Should I Build It Should I Build It
16 Apr 2025
Freelance

I want to build a Freelance marketplace that works like fiverr or ...

...Upwork

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Competitive Terrain

While there's clear interest in your idea, the market is saturated with similar offerings. To succeed, your product needs to stand out by offering something unique that competitors aren't providing. The challenge here isn’t whether there’s demand, but how you can capture attention and keep it.

Should You Build It?

Not before thinking deeply about differentiation.

Your are here

Entering the freelance marketplace arena is a bold move, given that there are 21 similar products already out there. That's a high number, meaning competition is stiff. The good news is that there's clearly a demand for these kinds of services, as evidenced by the medium engagement across these platforms, although the use signal is neutral, which is not uncommon. It's like stepping into a crowded stadium, so you'll need a killer strategy to stand out and not get lost in the noise. In your favor, the positive buy signal is extremely high, in the top 5% of products, suggesting that people see real value in solutions that streamline freelancing. Your challenge is to offer something so compelling that users choose your platform over established players.

Recommendations

  1. First, dive deep into what those 21 competitors are doing right and, more importantly, wrong. Read the reviews and comments on those platforms. Look for pain points users are consistently complaining about. Several similar products received complaints about the website design, missing features (custom CSS editor, localization options, custom domains, embed capabilities), and unclear pricing, while praising user-friendly interfaces and comprehensive features. Make sure to identify at least three key areas where you can significantly outperform the existing options. Don't just be 'another' marketplace; aim to be the marketplace for a specific niche or with a unique value proposition.
  2. Consider niching down. Instead of trying to be everything to everyone, focus on a specific type of freelancer or a particular industry. For example, you could specialize in creative freelancers (designers, writers, videographers) or focus on a specific industry like healthcare or finance. This will allow you to tailor your platform to the unique needs of that niche, making it more attractive to both freelancers and clients. For example, several comments mentioned the need for better matching of freelancers with clients, so perhaps you can use AI to facilitate better matches.
  3. Develop a crystal-clear brand and marketing strategy that highlights your unique selling proposition (USP). What makes your marketplace different and better? Make sure this message is front and center in all your marketing materials. Consider a referral program to incentivize early adoption. Many similar products received positive feedback due to user-friendly design, so keep this in mind.
  4. Engage relentlessly with your early users. Gather feedback, iterate quickly, and build a community around your platform. The early adopters are key to creating a buzz and spreading the word. Pay close attention to customer support; be responsive and helpful, addressing any issues promptly. This can be a major differentiator, as many established platforms are known for poor customer service.
  5. Address the criticism seen in similar products. Make sure you have custom CSS editor, localization options, custom domains, and embed capabilities. Also make sure your pricing structure is clear from the start. Requiring to schedule a call for pricing is a source of concern.

Questions

  1. Given the crowded market, what are the 2-3 absolute must-have features that freelancers in your chosen niche are currently missing in existing platforms?
  2. How can you build a community around your marketplace that fosters loyalty and advocacy, turning users into active promoters of your platform?
  3. What is your plan to ensure high-quality matches between freelancers and clients on your platform, and how will you continuously improve this matching process over time?

Your are here

Entering the freelance marketplace arena is a bold move, given that there are 21 similar products already out there. That's a high number, meaning competition is stiff. The good news is that there's clearly a demand for these kinds of services, as evidenced by the medium engagement across these platforms, although the use signal is neutral, which is not uncommon. It's like stepping into a crowded stadium, so you'll need a killer strategy to stand out and not get lost in the noise. In your favor, the positive buy signal is extremely high, in the top 5% of products, suggesting that people see real value in solutions that streamline freelancing. Your challenge is to offer something so compelling that users choose your platform over established players.

Recommendations

  1. First, dive deep into what those 21 competitors are doing right and, more importantly, wrong. Read the reviews and comments on those platforms. Look for pain points users are consistently complaining about. Several similar products received complaints about the website design, missing features (custom CSS editor, localization options, custom domains, embed capabilities), and unclear pricing, while praising user-friendly interfaces and comprehensive features. Make sure to identify at least three key areas where you can significantly outperform the existing options. Don't just be 'another' marketplace; aim to be the marketplace for a specific niche or with a unique value proposition.
  2. Consider niching down. Instead of trying to be everything to everyone, focus on a specific type of freelancer or a particular industry. For example, you could specialize in creative freelancers (designers, writers, videographers) or focus on a specific industry like healthcare or finance. This will allow you to tailor your platform to the unique needs of that niche, making it more attractive to both freelancers and clients. For example, several comments mentioned the need for better matching of freelancers with clients, so perhaps you can use AI to facilitate better matches.
  3. Develop a crystal-clear brand and marketing strategy that highlights your unique selling proposition (USP). What makes your marketplace different and better? Make sure this message is front and center in all your marketing materials. Consider a referral program to incentivize early adoption. Many similar products received positive feedback due to user-friendly design, so keep this in mind.
  4. Engage relentlessly with your early users. Gather feedback, iterate quickly, and build a community around your platform. The early adopters are key to creating a buzz and spreading the word. Pay close attention to customer support; be responsive and helpful, addressing any issues promptly. This can be a major differentiator, as many established platforms are known for poor customer service.
  5. Address the criticism seen in similar products. Make sure you have custom CSS editor, localization options, custom domains, and embed capabilities. Also make sure your pricing structure is clear from the start. Requiring to schedule a call for pricing is a source of concern.

Questions

  1. Given the crowded market, what are the 2-3 absolute must-have features that freelancers in your chosen niche are currently missing in existing platforms?
  2. How can you build a community around your marketplace that fosters loyalty and advocacy, turning users into active promoters of your platform?
  3. What is your plan to ensure high-quality matches between freelancers and clients on your platform, and how will you continuously improve this matching process over time?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 21
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 8
  • Net use signal: 25.9%
    • Positive use signal: 25.9%
    • Negative use signal: 0.0%
  • Net buy signal: 3.9%
    • Positive buy signal: 3.9%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.0%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

3veta Marketplace Builder - Build your own professional services marketplace in a day

12 Feb 2023 API Prototyping Tech

The most powerful solution to build service marketplaces from scratch. 3veta Marketplace Builder handles everything - from marketplace listings to managing bookings, in-app video calls, payments, and much more.

The comments express overwhelmingly positive sentiment towards 3veta's Marketplace Builder launch. Users are excited about its potential impact on service businesses. Many highlight the platform's user-friendly interface, customization options, and comprehensive features like booking, payments, video consultations, and analytics. Several users emphasized the convenience and time-saving aspects of the platform. There are inquiries about pricing, Spanish translation, subscriptions, custom design options and reasons to switch from existing platforms. Some recommend an interactive demo on the landing page and praise the team and product quality.

Users criticize the current website design and lack essential features such as a custom CSS editor, localization options, custom domains, and embed capabilities. The absence of a clear pricing structure and the requirement to schedule a call for pricing information are also points of concern.

Avatar
261
72
44.4%
6.9%
72
261
44.4%
6.9%
Relevance

StackWalls AI - AI powered freelancing marketplace

25 Jun 2023 Artificial Intelligence Business Freelance

Our AI-powered freelancing marketplace crafts tailored no-code business solutions for you, and instantly matches you up with the right freelancer with a magic price quote ✨

The Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with many users congratulating the team on their achievement and wishing them success. Several comments highlighted the product's simplicity, power, and innovative use of AI to benefit businesses and freelancers. Suggestions were made to increase visibility by listing the app on AI directories like wikigpt3.com. Users expressed excitement about the platform's potential for better freelancer matches. Overall, the launch was well-received with praise for the idea and execution.

Users criticize Upwork for failing to provide reliable matches for freelancers, leading to dissatisfaction with the platform's core service.

Avatar
180
21
9.5%
4.8%
21
180
9.5%
4.8%
Relevance

I built a solution to growing clients for Freelancers

20 May 2024 SaaS Productivity Freelance

Hey HN,A few months ago I lost my job in a tech startup. I started to do freelance work as a marketer and I realized that it was difficult to find clients. Upwork and all other platforms are so convoluted and the fee is ridiculous.So I created an all-in-one platform to help grow and MANAGE your freelance clients. You have your own personal portfolio, manage clients, invoice, projects and more.I'll be in beta test soon and I'm excited to solve this problem.- John

The product was built to help grow a freelancing business. A user pointed out that Show HN is intended for user-created projects.

The product lacks a proper platform, which is a significant drawback for users.

Avatar
2
2
2
2
Relevance

Speed Build Marketplace - Launch your online marketplace MVP in days - not months

25 Aug 2024 Startup Lessons Website Builder YouTube

Online two-sided marketplace boilerplate built using Next.js (App Router), Tailwind CSS, Clerk Auth, MongoDB and Stripe Connect. With it, you have everything needed to quickly launch your own marketplace MVP.

The Speedbuildmarketplace launch is generating excitement as a potential game-changer for quickly launching MVPs. However, the challenges of building marketplaces are recognized, with emphasis on the importance of rapidly testing the concept using minimal technology.

Avatar
15
3
33.3%
3
15
33.3%
Relevance

eBusiness Spaces (Pre-Launch) - Your one-stop solution for managing client work and payments

04 Jan 2023 Web App Productivity Task Management

eBusiness Spaces is a comprehensive platform that helps freelancers and small business owners manage the process of working with clients, from quoting and invoicing to managing projects and ensuring timely payment and payouts.

The Product Hunt launch received positive feedback, with users appreciating the product and the specific use case it addresses. The platform is seen as user-friendly, particularly beneficial for freelancers in streamlining client work and payment processes. Congratulations were also offered on the launch.

Avatar
69
3
33.3%
3
69
33.3%
Relevance

A minimalist, privacy-first site to sell your skills as a developer

29 Jul 2024 Developer Tools Freelance

Hi HN!A lot of us developers have websites. Why not add a "Hire Me" button for potential clients? Maybe we can make some extra money like this or even in time make it as our full-time freelance business.I don't think I like Upwork (low prices?), TopTal (too exclusive?) or Contra (too many features?)I just need a super simple site to list my skills and past projects. Maybe, and only maybe, there could also be some helpful tools, like an option to book a consultation call with me for a price.It’s currently very simple on purpose and I’m choosing new features very slowly. Next up: - See how many times your profile is visited - Allow creating fixed price projectsWould be fun to hear what you think?Rauno

Add 'Hire Me' button for developers' websites.

Dislikes Upwork, TopTal, Contra.

Avatar
11
1
100.0%
1
11
100.0%
Relevance

Notion Upwork Freelancer - The ultimate dashboard for managing your freelancing.

06 Oct 2023 Productivity Freelance Notion

Organize and manage your business with the first ever all-in-one Notion workspace for Upwork freelancers. This Notion template is packed with everything you need to manage your jobs from Upwork, complete tasks faster, focus on what's important, and more.

The Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with users congratulating Matt and the team. Users found the dashboard well-thought-out and helpful, describing the tool as comprehensive for freelancers. The Notion template was praised for its ability to track income and expenses and manage projects, saving users time and effort. The dedicated mobile view was also highlighted as a beneficial feature. Overall, users considered the product innovative, well-done, and amazing.

Avatar
114
11
9.1%
11
114
9.1%
Relevance

I built a tool to help you write Upwork proposals

27 May 2024 Productivity

Hello HN,I’m a solopreneur and I love building things. I've been freelancing on Upwork for over five years and I know how hard it can be to get started. So I built BidBuilder to help freelancers cut out their work and improve their chances of getting hired.If you're tired of spending hours on proposals without results, give BidBuilder a try.I’d love to hear your thoughts and feedback. Let’s discuss!

Proposals are high quality, not generic.

Avatar
2
1
1
2
Relevance

Workv.io - Product designed to simplify your freelance management

01 Sep 2023 Productivity Task Management Freelance

Streamline Your Freelance Business in single place & Manage your all Clients, services, Time, Meetings, Invoices, Proposals, Contracts, profile & more in single Place.

Workv.io is receiving positive feedback as a valuable tool for freelancers, particularly due to its AI assistance and client management features. Users appreciate the well-designed dashboard UI. The launch is being widely congratulated, with excitement expressed for its potential to organize freelance life. Many are noting the lifetime free access. There's also expressed interest in potential integrations.

Users expressed a desire for more clarity on how the AI adapts to the specific needs of freelancers. Additionally, seamless data synchronization with other tools was requested as a key feature enhancement for improved workflow integration.

Avatar
151
12
8.3%
12
151
8.3%
Relevance

Freelance Pro – a browser extension for Upwork freelancers

02 Jun 2023 Freelance

Hey HN! I've created this browser extension which converts pricing on Upwork into your local currency and adds it to the site so you can see how much you'll earn after fees in most currencies. There's also a calculator where you can see how much you might earn for an hourly job based on your working hours and the job length which you can play around with.I'm hoping to continue building some useful tools for freelancers who use Upwork so I'd welcome any feedback you have on this first stage!

Fantastic work! Questions about currency conversion and API.

Avatar
2
1
1
2
Relevance

Freelancer Hub - Streamline your freelance business effortlessly

06 Jul 2024 Task Management Freelance Notion

Freelancer Hub is the ultimate Notion template designed for freelancers to manage clients, projects, tasks, and finances all in one place. Pre-designed templates for invoices, contracts, and proposals will save you time and help you grow your business.

The Freelancer Hub Notion template launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with many users congratulating Steffy and Marco. Users consistently praised the template's structure, simplicity, clean design, and ease of use. Several comments highlighted its utility for client, project, and finance management. Some users inquired about compatibility with other platforms like Trello or Asana. Overall, the template is considered a complete package and a useful tool for serious business owners. Many wished the team success with their launch.

Avatar
86
21
4.8%
21
86
4.8%
Relevance

Freelance Dashboard - Track clients, projects, tasks, deadlines like a Pro!

11 Aug 2024 CRM Customer Communication Freelance

Take control of your freelance hustle, Stay organized, track clients, projects, tasks, fianance and crush deadlines like a Pro! Say goodbye to scattered spreadsheets and disjointed systems—embrace the freedom of freelancing with confidence.

The Product Hunt launch is receiving positive feedback, particularly regarding a freelancer template. Users are excited about its potential to boost productivity and streamline freelancer workflows by covering all necessary aspects. One user explicitly congratulated the launch team and highlighted the template's comprehensive nature. The overall sentiment suggests strong approval and excitement for the product's value to freelancers.

Avatar
7
2
100.0%
2
7
100.0%
Top