Should I Build It Should I Build It
03 Jun 2025
Hiring Career

a web based service that rates your resume against any job ...

...description, highlights your positives and negatives and how to better position yourself

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Swamp

The market has seen several mediocre solutions that nobody loves. Unless you can offer something fundamentally different, you’ll likely struggle to stand out or make money.

Should You Build It?

Don't build it.

Your are here

The idea of a web-based service that rates resumes against job descriptions falls into a crowded space. Our analysis found 22 similar products, which indicates high competition. This market segment is characterized by numerous solutions, many of which haven't truly resonated with users. The average number of comments on similar products is low (2), suggesting limited engagement. While some users are excited about such tools, criticisms often revolve around data privacy, the quality of resume suggestions, and comparisons to established players. Given these factors, standing out and achieving profitability will be a significant challenge unless you offer a fundamentally different value proposition.

Recommendations

  1. Deeply research why existing resume rating and optimization solutions haven't achieved widespread success. Understand the pain points users still face and identify unmet needs. Read user reviews, analyze competitor weaknesses, and identify gaps in the market. For example, the discussion summaries highlight the importance of data privacy and resume tailoring suggestions, so deeply think about that.
  2. Instead of targeting the entire job-seeking market, focus on a specific niche or group with unique resume needs. This could be a particular industry, career level, or demographic. By catering to a specific audience, you can tailor your service to their specific requirements and increase your chances of success. Think about e.g. government jobs - as one of the similar product discussions mentioned this as a potentially good niche.
  3. Consider creating tools or features that enhance existing resume services or platforms rather than directly competing with them. This could involve developing integrations with popular job boards or applicant tracking systems (ATS). By complementing existing solutions, you can tap into established user bases and generate revenue through partnerships. Some users talked about e.g. ATS integrations as something they would like to see.
  4. Explore adjacent problems related to career development or job searching that might be more promising. This could include services focused on interview preparation, career coaching, or skills assessment. By expanding your scope, you can tap into new markets and generate additional revenue streams. Instead of focusing just on the resume, think about the bigger picture - finding a job.
  5. Given the crowded market and lukewarm reception of similar products, consider whether it's worth investing significant time and resources into this idea. Evaluate your other startup ideas and prioritize the ones with the greatest potential for success. Don't be afraid to abandon this idea if you don't believe it can achieve significant traction.
  6. Prioritize data privacy and security. Address user concerns about how their resume data is stored, used, and protected. Be transparent about your data practices and implement robust security measures to prevent breaches. This is a critical point mentioned in many similar product discussions.
  7. Focus on providing highly tailored and relevant resume suggestions. Ensure that your AI algorithms are accurate and up-to-date. Continuously refine your algorithms based on user feedback and industry trends. Again, resume relevance to the job description came up multiple times in the similar product discussions, so that is critical.
  8. Clearly differentiate your service from competitors like Jobscan and Teal. Highlight your unique features and benefits. Focus on providing a superior user experience and delivering tangible results for job seekers. If you are just another alternative, you will not succeed.

Questions

  1. What specific, underserved niche within the job-seeking market will your service target, and what unique resume needs does this niche have that existing solutions don't address?
  2. How will you ensure the accuracy, relevance, and up-to-dateness of your AI-powered resume suggestions, and what specific measures will you take to address user concerns about data privacy and security?
  3. What unique features or benefits will your service offer that clearly differentiate it from competitors like Jobscan and Teal, and how will you measure the tangible results your service delivers for job seekers?

Your are here

The idea of a web-based service that rates resumes against job descriptions falls into a crowded space. Our analysis found 22 similar products, which indicates high competition. This market segment is characterized by numerous solutions, many of which haven't truly resonated with users. The average number of comments on similar products is low (2), suggesting limited engagement. While some users are excited about such tools, criticisms often revolve around data privacy, the quality of resume suggestions, and comparisons to established players. Given these factors, standing out and achieving profitability will be a significant challenge unless you offer a fundamentally different value proposition.

Recommendations

  1. Deeply research why existing resume rating and optimization solutions haven't achieved widespread success. Understand the pain points users still face and identify unmet needs. Read user reviews, analyze competitor weaknesses, and identify gaps in the market. For example, the discussion summaries highlight the importance of data privacy and resume tailoring suggestions, so deeply think about that.
  2. Instead of targeting the entire job-seeking market, focus on a specific niche or group with unique resume needs. This could be a particular industry, career level, or demographic. By catering to a specific audience, you can tailor your service to their specific requirements and increase your chances of success. Think about e.g. government jobs - as one of the similar product discussions mentioned this as a potentially good niche.
  3. Consider creating tools or features that enhance existing resume services or platforms rather than directly competing with them. This could involve developing integrations with popular job boards or applicant tracking systems (ATS). By complementing existing solutions, you can tap into established user bases and generate revenue through partnerships. Some users talked about e.g. ATS integrations as something they would like to see.
  4. Explore adjacent problems related to career development or job searching that might be more promising. This could include services focused on interview preparation, career coaching, or skills assessment. By expanding your scope, you can tap into new markets and generate additional revenue streams. Instead of focusing just on the resume, think about the bigger picture - finding a job.
  5. Given the crowded market and lukewarm reception of similar products, consider whether it's worth investing significant time and resources into this idea. Evaluate your other startup ideas and prioritize the ones with the greatest potential for success. Don't be afraid to abandon this idea if you don't believe it can achieve significant traction.
  6. Prioritize data privacy and security. Address user concerns about how their resume data is stored, used, and protected. Be transparent about your data practices and implement robust security measures to prevent breaches. This is a critical point mentioned in many similar product discussions.
  7. Focus on providing highly tailored and relevant resume suggestions. Ensure that your AI algorithms are accurate and up-to-date. Continuously refine your algorithms based on user feedback and industry trends. Again, resume relevance to the job description came up multiple times in the similar product discussions, so that is critical.
  8. Clearly differentiate your service from competitors like Jobscan and Teal. Highlight your unique features and benefits. Focus on providing a superior user experience and delivering tangible results for job seekers. If you are just another alternative, you will not succeed.

Questions

  1. What specific, underserved niche within the job-seeking market will your service target, and what unique resume needs does this niche have that existing solutions don't address?
  2. How will you ensure the accuracy, relevance, and up-to-dateness of your AI-powered resume suggestions, and what specific measures will you take to address user concerns about data privacy and security?
  3. What unique features or benefits will your service offer that clearly differentiate it from competitors like Jobscan and Teal, and how will you measure the tangible results your service delivers for job seekers?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 22
  • Engagement: Low
    • Average number of comments: 2
  • Net use signal: -0.7%
    • Positive use signal: 12.0%
    • Negative use signal: 12.6%
  • Net buy signal: -10.9%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.0%
    • Negative buy signal: 10.9%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

A website that tailors your resume for each job you apply for

05 Jun 2024 Hiring Career

Hey HN,I'm excited to share a project I've been working on for the past few months. As someone who has spent countless hours tweaking my resume for different job applications, I wanted to find a way to make this process more efficient and effective. So, I built a website that tailors your resume for each job you apply for.You can check it out here: https://resume.inkLooking forward to your thoughts!Cheers, Sami

Users expressed concerns about data privacy and the handling of resumes. The job application interface was criticized, and comparisons were made with other services like Jobscan and Teal, with some users not impressed but others excited to try the new service. There were mixed reviews on the resume suggestions feature, and one user mentioned cancelling during the trial. A free resume download with a promo code and a JSON Resume option were highlighted. Feedback was given on user experience, a homepage example, and an upload bug. The development of a feature using GPTs for merging information was mentioned, as well as the potential for AI collaboration. There were sarcastic comments and encouragement for the author to continue improving the service.

Users expressed concerns about data retention and unwanted marketing emails, and found the job application interfaces confusing. The integration with Jobscan and Teal was not well-received. Technical issues included problems with editing, replacement, a missing next button, homepage example, and an upload bug. Users also faced challenges with additive synonyms and deletions. There was sarcasm regarding the importance of Hacker News, and criticism about the resume example not being tailored. Additionally, concerns were raised about the automation aspect of the resume processes.

Avatar
32
15
6.7%
-6.7%
15
32
13.3%
Relevance

Rate My Resume - AI-Driven Resume Analysis Developed by Senior Recruiters

15 May 2024 Artificial Intelligence Hiring Career

RateMyResume.ai provides personalized, AI-driven feedback to optimize your resume, helping you stand out in the job market and advance your career goals efficiently.

Users are excited about RateMyResume.ai's ability to provide resume feedback and enhance resumes, potentially leading to landing their dream jobs. The tool is perceived as beneficial for resume improvement.

Avatar
10
2
100.0%
2
10
100.0%
Relevance

Tailored resumes based on job descriptions

23 Jul 2023 Hiring Career

Hi HN!I have been working on https://resgen.app for a couple weeks, and wanted to share it since it has been helpful for me in my own job search.The idea came about after the frustration of tailoring each resume for each job. The way we actually talk about our experiences and the way they are portrayed on the resume are sometimes different. So, I wanted to make something that takes my rambling about my experiences and turn it into a custom resume for each job.Resgen is a chrome extension / web app that tailors your experiences to best match the job description. On every LinkedIn job, a new button will appear that says "Generate". When clicked, a tailored resume will be generated using the experiences you entered on the app. It's also a good way to keep track of which resumes went to which job.Looking forward to hearing your feedback!

Introduces Resgen app for tailored resumes.

Avatar
2
1
1
2
Relevance

AI tool to tailor resume and cover letter, and prepare for interviews

06 Nov 2023 Hiring Career

Hi HN Community! I'd really appreciate your feedback on my new web app for job seekers. What it can do:1. Help you optimize your resume for a specific job description.2. Write a personalized cover letter.3. Identify most likely interview questions for the role and provide real-time feedback during mock interviews.The backend is written in Python (Flask). It relies on an internal database and multiple external APIs (incl. ChatGPT). The frontend is HTML/CSS/JavaScript.I'm very curious: What do you like and dislike the most about it? Did you experience any weird issues as you were playing around with it? And what would you suggest to improve? Thanks!

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Bullish Resume - Get Detailed AI Feedback on Your Resume.

28 Sep 2024 Hiring Tech Career

AI-powered resume critique tool providing actionable feedback to boost your job selection chances.

The AI resume critique tool is perceived as innovative and practical, with users finding it helpful for enhancing job prospects. Despite some negative feedback, users find the tool valuable overall.

The product launch was "roasted badly", implying the feedback received was overly critical and potentially harsh. This suggests a negative reception and potentially significant areas for improvement.

Avatar
18
3
3
18
Relevance

ResumaidPro – Tailoring Resumes Simplified

15 Oct 2024 Career

Hey HN!I built an app to tailor resumes to job descriptions. It has a Chrome extension and web app, with the extension being the main focus. Users can open it on supported job listings and hit "generate" to tailor their resume. The process: Upload base resume, open extension on listing or paste job description, review content, select template, and then download. You can edit and change the resume after you've generated it as well.You can also add cover letters and recruiter emails tailored to the job. The review step is important as I acknowledge AI isn't perfect and mistakes can be made (like lying), so with that review step, users can filter out things they don't want and also add information that may have been missed.I made this to help me tailor my resumes and have built a similar tool in the past, which inspired this one. I would love any and all feedback or ideas on what would make the tool more useful for you.Thanks! YounusLink --> https://www.resumaidpro.io/

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Resume Reviews Powered by GPT4 and Career Coaches

10 Nov 2023 Artificial Intelligence Hiring

Hello HN community,I have created resumechecker.ai, an AI-powered tool for resume reviews. After speaking with 20 career coaches, it was discovered that >90% of resumes fail to impress. Most of us talk about responsibilities, not achievements.Why It Matters: Writing a compelling resume is challenging, and this tool aims to simplify that process. Using OpenAI's API, resumechecker.ai offers detailed, personalized feedback to enhance resume quality.Key Features: AI Analysis for in-depth feedback. Actionable suggestions with detailed reasoning. Tailored recommendations to showcase achievements and skills.Privacy-focused: No account is needed, email addresses and resume data aren't stored. They are used only for delivering the review.Outcome: You can see an example review on the website. Some of the career coaches are using the tool to help their candidates :) Resumechecker was designed for job seekers to create resumes that stand out, increasing their chances of getting noticed and hired.Hope it can help you too~ I'd love to hear your thoughts and feedback!

Avatar
2
2
Relevance

Resumeverse - Tailored Resume for Every Job

13 Nov 2024 Hiring

Resumeverse is an AI-powered resume optimization tool that tailors your resume to match job descriptions, increasing your chances of passing ATS systems and landing interviews.

Users praise Resumeverse for its effectiveness in helping job seekers, particularly in competitive markets. It's considered a helpful and great initiative for job searching, with one user emphatically calling it "OP" (overpowered), indicating strong positive feelings about its capabilities and impact.

Avatar
13
3
33.3%
3
13
33.3%
Relevance

I made an open-source Resume Matcher. A Python based ATS with ML

24 Jul 2023 Hiring Productivity Career

What is Resume Matcher? IT's an AI Based Free & Open Source ATS, Resume Matcher to tailor your resume to a job description. Find the best keywords and gain deep insights into your resume.What it does? It's basically a python resume parser with NLP and Sentence Similarity capabilities to find how close your resume is to the job description. Since it does PDF parsing, it can tell people if their resume is ATS friendly or not. It also does keyword analysis and keyword matching between job descriptions and your resume. So you get to know where you can improve it further.What I'm looking for? If someone can mentor me to enhance my project. And help me with some pointers on how to grow and in what ways I can improve the tech stack, system design etc. It'll be amazing. Also, if someone who finds my idea novel enough to support it on GitHub, it'll be a great morale boost as well.Please try it out here: https://github.com/srbhr/Naive-Resume-Matching/ Website Link: https://www.resumematcher.fyi/ Streamlit Cloud Demo: https://resume-matcher.streamlit.app/Thanks for your time. Yours Truly, Saurabh Rai

Avatar
2
2
Relevance

We created a way for you to review your resume using AI

11 Apr 2024 Artificial Intelligence Hiring Career

Users suggest improvements for a Show HN product, emphasizing the need for a tool to filter resumes through hiring systems, AI for job postings, and ATS integration. They recommend enhancing the sales copy, addressing data privacy, and providing unique selling points. Positive feedback includes satisfaction with results and recommendations for candidates. Criticisms include the product being underdeveloped, lacking real link references, and reduced credibility from name-dropping. An AI assistant for recruiters and advice for HR screening in government jobs were also mentioned.

Users criticized the product for non-compliance with ePrivacy, identical resume scoring, lack of human consideration in HR screening, irrelevant content, data privacy issues, potential fines, lack of unique value, oversimplified LLM-based CV screening, being underdeveloped and overpriced, irresponsible ATS tool design, broken links in the Legal section, similarity to LinkedIn, unnecessary name-dropping, and use of unrelated quotes.

Avatar
8
17
-29.4%
-29.4%
17
8
5.9%
Top