Should I Build It Should I Build It
19 Apr 2025
Data Data & Analytics Data Visualization Analytics

A data dashboard for cities, to easily extract insights for publicly ...

...available data for each city.

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Freemium

People love using similar products but resist paying. You’ll need to either find who will pay or create additional value that’s worth paying for.

Should You Build It?

Build but think about differentiation and monetization.

Your are here

Creating a data dashboard for cities to extract insights from public data puts you in the "Freemium" category. This means users are likely to use your product but may resist paying for it. With 22 similar products already out there, competition is significant, indicating a well-explored but potentially saturated market. Average engagement for these types of products is moderate, with around 7 comments per product launch. To succeed, you'll need to identify a strong differentiation factor and a clear path to monetization. Your core challenge is to provide enough value in the free version to attract users while creating compelling premium features that justify a paid subscription. Think deeply about who in city government or public services would truly benefit from readily accessible data insights.

Recommendations

  1. Start by identifying the specific user within city government or related sectors who would benefit most from your free data dashboard. Understanding their daily workflows and pain points will guide your feature development and prioritization.
  2. Based on user feedback and usage patterns, create premium features that cater to power users or specific departmental needs. These could include advanced analytics, custom report generation, or integrations with other city systems. Referencing the feedback from similar products, focus on functionalities such as AI-driven metric suggestions which has received interest.
  3. Explore a team-based pricing model rather than individual subscriptions. This aligns with how city governments operate and could be more appealing for budget allocation. Consider offering tiered pricing based on the number of users or the level of features unlocked.
  4. Offer personalized onboarding, training, or consulting services to help city staff effectively use the dashboard and derive actionable insights. This could be a valuable upsell, particularly for smaller municipalities with limited data analysis expertise. Given issues raised in similar projects consider integrations with tools like Google Analytics API.
  5. Implement a phased pricing approach, starting with a low introductory price and gradually increasing it as you add more features and demonstrate value. Gather user feedback on perceived value versus price to fine-tune your pricing strategy. In light of comments about dashboards by Equals consider having a clearly visible pricing page.
  6. Focus on seamless integration with existing city data sources and systems. Make it easy for users to import, export, and analyze data without requiring extensive technical skills. Address concerns about dataset privacy, particularly when handling sensitive government data. Ensure compliance with data security regulations and implement robust access controls.
  7. Prioritize fast performance, especially when dealing with large datasets. Optimize your code and infrastructure to ensure quick loading times and responsive interactions. Consider caching frequently accessed data to improve performance.
  8. Given users' confusion with similar products that have confusing READMEs make sure to make yours as clear as possible including screenshots and code snippets. This reduces the learning curve and increases adoption.

Questions

  1. What specific data sources will your dashboard integrate with, and how will you ensure data accuracy and reliability?
  2. How will you differentiate your data dashboard from existing solutions, and what unique value proposition will you offer to city governments?
  3. How will you balance the need for a free tier with the desire to generate revenue, and what pricing strategies will you employ to encourage users to upgrade to a paid subscription?

Your are here

Creating a data dashboard for cities to extract insights from public data puts you in the "Freemium" category. This means users are likely to use your product but may resist paying for it. With 22 similar products already out there, competition is significant, indicating a well-explored but potentially saturated market. Average engagement for these types of products is moderate, with around 7 comments per product launch. To succeed, you'll need to identify a strong differentiation factor and a clear path to monetization. Your core challenge is to provide enough value in the free version to attract users while creating compelling premium features that justify a paid subscription. Think deeply about who in city government or public services would truly benefit from readily accessible data insights.

Recommendations

  1. Start by identifying the specific user within city government or related sectors who would benefit most from your free data dashboard. Understanding their daily workflows and pain points will guide your feature development and prioritization.
  2. Based on user feedback and usage patterns, create premium features that cater to power users or specific departmental needs. These could include advanced analytics, custom report generation, or integrations with other city systems. Referencing the feedback from similar products, focus on functionalities such as AI-driven metric suggestions which has received interest.
  3. Explore a team-based pricing model rather than individual subscriptions. This aligns with how city governments operate and could be more appealing for budget allocation. Consider offering tiered pricing based on the number of users or the level of features unlocked.
  4. Offer personalized onboarding, training, or consulting services to help city staff effectively use the dashboard and derive actionable insights. This could be a valuable upsell, particularly for smaller municipalities with limited data analysis expertise. Given issues raised in similar projects consider integrations with tools like Google Analytics API.
  5. Implement a phased pricing approach, starting with a low introductory price and gradually increasing it as you add more features and demonstrate value. Gather user feedback on perceived value versus price to fine-tune your pricing strategy. In light of comments about dashboards by Equals consider having a clearly visible pricing page.
  6. Focus on seamless integration with existing city data sources and systems. Make it easy for users to import, export, and analyze data without requiring extensive technical skills. Address concerns about dataset privacy, particularly when handling sensitive government data. Ensure compliance with data security regulations and implement robust access controls.
  7. Prioritize fast performance, especially when dealing with large datasets. Optimize your code and infrastructure to ensure quick loading times and responsive interactions. Consider caching frequently accessed data to improve performance.
  8. Given users' confusion with similar products that have confusing READMEs make sure to make yours as clear as possible including screenshots and code snippets. This reduces the learning curve and increases adoption.

Questions

  1. What specific data sources will your dashboard integrate with, and how will you ensure data accuracy and reliability?
  2. How will you differentiate your data dashboard from existing solutions, and what unique value proposition will you offer to city governments?
  3. How will you balance the need for a free tier with the desire to generate revenue, and what pricing strategies will you employ to encourage users to upgrade to a paid subscription?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 22
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 7
  • Net use signal: 8.5%
    • Positive use signal: 10.0%
    • Negative use signal: 1.5%
  • Net buy signal: -0.8%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.4%
    • Negative buy signal: 1.2%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Urban Stats

06 Aug 2023 Maps

This is a project one of my friends has been working on for a while. The goal is to aggregate data from the U.S. census and some other sources across basically any sort of region/administrative boundary/district/statistical area one could imagine in the United States. This is comparable to (and created somewhat out of frustration with) the U.S. Census's Quickfacts, but with way more types of regions and types of statistics.Please let us know if you have any suggestions for types of regions to add, or for other statistics to add (or anything else that might be an improvement).

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

valencia-now – real-time traffic information about Valencia

27 Mar 2024 Developer Tools

This simple dashboard allows visualization of real-time, historical, and aggregated data on traffic and air quality in Valencia (Spain).Using public data sources, processed with Tinybird and visualized with Streamlit

Users report that the site appears to be broken, with HTTP referrer restrictions causing 429 errors. A link is provided for reference.

Users have reported that the site is broken and that the HTTP referrer restriction is causing 429 errors.

Avatar
10
3
3
10
Relevance

PickYourPlace – Making location-based data accessible for home seekers

05 Nov 2024 SaaS

I built a tool to help people make data-driven decisions about where to live, starting with Calgary, AB. Instead of just showing property listings, it aggregates and visualizes:- Historical property values (up to 20 years of municipal assessment data)- Crime statistics (population-adjusted, categorized by type)- Proximity analysis (schools, healthcare, transit, amenities)- Flood risk assessment- Travel time calculations for different modes of transportTech stack:- Frontend: Vue.js with Nuxt.js (hybrid SSR/SPA architecture)- Styling: shadcn-vue and Tailwind CSS- Maps: Mapbox with PMTiles for efficient vector tile serving- Database: PostgreSQL with PostGIS and H3 for spatial indexing and queries- Architecture: Explore page runs as SPA for smooth interactions, other pages SSR for better SEO/performanceDemo: https://www.pickyourplace.app/Background: Built initial prototype 3 years ago for an AWS hackathon. Recently rebuilt and launched v1.0 with up-to-date data and improved system design. Currently free to use, planning to expand to more cities.Would love feedback from the HN community on:1. Which cities to add next2. Additional datasets that would be valuable3. Features that would make this more useful for your use case

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Dashify, transform raw data into dashboards easily

25 Mar 2024 SaaS

Hey everyone, I wanted to share something exciting I've built recently - Dashify, a user-friendly platform that simplifies data visualization.You can pull in data from any APIs using automated GET/POST requests. Dashify also offers integrations with AirTable, Hubspot, Youtube, Google Sheets, and many more to come, enabling you to consolidate data from various sources in a single, unified dashboard.Dashify is designed with a user-friendly interface, making it accessible to users of all skill levels. It also offers collaborative features, allowing you to share interactive dashboards with team members, clients, or stakeholders. You can collaborate, discuss insights, and work together seamlessly.Let me know your thoughts on this and welcome to all feedback!

Pricing page doesn’t show prices

Pricing page lacks prices

Avatar
1
1
1
1
Relevance

I built a Platform for Creating and Sharing Data-Driven Dashboards

24 May 2024 Analytics

Hey HN,I've built a platform where individuals or businesses can create and share dashboards with ease. I've included integrations with Airtable, Google Sheets, Youtube Analytics and Hubspot, as well as APIs using automated GET/POST requests.I've designed it with simplicity in mind, requiring no technical knowledge.Let me know your thoughts and suggestions!

Congrats on release! Comparison to Chartbrew?

Avatar
2
1
1
2
Relevance

I made a lightweight data visualization platform

25 Oct 2024 Data Visualization Developer Tools

Hey everyone,I’ve been working on a project called PrettyData, a lightweight data visualization platform. My goal is to make it easier for anyone to turn raw data into beautiful dashboards, even without deep technical skills. Just by easily clicking through.What it does:- Pulls data directly from Google Sheets, Dune Analytics or Postgres tables.- Lets users build and customize dashboards easily with ECharts- No-code and just withI started this because I noticed there are free tools as Superset, but the learning curve is a bit steeper and probably too complicated for most not deeply technical people. PrettyData aims to be the missing link between semi-raw data and useful dashboards—without friction.Why it might interest you:- 14 day free trial, no credit card required.- I’d love to hear feedback from the HN community on the concept, user experience, or areas for improvement.- Feature requests are welcome — I’m balancing development and marketing, so your input would help steer things in the right direction.If this sounds like something you’d find useful, I’d appreciate it if you gave it a spin at https://app.prettydata.xyz. Your feedback would mean a lot and help shape the product!Thanks for reading, and feel free to AMA in the comments.

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Dashboards by Basedash - AI-powered dashboards directly from your database

28 Sep 2023 Artificial Intelligence Productivity Analytics

With dashboards, every team in your workspace gets its own customizable page to show data like daily signups, WAU, or anything else you store in your database. Create views and queries with AI in seconds, then build a dashboard to share with your team.

The Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with users praising the seamless design, pre-built graphs, and potential for rich data insights. Many congratulated the launch team and expressed excitement to use the product. There's interest in AI-driven metric suggestions and customizability of dashboards for different teams. Users are also requesting broader database support, specifically mentioning MongoDB and Firestore. Some users inquired about AI generation capabilities and compatibility with SQL and HTML.

Users expressed concerns regarding missing features, specifically requesting AI-driven metric suggestions and Firestore support. These requests imply a perceived lack in the current functionality of the product.

Avatar
140
14
7.1%
14
140
7.1%
Relevance

Embeddable - Lightning-Fast Embedded Analytics

30 Sep 2024 Data & Analytics Data Visualization Developer Tools

The award-winning developer toolkit for building fast-loading, interactive dashboards into your product. ⭐️ Customise our charts in code, or bring your own ⭐️ Easily build dashboards in a no-code interface ⭐️ Embed directly in your frontend - no iframes!

Embeddable is receiving positive feedback for its no-code, easy-to-manage embedded analytics solution, customizable charts and dashboards. Users praise its simplicity, speed, and flexibility, particularly the no-iframe approach, saving time and eliminating iframe headaches. The smooth and efficient analytics integration for product teams is highlighted. Users congratulate the team on the launch and express excitement to try the product and anticipate future growth. Questions arise regarding coding knowledge needed and support for frameworks beyond React, and API integration.

A user inquired about Google Analytics API integration, questioning whether the product supports this feature.

Avatar
114
22
36.4%
22
114
36.4%
Relevance

Evidence - Interactive dashboards with extraordinary performance

21 Jun 2024 Open Source GitHub Developer Tools

Combine data from anywhere, visualize datasets with millions of rows, and deliver zero-latency interactivity - in pure SQL.

Evidence's Product Hunt launch received positive feedback for its SQL data visualization, interactivity, and chart creation speed, simplifying data engineer/analyst tasks. Users find it suitable for client presentations. Questions arose regarding integration with BI tools, workflow migration, SQL dialect transition ease, cache layer creation, size limits, and runtime speed. Several users congratulated the Evidence team on the launch.

Users express concerns about performance, particularly with large datasets. The slow runtime during report generation with substantial amounts of data is a key criticism. This negatively impacts the product's usability for users dealing with extensive data.

Avatar
192
9
9
192
Relevance

Dashboards by Equals - Business intelligence, but dead easy

24 Oct 2023 Artificial Intelligence Data & Analytics Business Intelligence

Instantly turn spreadsheets into dashboards powered by live data and auto-distribute up-to-date reports to Slack, email, and Slides - all in a few clicks. Drag and drop to add cells, tables, and charts. Add context with text and AI-generated summaries.

Equals' Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with users praising its intuitive design, seamless UX/UI, and time-saving automation features. Many highlighted the dashboard functionality for streamlining data visualization and reporting, transforming spreadsheets into real-time insights. Users expressed excitement about using Equals for various tasks, including GTM meeting prep, forecasting, and budget tracking. Several comments congratulated the team on the launch, with specific mentions of team members. Questions arose regarding output locations, real-time data feeds, security, and potential integration with other platforms. Overall, users see Equals as a game-changer for data-heavy businesses.

Critics view the software as a glorified spreadsheet. Users find the landing page navigation difficult and express concerns about dataset privacy. The analytics tools are considered uninteresting. Some users mentioned struggling with Excel for forecasting and bookkeeping, suggesting a need for improved functionality. The absence of a free plan is a point of contention, with users preferring it over a free trial.

Avatar
833
65
21.5%
0.0%
65
833
21.5%
1.5%
Relevance

I made an open-source personal dashboard builder

16 Aug 2024 Open Source

Users find the title and README confusing, suggesting a need for clearer descriptions and examples. The term 'link-in-bio' is not well understood, though some recognize it as a tool for influencers to share multiple links. The product is seen as an attempt at a personal dashboard for data visualization, similar to Linktree but with additional features. It's considered early stage, with users requesting more information, a working demo, and clarification on the free model. There are technical issues noted, such as broken links and problems with WebGL. Some praise the idea and suggest expanding the target audience.

Users criticized the Show HN submission for having a misleading title, unclear README, and lack of clarity on the product's purpose and value. The landing page was noted to be lacking in insight, screenshots, and code snippets. There were technical issues such as 404 errors, server-side exceptions, and inefficient code conversion. The product was not seen as suitable for personal use, with a need for real-time functionality and better personal data visualization. Users also expressed a need for better account creation options, dissatisfaction with sign-up methods, and a desire for a more straightforward company website.

Avatar
68
46
-2.2%
-2.2%
46
68
4.3%
Top