Created web app for bookmarking across multiple browsers.

The Product Hunt launch garnered positive interest, with users expressing excitement about the tool's potential for boosting productivity and organization. Several users are eager to try it out when it becomes available, highlighting its features for managing favorite sites and providing AI recommendations. One user showed interest but was hesitant to share their email. Overall, the launch was considered straightforward, and commenters wished the product well.

The primary criticism revolves around the reluctance to provide an email address before the product launch. Users are hesitant to share their email information upfront.

Users find the messaging fragmented and the purpose unclear. There is a request for live examples and the ability to create pages without signing up. One user is not interested but shares first impressions and offers congratulations.

Users criticized the product for having fragmented messaging and an unclear purpose. They also mentioned that the website lacks clarity and requires sign-up, which is inconvenient. Additionally, the absence of interactive demos was highlighted as a significant drawback.

Cool project, saw it on Reddit, made my own tool

Made my own tool with different approach

Users express excitement about new features and the Bookmarker.me 1.0 launch on Product Hunt. One user, however, reports an unsuccessful login and seeks clarification on whether it's a demo issue or an error. The positive sentiment revolves around the product's improvements and the anticipation of trying the new version.

The primary criticism reported is login failure. Users are unable to successfully log in to the platform, hindering their ability to use the product. This issue needs immediate attention to ensure accessibility.

Users are interested in local functionalities such as running, note addition, and API access. The self-hosted nature with AI tagging is appreciated, but there are concerns about the lack of pricing, contact information, and local storage options, leading to trust issues. The need for return shipping is questioned, and while one user finds the service priceless, an infosec expert points out potential user negligence in security and privacy. There is also a sentiment of agreement and sadness expressed by users.

Users criticized the product for lacking local run capabilities, note addition, documentation association, and a local API. There were concerns about the absence of pricing information, contact options, and local storage, leading to trust issues. The refund policy was deemed unnecessary, and there were remarks about users being careless with security and privacy.

The Show HN product, likely a bookmark management tool, received mixed feedback. Users praised its features, potential, and neat design, with some expressing interest in self-hosting options like Linkwarden. Authentication methods, including next-auth and LDAP, were discussed. Monetization strategies and project vision were queried, with a $4/month fee mentioned. Technical aspects like using Next.js, Prisma, and Docker were debated, with some concerns about resource usage on small VPS. Suggestions included free tiers with ads, integration of SingleFile support, and full-text search capabilities. Issues with Safari extension support and comparisons to other tools like Raindrop.io, Archivebox, and Floccus were made. Some users were interested in collaborative features, while others preferred non-collaborative use. The community also discussed archiving, with decentralized solutions and the ability to save and search web pages being important to some. Overall, the product was seen as cool and promising, with room for improvement and expansion.

-Github lists not collaborative or searchable. - Freemium model needed for massive scale. - Missing central user authentication. - Figure out merging existing users and data. - Only username/password as default. - no export functionality - Why save a click? - Not suitable for small VPS. - Doesn't need collaboration feature - Dislikes JS apps - archive.org problematic, lacks collaboration features. - Archive.org problematic, not allowing more sites. - Archived content may be removed under pressure. - info on removal process is hard to find - No periodic update check option. - Websites require addons to be tolerable. - HamsterBase is not open source. - No docker version available yet - Focus on service benefits, not technical details. - Crashes on Mac M1 due to Prisma. - Unclear if highlights and annotations are saved. - Limited to MVP at launch. - Lacks SingleFile support. - Issues bundling Prisma packages in Next standalone mode. - No text search for bookmarks. - Not a single tool solution. - Left column is too narrow - Linkwarden lacks automatic archive.org submission. - Sluggish and buggy. - Never used local personal search engine. - Lacks API, YaCY disappointing. - Archiving stops after a few hundred bookmarks. - Not actively maintained. - Not top priority. - No page for most popular collections - People don't use Zotero for archiving - No Safari extension or iOS app available. - Missing or broken documentation link - Full-text search doesn't cover website contents. - Effort not diminished, but Floccus preferred. - Collaborative feature missing. - Lacks UI for managing, archiving bookmarks - Not user friendly. - Safari not user-friendly. - Not user-friendly for non-Apple users. - This wasn't an answer - Artificial limitations imposed by Apple. - Developer fee to publish extension app. - No Safari support due to Apple's policies. - Floccus lacks features. - Browser extension not working, manual URL addition. - Common login error with Shiori server. - Web app not actual browser bookmark sync. - Questioning need for third-party bookmark syncer. - No cross-browser sync, Safari missing. - Firefox UI could be better. - Can't use own server - Browsers lack advanced bookmark management features. - LinkedIn causes pain to humanity.

The Notion Bookmark Manager template launch on Product Hunt received overwhelmingly positive feedback. Users congratulate Maestro on the launch and praise the template's usefulness for organizing and centralizing bookmarks. Many highlighted its potential to be a lifesaver and wished they had it sooner, especially for academic work. The convenience of managing bookmarks within Notion, instead of just websites, was appreciated. Several users suggested a Chrome extension to enhance the template's functionality. Overall, the template is considered a valuable tool for Notion users to streamline bookmark management.

Doesn't work with browser clearing data on exit

Incompatible with privacy settings

EasyMark, created by solopreneur Kapil, addresses bookmark management challenges and is well-curated. Users highly recommend it for its productivity benefits, noting it enhances browsing by making it easier and more interactive. One user inquired about the possibility of sharing managed data with friends, indicating a potential feature request. Overall, the product is seen as bringing essential positive change to browsing habits.

The provided comment does not contain any criticism. Therefore, a summary of criticisms cannot be generated.

The Product Hunt launch received positive feedback, with users congratulating the makers and expressing excitement. Users praised the idea, clean interface, and usefulness of the tool. Bookmarker was highlighted for solving the problem of having too many open tabs. Several users expressed they absolutely loved the product and are excited about future features.

Users express excitement for the bookmark management tool, praising its simplicity, clean design, smart sorting, and dark mode. Many are eager to try it for organizing messy bookmarks and decluttering browsers. The visual display with icons and titles is well-received. Key features highlighted include quick search, custom categories (requested by many), and tab management. Some users suggest improvements such as AI features, custom tags, folder categorization, and off-canvas implementation. The tool's usefulness for agencies and managing numerous bookmarks is noted.

Users criticize the product for lacking uniqueness compared to other bookmarking tools and its Chrome-centric focus, requesting integration with other browsers. Many dislike the new tab replacement feature and seek alternative use options. Users desire enhanced bookmark management features, including categorization into folders, custom tags, and the ability to move/edit bookmarks within the app. Conflicts with other extensions, like daily.dev, were also noted. Improvements to Chrome's bookmarking system and custom categories are suggested as beneficial next steps.