Your are here

You're entering a market, the 'Swamp,' filled with ideas that haven't quite taken off. An app that tracks how often someone pees has been tried before, with about 5 similar products already out there. While this gives us medium confidence that the category is real, it also means you'll be facing existing solutions and potential competition. Engagement with these similar apps is low, averaging only 2 comments per product. There are no strong positive signals around people explicitly wanting to use or buy these apps. This suggests a general lack of enthusiasm or a perceived lack of value in the existing market. Because of this, you will need to work hard to differentiate yourself and build demand to stand out. In its current form, this idea does not seem very promising.

Recommendations

1. Start by thoroughly researching why existing pee-tracking apps haven't gained traction. Dive into user reviews, identify pain points, and understand what's missing. Many failed products exist for a reason, and your first job is understanding that reason.
2. If you're still set on this idea, narrow your focus to a specific user group with unmet needs. Perhaps target athletes monitoring hydration, individuals with specific medical conditions (like diabetes or overactive bladder), or elderly people. A more focused value proposition could help gain initial traction.
3. Instead of directly competing with existing apps, explore building tools or features that could enhance them. Think about integrations or add-ons that solve specific problems or address unmet needs. For example, can you build integrations with wearable devices for automated tracking or generate reports for physicians?
4. Consider adjacent problems related to health tracking or personal analytics. Could you pivot to a broader health monitoring app or focus on a more pressing need within the health and wellness space? For instance, tracking fluid intake more broadly or monitoring other bodily functions.
5. Given the lack of enthusiasm for existing solutions and the potential challenges, it might be wise to save your energy for a different opportunity. Explore other ideas or markets that might be more promising and less saturated.
6. Based on user concerns from similar products, pay special attention to data privacy and security. If your app processes health-related information, ensure you comply with all relevant regulations (like HIPAA) and clearly communicate your privacy practices to users. Consider encrypting data and providing transparency around data usage.
7. Since monetization was a concern in similar products, think through your business model early on. Will you offer a subscription, in-app purchases, or partner with healthcare providers? Avoid relying solely on advertising, as this can detract from the user experience.
8. Given that similar products received little engagement in terms of comments, you should carefully study how you can elicit engagement from your target users. Are they on Reddit? Discord? How can you offer value there?

Questions

1. What specific unmet need does your pee-tracking app address that existing solutions have failed to solve? Is there a unique angle or feature that can differentiate your app in a crowded market?
2. How will you ensure data privacy and security, especially if your app collects sensitive health information? What steps will you take to comply with regulations like HIPAA and build trust with your users?
3. What is your plan to generate demand for your app? Given the lack of engagement in similar apps, how will you incentivize users to try your product?