feedback, with users praising its voice input, automatic categorization, and ease of use for expense tracking. The beautiful UI was also noted. Some users inquired about the app's monetization strategy and use case details. There's interest in English language support, potentially due to the app's presence in the German Appstore. Suggestions included listing MonAI in AI directories and promoting it on platforms like WikiGPT3. One user expressed excitement at finding MonAI after conceiving a similar idea.

Users are concerned about MonAI's monetization strategy and its support for different currencies. There is also confusion regarding language support, specifically whether the app supports English, given its listing in the German App Store.

Avatar
104
12
41.7%
8.3%
12
104
41.7%
8.3%
Relevance

Monarch AI Assistant - Makes managing your money as easy as having a conversation

13 Jun 2023 Artificial Intelligence Fintech Money

Introducing the first AI-powered personal finance assistant that makes managing your money as easy as having a conversation. Built on top of Monarch's best-in-class personal finance app, available on web, iOS, and Android.

Monarch Money's Product Hunt launch garnered excitement from existing users eager to try new AI-powered features and tools. Many praised Monarch as a Mint alternative, highlighting its usability and valuable insights. There's enthusiasm for AI in finance, but some users prioritize core features like bug fixes and data privacy. Concerns were raised regarding financial data security with OpenAI. Questions about Open Banking integration, the AI stack, and sound design were asked. Suggestions included partnership benefits like spending summaries and app directory listings. Congratulations were offered on the launch.

Users appreciate the lack of forced credit card usage. However, concerns exist regarding the prioritization of AI/ChatGPT integration over essential bug fixes and core features. Managing multiple subscriptions is a pain point. A major concern revolves around data security when integrating with OpenAI, with users requesting more transparency and assurance.

Avatar
207
24
33.3%
0.0%
24
207
41.7%
4.2%
Relevance

Rolly: Your AI Money Tracker - Rolly: Effortless Expense Tracking with AI Precision

11 Aug 2024 Personal Finance Development No-Code

Rolly: Your AI Money Tracker simplifies finances with AI that records and categorizes your expenses and income. Just chat with Rolly, and it handles the rest. Enjoy seamless, accurate tracking and real-time financial insights.

Users are excited about the AI finance tracker, with one highlighting the genius of chatting to track expenses and its potential as a game-changer. There are questions about currency support, integrations, and the details of the freemium plan. The AI expense tracking functionality is particularly well-received.

Users expressed interest in multi-currency support and integration with budgeting tools. There were also concerns about the AI's learning curve and how quickly it would adapt to individual user habits.

Avatar
11
3
100.0%
3
11
100.0%
Relevance

Made an AI Money Tracker without any coding experience

28 Sep 2024 Artificial Intelligence Personal Finance Money

Hello everyone,I have created Rolly: AI Money Tracker - a new AI expense tracker where you can easily record your transactions just by chatting with our bot Rolly and it will automatically record and categorise the transaction into the most suitable category (you can also create any of your own category and it will also take care of it in consideration). You can always talk to the AI in any language and your transaction in any currency and it will always convert it into the base currency you've selected earlier. Rolly will also respond to your transaction in a interesting manner to make your expense tracker journey more interesting!App Store: https://apps.apple.com/au/app/rolly-ai-money-tracker/id66365...Play Store: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.jc.rollymo...Anyone that have any feedback or needs for any new feature, do feel free to let me know and I'm happy to discuss and incorporate it. Thanks.

Cool and terrifying. Local version for privacy?

Concern about privacy

Avatar
3
1
1
3
Relevance

ExpenSee - A expense tracking app

09 Jul 2023 Personal Finance

ExpenSee simplifies expense tracking and financial management with natural language input, voice recognition, photo capture, Siri integration, extensive app integrations, and robust security.

Avatar
78
78
Relevance

Surplus: auto-track expenses - One-stop shop for smart and effortless expense management

10 Apr 2024 Personal Finance Budgeting Finance

Understand your money moves better with Surplus. Our intuitive app seamlessly connects to your bank accounts, automatically tracking your incomes, expenses and recurring payments. Say goodbye to tedious manual entry—Surplus does it all for you.

Surplus is a platform for tracking and optimizing expenses with bill reminders. Users congratulate the team on the launch and express excitement about the product's potential for managing payments, tracking spending and subscriptions, and improving financial literacy. There's interest in credit-based insights and hopes for credit card/MF tracking features. Commenters wish Raj and the team success.

The primary criticism is a feature request for credit card and mutual fund (MF) tracking implementation. This suggests users desire more comprehensive financial tracking capabilities within the product.

Avatar
31
10
20.0%
10
31
20.0%
Relevance

Expense tracker and money manager (budget,etc.)

12 Feb 2023 Personal Finance Android Money

Hey guys,I just recently finished my Android app and in general it's about money management which includes, expense tracking, budget manager, accounts, etc. For now, it only includes expense tracking and monthly statistic with more to come soon!The reasons why I made this app knowing that there's a lot of similar app out there are that I love building new product and I would love to build an expense tracker and money manager that's more rich in features and offline-first (data saved locally in the device).If you're using Android please check it out and let me know what you think about it! Any feedback or advice are welcomed. Thank you!

Android money management app with expense tracking and statistics.

Limited features currently available.

Avatar
1
1
1
1
Relevance

Money Tracker - Simple & intuitive expense app

08 Nov 2024 Fintech Productivity Money

Money Tracker is an ultra-lightweight expense management app that simplifies budget tracking and spending analysis. It offers secure, offline data storage (iCloud only), an intuitive Apple-standard design, and powerful insights through charts and reports.

Avatar
6
6
Relevance

Expense Now – Money Organizer - Track, Budget, Save and Take Control of Your Finances

30 Aug 2024 Personal Finance Android Money

Expense Now is a user-friendly budgeting app that helps you track your income and expenses effortlessly. With its intuitive interface and powerful features, Expense Now empowers you to take control of your finances and make informed financial decisions.

Expense Now app is being lauded for simplifying expense tracking and budgeting. Users appreciate features like receipt photo uploads and expense categorization. Several users inquired about the app's differentiation, user experience (UX), and the availability of a freemium model. There's also interest in manual expense input. Overall, the app is considered handy and helpful, showing promise after its launch.

The primary criticism raised is the extent of manual input required to effectively use the product. Users are questioning the level of automation and the amount of hands-on effort needed, implying a potential concern about the product's efficiency or ease of use.

Avatar
7
7
42.9%
7
7
42.9%
Relevance

Budgety - Budgeting, expense tracking, money manager

09 Jul 2024 Personal Finance Android Money

Budgety is a budgeting, expense tracking and money management app. Track your income, expenses, savings and progress towards your financial goals. Analyze your spending patterns, goals, identify areas for improvement and make informed decisions

Users appreciate the shared budget feature for financial tracking and the fast onboarding process. The personalized transaction notes are useful for expense tracking, and the app provides valuable spending insights to identify potential areas for cutbacks.

Avatar
7
4
75.0%
4
7
75.0%
Top