Your are here

Turning long-form content like YouTube videos and podcasts into shorter posts across multiple platforms is an idea many have explored, placing it firmly in the 'Swamp' category where numerous mediocre solutions already exist. With 10 similar products already out there, the competition is high. The average engagement is low (2 comments), suggesting that existing solutions haven't quite captured users' attention. There are no net use or buy signals, indicating neutrality but also suggesting a lack of strong positive or negative sentiment. Because of this saturation and lack of clear market enthusiasm, you'll face an uphill battle to create something that stands out and generates revenue. You'll need a REALLY unique angle to succeed.

Recommendations

1. First, deeply investigate why current solutions in this space aren't resonating with users. What are their pain points? What unmet needs exist? Read the user's criticism from the similar product launches (e.g. the tool that summarizes 3-hour YouTube videos was criticized for lack of free trial, spelling errors, and insufficient examples). Don't just build a "me too" product; find a real gap.
2. If you decide to move forward, focus on a very specific niche or user group that is not well-served by existing tools. For example, instead of targeting all YouTube users, consider focusing on academics who need to quickly extract key information from lectures, or marketers who repurpose content for social media.
3. Another approach is to create tools that enhance existing platforms rather than trying to replace them. Think about building integrations or plugins that work seamlessly with YouTube, podcasting platforms, or social media management tools. Consider building tools for the existing providers instead of building yet another competing platform.
4. Explore adjacent problems related to content creation and distribution. Perhaps there's a need for better content discovery tools, improved video editing software, or more effective ways to monetize content. Broaden your perspective.
5. Given the crowded market and the challenges faced by similar products, seriously consider whether this is the best use of your time and resources. There might be other, more promising opportunities that align better with your skills and interests. This is especially true given the negative feedback from existing similar products (slow speeds, mobile issues, feature overlap etc.).
6. Consider the criticism that some similar products faced: users asking how the idea differs from the YouTube Clip feature, or the slow speed of similar video clip search engines. Think how you would clearly differentiate yourself from existing free features to be successful.

Questions

1. What specific, unmet needs are you addressing that current solutions in the long-form to short-form content space are failing to fulfill?
2. How will you differentiate your product from existing solutions, especially considering the negative feedback regarding lack of originality and feature overlap?
3. Given the low engagement observed in similar products, what innovative strategies will you employ to attract and retain users?