Should I Build It Should I Build It
04 May 2025
Health Health & Fitness

Spring Challenge: Mental Spa is a group habit-tracking app with a ...

...twist—self-care meets accountability. Users join small, private challenge groups where they commit to daily wellness habits like drinking water, taking steps, or screen-free time. The vibe is calm and motivating, but there’s structure: miss too many days, and you’re gently ejected from the group. It’s like a mental detox with a little peer pressure magic. Each group tracks progress together, sends encouragement, and stays on pace as a team. It’s not just about tracking—it’s about showing up, staying mindful, and growing stronger together.

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Freemium

People love using similar products but resist paying. You’ll need to either find who will pay or create additional value that’s worth paying for.

Should You Build It?

Build but think about differentiation and monetization.

Your are here

Your idea, Spring Challenge: Mental Spa, taps into the popular trend of habit tracking, but with a focus on self-care and group accountability. Our analysis indicates you're in the 'Freemium' category, meaning similar products often struggle with monetization despite user interest. With 17 similar products already out there, competition is substantial. While the average engagement (14 comments) is relatively high, the lack of explicit 'use' or 'buy' signals from comparable products suggests that users like the concept but aren't necessarily willing to pay for it or even actively use it long-term. You'll need to carefully consider how to differentiate yourself and establish sustainable revenue streams. Your core concept has merit, but thoughtful execution around monetization and user retention will be key.

Recommendations

  1. Given the freemium nature of this space, deeply analyze which aspects of your app drive the most value for free users. This will inform your decisions on what to gate behind a premium subscription. Based on the Accountable and Squad Habits feedback, focus on making the core group accountability features exceptionally engaging and user-friendly, as this appears to be a primary driver of interest.
  2. Explore premium features that extend the value for highly engaged users. Consider elements like personalized habit plans, deeper analytics on progress, or exclusive content from wellness experts. The comments from Mindful shows users are interested in tracking data comprehensively.
  3. Instead of individual subscriptions, explore team or group pricing models, positioning the app as a tool for workplace wellness programs or close-knit friend groups. The "squads" mentioned in Squad Habits reviews appear to be a key engagement driver, so leveraging that for monetization may be fruitful.
  4. Offer personalized guidance or consulting services as a premium add-on. This could include one-on-one coaching sessions, tailored wellness plans, or expert Q&A sessions within the app. The 'motivating personal wellness coach' aspect of Habitually is a good signal for this.
  5. Test different pricing models with small cohorts of users to see what resonates. Experiment with freemium tiers, subscription options, and one-time purchases to find the optimal balance between accessibility and revenue generation. Don't be afraid to iterate based on user feedback.
  6. Address potential user drop-off by incorporating gamification, personalized reminders, and community challenges to maintain engagement over time. The discussion summary for Habitually touches on the pain point of losing engagement, so proactively build features to combat this.
  7. Prioritize seamless time zone handling for global user groups, as this was a concern raised in the Accountable reviews. Clear and accurate time tracking is essential for successful group accountability.
  8. Consider a web version of your app to address the feedback from Better Mind about typing difficulties on phones. This could improve the journaling experience and overall accessibility.

Questions

  1. Given the existing competition and the freemium nature of the market, what specific, unique features will you incorporate to make Spring Challenge: Mental Spa stand out and attract paying users?
  2. How will you proactively address the potential for user disengagement over time, and what metrics will you track to measure the effectiveness of your retention strategies?
  3. What is your go-to-market strategy for acquiring initial users, and how will you leverage the power of group accountability to drive organic growth and referrals?

Your are here

Your idea, Spring Challenge: Mental Spa, taps into the popular trend of habit tracking, but with a focus on self-care and group accountability. Our analysis indicates you're in the 'Freemium' category, meaning similar products often struggle with monetization despite user interest. With 17 similar products already out there, competition is substantial. While the average engagement (14 comments) is relatively high, the lack of explicit 'use' or 'buy' signals from comparable products suggests that users like the concept but aren't necessarily willing to pay for it or even actively use it long-term. You'll need to carefully consider how to differentiate yourself and establish sustainable revenue streams. Your core concept has merit, but thoughtful execution around monetization and user retention will be key.

Recommendations

  1. Given the freemium nature of this space, deeply analyze which aspects of your app drive the most value for free users. This will inform your decisions on what to gate behind a premium subscription. Based on the Accountable and Squad Habits feedback, focus on making the core group accountability features exceptionally engaging and user-friendly, as this appears to be a primary driver of interest.
  2. Explore premium features that extend the value for highly engaged users. Consider elements like personalized habit plans, deeper analytics on progress, or exclusive content from wellness experts. The comments from Mindful shows users are interested in tracking data comprehensively.
  3. Instead of individual subscriptions, explore team or group pricing models, positioning the app as a tool for workplace wellness programs or close-knit friend groups. The "squads" mentioned in Squad Habits reviews appear to be a key engagement driver, so leveraging that for monetization may be fruitful.
  4. Offer personalized guidance or consulting services as a premium add-on. This could include one-on-one coaching sessions, tailored wellness plans, or expert Q&A sessions within the app. The 'motivating personal wellness coach' aspect of Habitually is a good signal for this.
  5. Test different pricing models with small cohorts of users to see what resonates. Experiment with freemium tiers, subscription options, and one-time purchases to find the optimal balance between accessibility and revenue generation. Don't be afraid to iterate based on user feedback.
  6. Address potential user drop-off by incorporating gamification, personalized reminders, and community challenges to maintain engagement over time. The discussion summary for Habitually touches on the pain point of losing engagement, so proactively build features to combat this.
  7. Prioritize seamless time zone handling for global user groups, as this was a concern raised in the Accountable reviews. Clear and accurate time tracking is essential for successful group accountability.
  8. Consider a web version of your app to address the feedback from Better Mind about typing difficulties on phones. This could improve the journaling experience and overall accessibility.

Questions

  1. Given the existing competition and the freemium nature of the market, what specific, unique features will you incorporate to make Spring Challenge: Mental Spa stand out and attract paying users?
  2. How will you proactively address the potential for user disengagement over time, and what metrics will you track to measure the effectiveness of your retention strategies?
  3. What is your go-to-market strategy for acquiring initial users, and how will you leverage the power of group accountability to drive organic growth and referrals?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 17
  • Engagement: High
    • Average number of comments: 14
  • Net use signal: 10.7%
    • Positive use signal: 11.0%
    • Negative use signal: 0.3%
  • Net buy signal: 0.0%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.0%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.0%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Group accountability for atomic habits (iOS)

15 Jan 2023 Productivity

I started this project by running 10-day group challenges on Whatsapp. The group was gathered via a Webflow landing page, Google forms, Zapier and a PayPal button (here’s what I posted on HN at that time - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32363731).The WhatsApp challenges turned out to be a hit with over 85% checking in daily and 45% repaying to join multiple challenges.After having tried Streaks, Habitify, GTD, reminder apps, google calendar, Notion...etc—I was still having trouble staying consistent with my personal/wellness goals and habits. Methods from Atomic Habits by James Clear—are what worked best for me—but sticking to it alone was hard. For example, I had a daily push-up reminder on my google calendar that I ignored for almost a year.Fast forward, I’m now on day 120+ doing push-ups, meditation and waking up before 6am—after participating in group accountability challenges :)To see if we can scale it to help more people and potentially build a community-driven business—we just released an iOS app.Recap of how it works:- Join 10-30 day accountability challenges in small groups of 3-12 people- Commit a daily goal and check-in with the group on whether you didn’t or didn’t do it- Daily visual progress reports, reward credits/penalties and support from others helps everyone stay on track- Create and join private challenges with friendsWould love to have you try it by joining a challenge—and see if could help you become the person you want be for 2023!

Avatar
5
5
Relevance

Accountable - Habit formation & accountability - crush your goals together

15 Jun 2024 Health Community Task Management

Accountable is a habit formation and accountability app that leverages group accountability to help you stay committed and consistent. Set goals, join or create a cohort, and crush your goals together.

Accountable's Product Hunt launch received positive feedback, with users highlighting the effectiveness of group accountability for achieving goals. Key features mentioned include cohorts and collaboration for enhanced commitment and consistency. Users inquired about Accountable's unique advantages, how the group function works, and whether an account is needed. Time zone handling and specific goals, such as drinking water, were also noted. Overall, users found the tool useful, emphasizing the importance of community accountability.

Users are questioning the product's unique advantages over existing solutions, implying that the current app is sufficient. There are also concerns about how the app handles different time zones, suggesting a need for clarification on its time zone management capabilities.

Avatar
112
7
28.6%
7
112
28.6%
Relevance

Squad Habits - Daily habits & goals together

15 Jan 2024 Android iOS Health & Fitness

Squad is a group accountability app for building positive daily habits in small groups.

The Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with many congratulating the team and praising the app's concept, UI/UX, design, and social accountability features. Users appreciate the potential for habit building, mutual support, and increased productivity. Several users reported the app being unavailable in certain regions (Japan, Poland, Nigeria) and on iOS. Suggestions included public squads, easier invites, and a focus on community. There are questions about the app's network effect and maintaining engagement. Some users also shared their personal experiences with using the app for fitness.

Users expressed concerns about the app's limited regional availability, particularly in Japan and Poland. Several users reported the app was unavailable in their region's app store. There were concerns raised about the landing page's design, specifically the font and size, which didn't meet expectations for some users. Others suggested adding screenshots to the landing page. Users requested more app features and goal customization options. Questions were raised about the app's usefulness if only one friend downloads it, and some faced installation issues. The launch was perceived as taking a long time.

Avatar
365
170
12.9%
170
365
12.9%
Relevance

better mind - Daily habit-building and journal app for self-improvement

26 Jan 2024 iOS Health & Fitness Apple

better mind is a daily habit-building and journal app that helps you achieve your goals of positivity and self-improvement. get notified about one action to try daily, journal about how it made you feel, and track your progress as you grow with each day.

Users generally praise the product's sleek design and simple interface, with one user specifically appreciating the accountability system. Several users downloaded the app and had positive initial experiences, with one user loving the simple design after completing their first journal. There's a suggestion for community features to enhance support and a request for a web version due to phone typing difficulties. Overall, users congratulate the launch and express interest in the product's potential.

Users find typing long texts on their phones to be cumbersome. A suggestion for improvement involves integrating community features into the app to enhance user engagement and experience.

Avatar
37
8
37.5%
8
37
37.5%
Relevance

Mindful - Mindfulness-based day planning for a healthier day-to-day

25 Oct 2023 Calendar Health & Fitness Tech

Mindful is a mobile app that handles daily scheduling for you and in a manner that it produces a less stressful schedule. Comes with many helpful features like tracking your efficiency, remembering to take time out of your day for healthy habits, and more.

The launch is receiving positive feedback, with users praising the product's efficiency and expressing satisfaction. There are congratulations on the launch and recognition of the challenging topic. Users are inquiring about specific features, including comprehensive data tracking, integration with voice assistants like Google Now, and compatibility with work/personal schedules. Suggestions include adding a mood tracker and expanding meditation offerings. One user highlights the product's ability to make finding zen easy and questions it's relevance.

The feedback suggests a potential enhancement by integrating a mood tracker feature to improve the app's functionality. Otherwise, the overall sentiment appears positive, with no other criticisms raised.

Avatar
112
13
13
112
Relevance

We Made a Guided Journaling App for Mindfulness

23 Jul 2024 Writing Meditation Health & Fitness

Hi HN,This is the backstory for Sunrise, our guided journaling app. After experiencing burnout twice, I looked into cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT). Finding the right therapist, however, was costly and frustrating due to inconsistent quality and limited availability. While I eventually succeeded, many aren't as fortunate—roughly 122 million Americans still live in areas lacking sufficient mental health professionals.This challenge led me to an unexpected source of support: mobile apps. Journaling apps, in particular, offered a unique solution for managing my anxiety. They were affordable, self-reliant, private, and portable tools that were also more active and introspective than meditation apps. Despite these benefits, existing journaling apps had their limitations: they focused more on record-keeping than on my mental health.Drawing from these experiences, my cofounders and I made Sunrise, a journal therapy app that goes beyond simply recording daily events. Sunrise enhances mindfulness with evidence-based journal guides, visual mental health progress tracking, and "Positive Notes" for emotional support. Our goal is to provide individuals with the safest digital space to reflect, relax, and recharge on their path to better mental wellbeing.You can see a detailed product demo in our website or download the app for free from July 23 to Aug 1 - let us know what you think HN Community. Cheers!Links:[Website & Demo](https://www.sunrise-app.com/?utm_source=hackernews&utm_mediu...)[iOS Download](https://apps.apple.com/app/apple-store/id6502430422)[Android Download](https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.fimpact.su...)

Avatar
2
2
Relevance

Micro Habits - Supercharge your self-improvement journey

30 May 2023 Android Productivity Health & Fitness

self-improvement app, Habit tracker, goal tracker, todos, routine tracker, mood tracker, journaling, accountability partners, personal weekly and monthly challenges.

Users are congratulating the launch of the Micro Habits app. They are excited about its launch and looking for a comprehensive habit tracking application that can provide contextual habit tracking.

The primary criticism is a request for real-life use cases. Users are seeking practical applications and examples to better understand the product's value and functionality.

Avatar
85
3
33.3%
3
85
33.3%
Relevance

NeuroPeace - System to be more mindful

05 Jul 2024 Health Android Meditation

Transform your mental well-being with NeuroPeace, the app designed to help you cultivate a happier, healthier mind. NeuroPeace empowers you to take control of your emotional health and find balance in your daily life.

Avatar
6
6
Relevance

Challenges App - MVP

24 Apr 2024 Productivity

Hey there! This is my first post on HN! Let's go!!In my opinion, tracking habits through normal habit tracker apps is not much rewarding, as it does not reward you in short-term period, for example after completing 10 days of reading daily.So I have decided to make an app where you can take challenges for X number of days. And after completing them, you can repeat them if you feel like it (to be implemented).It would be great if you can share any suggestions!Thank you!!

Avatar
2
2
Relevance

Habitually - Improve Your Life One Habit at a Time With Our ML Journal

01 Sep 2023 Android Lifestyle Health & Fitness

Revolutionise your wellbeing with Habitually - the ultimate lifestyle tracking app. Our intuitive features and personalized insights empower you to make positive changes and achieve your goals.

Habitually is perceived as a motivating personal wellness coach with intuitive features, aimed at helping users improve their lifestyle and achieve goals. There's encouragement for its potential to help many people. A query was raised regarding personalization and success stories. A potential downside mentioned is user disengagement over time, where enthusiasm wanes, app use declines, and notifications become annoying. There's also a question on how the team will handle questions post-launch.

Users criticize the app for lacking integration with other health apps and wearables. Some users report losing interest and disengaging with the app over time, suggesting a decline in its long-term appeal and user enthusiasm.

Avatar
88
6
0.0%
6
88
16.7%
Relevance

Motivational Health App

25 Feb 2024 Artificial Intelligence Health & Fitness

Hey. Our small team created this app focused on improving motivationally healthy lives and creating motivationally aligned workplaces. It has an AI Virtual Assistant (OpenAI-based), and permits private and group chats. We are looking for partners to help us make the world a better place through motivational health.

Avatar
1
1
Top