Should I Build It Should I Build It
08 Apr 2025
Artificial Intelligence Hiring

an automated AI cv builder, that takes info from all kinds of sources ...

...and gives you a professional CV

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Swamp

The market has seen several mediocre solutions that nobody loves. Unless you can offer something fundamentally different, you’ll likely struggle to stand out or make money.

Should You Build It?

Don't build it.

Your are here

The idea of an automated AI CV builder falls into a crowded space, with many existing solutions that haven't quite captured the market's heart. Our analysis shows a significant number of similar products (n_matches = 26), indicating high competition. While the average engagement (n_comments = 2) is low, suggesting that many of these solutions haven't generated substantial user interaction, it's worth noting that negative feedback around data privacy issues, potential for scams, and lack of clear privacy policies exists in many of these launches. Given this context, entering this space requires a fundamentally different approach or a focus on a specific niche to avoid becoming just another mediocre option. Existing resume builders are often criticized for paywalling basic functionalities and a lack of customization options.

Recommendations

  1. Start by deeply researching why existing AI CV builders haven't fully satisfied users. Read through the criticism summaries of similar products; users are concerned about generic resumes, lack of customization, and potential privacy issues. Understand these pain points before you even begin to design your product.
  2. Consider focusing on a specific niche or underserved group of job seekers. For instance, you could specialize in crafting CVs for highly technical roles, creative professions, or specific industries like healthcare. Tailoring the AI's training data and algorithms to this niche will improve relevance and differentiation. This could also help you with early stage content generation and demand generation in this niche. Be careful to consider all of the edge cases as you narrow the focus of the product.
  3. Explore the possibility of creating AI-powered tools for existing resume writing services or career coaches instead of directly competing with them. Offer your technology as a white-label solution to enhance their services and reach a wider audience. This shifts your business model from direct-to-consumer to B2B, which could reduce marketing costs and increase the likelihood of success.
  4. Prioritize data privacy and security from the outset. Be transparent about how user data is collected, stored, and used, and implement robust security measures to prevent data breaches. Consider building a privacy policy first, so that you can be completely upfront with any potential users. Many users from the similar product launches expressed concerned about privacy issues.
  5. Focus on providing unique value beyond just automating resume creation. Consider integrating features like AI-powered interview preparation, personalized career coaching, or skills gap analysis to offer a more comprehensive solution. Make sure that the AI that you develop also provides useful feedback.
  6. Implement a robust feedback mechanism and actively solicit user input to continuously improve the AI's accuracy and effectiveness. Pay close attention to user reviews and comments on competitor products to identify areas for improvement. User feedback is paramount to success, and can allow your product to stand out from the competition. Prioritize feedback to make sure your product gains market traction.

Questions

  1. Given the existing concerns around data privacy with AI resume builders, what specific measures will you implement to build trust and ensure user data security?
  2. How will you differentiate your AI CV builder from the numerous existing solutions to offer genuinely unique value and avoid becoming just another mediocre option?
  3. Considering the criticism that AI tools can worsen the hiring process, how will you ensure your AI CV builder helps genuine applicants and doesn't contribute to clogging pipelines with irrelevant or low-quality resumes?

Your are here

The idea of an automated AI CV builder falls into a crowded space, with many existing solutions that haven't quite captured the market's heart. Our analysis shows a significant number of similar products (n_matches = 26), indicating high competition. While the average engagement (n_comments = 2) is low, suggesting that many of these solutions haven't generated substantial user interaction, it's worth noting that negative feedback around data privacy issues, potential for scams, and lack of clear privacy policies exists in many of these launches. Given this context, entering this space requires a fundamentally different approach or a focus on a specific niche to avoid becoming just another mediocre option. Existing resume builders are often criticized for paywalling basic functionalities and a lack of customization options.

Recommendations

  1. Start by deeply researching why existing AI CV builders haven't fully satisfied users. Read through the criticism summaries of similar products; users are concerned about generic resumes, lack of customization, and potential privacy issues. Understand these pain points before you even begin to design your product.
  2. Consider focusing on a specific niche or underserved group of job seekers. For instance, you could specialize in crafting CVs for highly technical roles, creative professions, or specific industries like healthcare. Tailoring the AI's training data and algorithms to this niche will improve relevance and differentiation. This could also help you with early stage content generation and demand generation in this niche. Be careful to consider all of the edge cases as you narrow the focus of the product.
  3. Explore the possibility of creating AI-powered tools for existing resume writing services or career coaches instead of directly competing with them. Offer your technology as a white-label solution to enhance their services and reach a wider audience. This shifts your business model from direct-to-consumer to B2B, which could reduce marketing costs and increase the likelihood of success.
  4. Prioritize data privacy and security from the outset. Be transparent about how user data is collected, stored, and used, and implement robust security measures to prevent data breaches. Consider building a privacy policy first, so that you can be completely upfront with any potential users. Many users from the similar product launches expressed concerned about privacy issues.
  5. Focus on providing unique value beyond just automating resume creation. Consider integrating features like AI-powered interview preparation, personalized career coaching, or skills gap analysis to offer a more comprehensive solution. Make sure that the AI that you develop also provides useful feedback.
  6. Implement a robust feedback mechanism and actively solicit user input to continuously improve the AI's accuracy and effectiveness. Pay close attention to user reviews and comments on competitor products to identify areas for improvement. User feedback is paramount to success, and can allow your product to stand out from the competition. Prioritize feedback to make sure your product gains market traction.

Questions

  1. Given the existing concerns around data privacy with AI resume builders, what specific measures will you implement to build trust and ensure user data security?
  2. How will you differentiate your AI CV builder from the numerous existing solutions to offer genuinely unique value and avoid becoming just another mediocre option?
  3. Considering the criticism that AI tools can worsen the hiring process, how will you ensure your AI CV builder helps genuine applicants and doesn't contribute to clogging pipelines with irrelevant or low-quality resumes?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 26
  • Engagement: Low
    • Average number of comments: 2
  • Net use signal: -0.8%
    • Positive use signal: 14.7%
    • Negative use signal: 15.5%
  • Net buy signal: -9.8%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.0%
    • Negative buy signal: 9.8%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

AICVPro - AI-Powered CV Builder for Job Seekers

08 Dec 2024 Artificial Intelligence Productivity Career

AICVPro is an AI-powered platform that helps you create professional CVs effortlessly. Upload your existing CV or job description, choose from customizable templates, and generate a tailored CV for free. Download as a PDF and edit anytime.

AICVPro launch: AI-powered CV creation for career advancement.

Looking for feedback, so no criticism is given.

Avatar
6
1
1
6
Relevance

ResumeAI, AI-powered Resume Builder (get your resumes done in seconds!)

22 Jul 2024 Artificial Intelligence Hiring Productivity Career

Hey everyone,I'm self-taught dev from France. I'd like to share and receive your feedback on ResumeAI, which is a project I've been working on because I was frustrated with the traditional resume building process. I especially got tired of multiple input fields for all the resume builders out there. So I built a solution to generate fully formatted CVs out of a single text area. It's also possible to use your own voice in order to describe your experiences, projects, etc from just natural language (my app is using the whisper LLM under the hood).For now you can try it for free, just refresh the page if you see the paywall in order to try again. AI rewrites for now are unlimited. I've got a bunch of templates ready and more are on the way.Please visit https://resumeai.app/ to let me know what you guys think!

Avatar
4
4
Relevance

Amazing CV - Get a professionally written resume in minutes using AI

23 Aug 2023 SaaS Hiring Productivity

Amazing CV: Revolutionize your job hunt with our AI-powered resume builder. Transform existing CVs into professional masterpieces in minutes. Tailored, fast, impactful. Dive into the future of resume crafting. https://amazing.cv

Users congratulated Dan Cabaniss and wished good luck on the launch of Amazing CV. They found the AI-powered resume builder impressive and a great time-saver. Users also appreciated the easy resume upload, quick results, funny AI authors, and useful feedback.

The primary criticism suggests enhancing design customization options for resumes. Users are looking for more control over the visual aspects of their resumes.

Avatar
109
6
16.7%
6
109
16.7%
Relevance

Smart CV Generator - Customize your resume for specific job requirements with AI

09 Oct 2023 Artificial Intelligence Hiring Career

Customize your resume for specific job requirements instantly with AI and increase the response rate from the recruiters. Use a simple 3 step process to create a custom CV for every job you apply.

The resume customization product launch was well-received. Users find it intelligent and useful for jobseekers, revolutionizing resume tailoring by saving time and increasing efficiency. There's anticipation for future updates. Some users suggest the product needs better attention and support.

The primary criticism revolves around the need for improved attention and support for the product. This suggests that users are seeking better assistance, guidance, or responsiveness from the product team.

Avatar
89
5
60.0%
5
89
60.0%
Relevance

tailor.cv - Leverage AI & Recruiters to tailor your CV to a specific job

24 Aug 2024 Artificial Intelligence SaaS Career

Finding a job has never been this hard. Boost your chances by using AI to create a customized CV for a specific role in minutes. Plus, have it verified by professional recruiters before sending it off to the hiring team—all for free.

Tailor.cv's Product Hunt launch is met with excitement and congratulations. Users praise its AI-driven approach combined with human expertise as a game-changer for job seekers. The tool is highlighted for making the job application process easier and helping candidates stand out. One user inquired about the AI's information extraction method. A user also expressed optimism, noting past frustrations with other CV builders, and hoped this will be different.

Users expressed concerns about how the AI tailors CVs for niche roles. One user indicated dissatisfaction with previous CV builders, implying a need for this tool to offer a more compelling and effective solution than existing alternatives.

Avatar
26
8
25.0%
8
26
25.0%
Relevance

Bamble AI CV Creator - Resume co-pilot & creator

12 Nov 2024 Artificial Intelligence Human Resources Hiring

Create AI powered high-quality CV in 3 clicks

CV Co-Pilot and Bamble AI CV Creator launched on Product Hunt, both aiming to enhance job applications and create resumes that represent a user's potential and career goals. The focus is on advancing and improving the job application process through AI-powered resume creation.

There were no criticisms mentioned regarding this Product Hunt launch.

Avatar
21
2
2
21
Relevance

AI Resume Builder - Create Your Job Resume Effortlessly with HireQuotient

24 Sep 2024 Artificial Intelligence Hiring Career

Looking for an AI Resume Builder? Try free resume maker to craft job-winning resume for any profession. ✔Unlimited templates ✔No signup required ✔Free resume download.

HireQuotient's AI Resume Builder is praised for its free, easy, and quick resume creation process. Users appreciate the absence of mandatory sign-ups, making it a convenient tool.

Users criticize existing resume builders for requiring sign-ups or payment to access fundamental features. This paywalling of basic functionalities is a common pain point highlighted in the feedback.

Avatar
7
2
100.0%
2
7
100.0%
Relevance

I Made an AI Resume Maker That Turns Any Job Link into Tailored Resumes

10 Oct 2024 Artificial Intelligence Hiring Career

Hey HN, I am a solopreneur building AI SaaS and mini tools.I recently built ResumeSet, an AI resume builder that creates tailored resumes based on job descriptions from any job link.Job hunting can feel like a full-time job itself, especially with the growing reliance on Applicant Tracking Systems (ATS) that automatically filter out resumes. I wanted to help job seekers create resumes more likely to pass ATS checks without endless manual tweaking.How it works: - Paste the job link, and ResumeSet's AI analyzes the job requirements to tailor your resume to match the job's key requirements and skills. - The result? A resume that is ATS (Applicant Tracking System) friendly and increases the likelihood of passing automated screenings. - PDF export feature for easy downloads and integrations into existing job platforms. - No fancy templates, just functional and ATS-friendly formatting.Why I built this: I noticed how time-consuming and frustrating it is to repeatedly tweak resumes for every job application, especially when fighting against rigid ATS systems. I wanted to automate this process and make job hunting more efficient by focusing on what matters—tailoring resumes specifically to each role.ResumeSet helps users avoid the generic, one-size-fits-all resumes that often get rejected. I see how often good candidates are missed due to poorly optimized resumes. My goal was to make a simple but effective tool that bridges that gap.Tech Stack: - Built with Django and OpenAI API for the core AI functionality. - Frontend is a simple Bootstrap for a responsive design.I'd love to get feedback from the community. Thoughts on improving it or potential features? You can try it for free here: https://resumeset.com.Looking forward to your comments and suggestions!

Users express concerns about AI tools in hiring, noting they can worsen the process by clogging pipelines and harming genuine applicants. There's a call for an AI-powered application checker and criticism of ATS systems. Suggestions include adopting jsonresume format for easier data import and improving job application strategies. Positive feedback includes praise for the invention and interest in filtering irrelevant job history. Technical issues reported include a broken UI on Firefox. Two comments were noted as dead.

Users criticize the product for exacerbating hiring issues, with AI tools causing false positives and harming job seekers. There's no redress for rejections. The job application strategy is deemed terrible, with excessive manual data entry, disliked resume retyping, and lengthy profile detail filling. Additionally, the UI is reported to be broken on Firefox.

Avatar
12
12
-33.3%
-25.0%
12
12
8.3%
Relevance

CV Optimiser - Effortlessly tailor your CV for any job in seconds.

07 Oct 2024 Artificial Intelligence User Experience Career

CV Optimiser uses AI to instantly tailor your CV to any job description. Upload your CV add the job posting and get a customized CV with feedback and a fit score. Generate a matching cover letter and export as a PDF, Word file, or shareable link—all in seconds

CV Optimizer praised for inventive concept and easing job searches.

Avatar
10
1
1
10
Relevance

Free AI-Powered Resume and Cover Letter Maker

27 Apr 2024 Artificial Intelligence Hiring Career

Users expressed concerns about AI-generated resumes, highlighting issues such as potential for scams, lack of privacy policy, and increased unwanted contact. Some view the current job application landscape pessimistically, suggesting that traditional CVs and cover letters are becoming obsolete as AI begins to handle more of the application process. There's also a sentiment that AI's role in job searching could lead to a polarized outcome of either great success or menial work. One comment simply acknowledges the situation with a colloquial 'Aye!'

Users criticized the AI resume service for lack of clarity and privacy policy, expressing skepticism about its effectiveness. Complaints include receiving numerous calls from unknown numbers, a negative view of the current state of the service, concerns about Gmail's auto-suggest feature, and the potential for generating fake CVs on a large scale, suggesting over-reliance on AI.

Avatar
10
11
-9.1%
11
10
Relevance

ResumerX – Elevate your CV using AI

13 Feb 2023 Artificial Intelligence Productivity Career

I have worked on this tool to make your CV better using OpenAI's API.Here is the pitch:Maximize your job search potential with the power of AI! As the buzz surrounding OpenAI's GPT-3 grows, I discovered its amazing potential for enhancing CVs.With the job market competitive, a standout resume is crucial for landing your next job. That's why I developed ResumerX, a tool leveraging OpenAI's API to elevate your CV and give you an edge in the interview process.Or, as Chat-GPT puts it: Unlock your full potential with our AI-powered platform and let it edit your CV to new heights. Build on OpenAI's GPT-3 API.And it's easy to use:Feed in Your CV Texts: Provide the text from your current CV in ResumerX's platform.♺ Generate Optimized Texts: Optimize your CV text with AI technology. Make them shorter, extend or change tone.Use Texts in Your CV: Boost your CV's impact with ResumerX's optimized text. Just copy and paste them into your CV.My goal with this is to help you improve your CV with no effort, using AI tooling. For recruiters and hiring managers, using AI technology for CV texts will also make it easier to compare CVs - focus is on the content, not form.Yes, yes, there are lots of tools like this. ResumerX is effort-less, without registration, and for free.Try out the tool and let me know how it can be improved. Hope it will be helpful to some.

Avatar
7
7
Relevance

We created a way for you to review your resume using AI

11 Apr 2024 Artificial Intelligence Hiring Career

Users suggest improvements for a Show HN product, emphasizing the need for a tool to filter resumes through hiring systems, AI for job postings, and ATS integration. They recommend enhancing the sales copy, addressing data privacy, and providing unique selling points. Positive feedback includes satisfaction with results and recommendations for candidates. Criticisms include the product being underdeveloped, lacking real link references, and reduced credibility from name-dropping. An AI assistant for recruiters and advice for HR screening in government jobs were also mentioned.

Users criticized the product for non-compliance with ePrivacy, identical resume scoring, lack of human consideration in HR screening, irrelevant content, data privacy issues, potential fines, lack of unique value, oversimplified LLM-based CV screening, being underdeveloped and overpriced, irresponsible ATS tool design, broken links in the Legal section, similarity to LinkedIn, unnecessary name-dropping, and use of unrelated quotes.

Avatar
8
17
-29.4%
-29.4%
17
8
5.9%
Top