Should I Build It Should I Build It
10 Apr 2025
Hiring Career

Job board that agregates job listings from multiple sources and job ...

...sites along with company career pages

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Swamp

The market has seen several mediocre solutions that nobody loves. Unless you can offer something fundamentally different, you’ll likely struggle to stand out or make money.

Should You Build It?

Don't build it.

Your are here

You're entering a crowded space with your job board aggregator idea. Our data shows 28 similar products already exist, putting you firmly in the 'Swamp' category – a place where many have tried and few have truly thrived. Engagement with these existing job boards is low, with an average of just 2 comments per product launch, indicating a struggle to capture user attention. The good news is that people generally seem open to the concept of a consolidated job board. However, the sheer number of competitors means you'll need a very compelling differentiator to avoid getting lost in the noise. Focus on researching why existing solutions haven't resonated and find a unique angle or underserved niche.

Recommendations

  1. Begin by deeply researching existing job board aggregators. Understand their weaknesses, the user complaints, and where they fall short. Look at the comments and criticism from similar product launches. What are users explicitly asking for that they are not getting? This will help you identify unmet needs and potential differentiation strategies. For example, several similar products lacked industry-specific boards, European companies, remote job options, and detailed company information. Address these gaps in your offering.
  2. Instead of directly competing with established giants, carve out a niche. This could be a specific industry (e.g., sustainability, AI ethics), a particular type of role (e.g., fully remote, visa sponsorship), or a unique demographic (e.g., veterans, neurodiverse individuals). Tailoring your aggregator to a specific audience can significantly increase its relevance and appeal. JobboardHub was criticized for a lack of industry-specific boards, so focusing on a niche would address this criticism.
  3. Consider providing tools or services to existing job boards rather than competing head-on. Can you offer analytics dashboards, candidate enrichment services, or automated content creation for job postings? This approach lets you leverage the existing infrastructure while addressing pain points and creating value. Think of how you can provide value-added solutions on top of existing job boards.
  4. Explore related problems in the hiring space that might be more promising. Instead of aggregation, could you focus on improving candidate screening, automating outreach, or enhancing the employer branding process? Sometimes, the most impactful solutions lie in adjacent areas that are ripe for innovation. Consider whether job aggregation is truly the highest-impact area to focus on.
  5. Before investing significant time and resources, validate your concept with your target audience. Conduct user interviews, run surveys, and create prototypes to gather feedback and iterate on your idea. Ensure that your solution truly resonates with your chosen niche before committing to full-scale development. For example, the jobdata launch had users requesting a trial or preview of listings, which indicates the importance of validating the product before launch.
  6. Carefully consider your monetization strategy. Many job boards rely on premium job postings, subscriptions, or advertising. Analyze the revenue models of your competitors and identify opportunities to innovate. Could you offer performance-based pricing, tiered subscription plans, or value-added services? Ensure that your chosen model aligns with the needs and preferences of your target audience. Also, JobScan Search Engine could add a list of job boards with the countries/niches they cover, and charge for it.
  7. Given that the 'Swamp' is full of similar products, think hard about whether this is the best use of your time and energy. Is there a more pressing problem you could solve, or a more innovative opportunity you could pursue? Be honest with yourself about the potential risks and rewards before diving in headfirst. The idea category explicitly recommends to save your energy for a better opportunity.

Questions

  1. Given the low engagement with existing job boards, what specific features or functionalities will you incorporate to capture and retain user attention within your niche?
  2. If you focus on a niche, what is your distribution strategy to reach those users who might not know that your platform exists, and how will you incentivize job posters to use your aggregator instead of posting directly on LinkedIn or Indeed?
  3. Considering the criticisms of similar platforms (lack of European companies, remote options, detailed company info, unresponsive buttons), how will you proactively address these pain points to deliver a superior user experience from day one?

Your are here

You're entering a crowded space with your job board aggregator idea. Our data shows 28 similar products already exist, putting you firmly in the 'Swamp' category – a place where many have tried and few have truly thrived. Engagement with these existing job boards is low, with an average of just 2 comments per product launch, indicating a struggle to capture user attention. The good news is that people generally seem open to the concept of a consolidated job board. However, the sheer number of competitors means you'll need a very compelling differentiator to avoid getting lost in the noise. Focus on researching why existing solutions haven't resonated and find a unique angle or underserved niche.

Recommendations

  1. Begin by deeply researching existing job board aggregators. Understand their weaknesses, the user complaints, and where they fall short. Look at the comments and criticism from similar product launches. What are users explicitly asking for that they are not getting? This will help you identify unmet needs and potential differentiation strategies. For example, several similar products lacked industry-specific boards, European companies, remote job options, and detailed company information. Address these gaps in your offering.
  2. Instead of directly competing with established giants, carve out a niche. This could be a specific industry (e.g., sustainability, AI ethics), a particular type of role (e.g., fully remote, visa sponsorship), or a unique demographic (e.g., veterans, neurodiverse individuals). Tailoring your aggregator to a specific audience can significantly increase its relevance and appeal. JobboardHub was criticized for a lack of industry-specific boards, so focusing on a niche would address this criticism.
  3. Consider providing tools or services to existing job boards rather than competing head-on. Can you offer analytics dashboards, candidate enrichment services, or automated content creation for job postings? This approach lets you leverage the existing infrastructure while addressing pain points and creating value. Think of how you can provide value-added solutions on top of existing job boards.
  4. Explore related problems in the hiring space that might be more promising. Instead of aggregation, could you focus on improving candidate screening, automating outreach, or enhancing the employer branding process? Sometimes, the most impactful solutions lie in adjacent areas that are ripe for innovation. Consider whether job aggregation is truly the highest-impact area to focus on.
  5. Before investing significant time and resources, validate your concept with your target audience. Conduct user interviews, run surveys, and create prototypes to gather feedback and iterate on your idea. Ensure that your solution truly resonates with your chosen niche before committing to full-scale development. For example, the jobdata launch had users requesting a trial or preview of listings, which indicates the importance of validating the product before launch.
  6. Carefully consider your monetization strategy. Many job boards rely on premium job postings, subscriptions, or advertising. Analyze the revenue models of your competitors and identify opportunities to innovate. Could you offer performance-based pricing, tiered subscription plans, or value-added services? Ensure that your chosen model aligns with the needs and preferences of your target audience. Also, JobScan Search Engine could add a list of job boards with the countries/niches they cover, and charge for it.
  7. Given that the 'Swamp' is full of similar products, think hard about whether this is the best use of your time and energy. Is there a more pressing problem you could solve, or a more innovative opportunity you could pursue? Be honest with yourself about the potential risks and rewards before diving in headfirst. The idea category explicitly recommends to save your energy for a better opportunity.

Questions

  1. Given the low engagement with existing job boards, what specific features or functionalities will you incorporate to capture and retain user attention within your niche?
  2. If you focus on a niche, what is your distribution strategy to reach those users who might not know that your platform exists, and how will you incentivize job posters to use your aggregator instead of posting directly on LinkedIn or Indeed?
  3. Considering the criticisms of similar platforms (lack of European companies, remote options, detailed company info, unresponsive buttons), how will you proactively address these pain points to deliver a superior user experience from day one?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 28
  • Engagement: Low
    • Average number of comments: 2
  • Net use signal: 9.1%
    • Positive use signal: 10.5%
    • Negative use signal: 1.4%
  • Net buy signal: 1.1%
    • Positive buy signal: 2.5%
    • Negative buy signal: 1.4%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

I made a curated job board

21 Jun 2023 Hiring Career

Hi HN!I built a job board that aggregates openings from interesting (and growing) companies that are backed by great investors. The goal is to solve a problem I and some friends face during job hunts; We all start with a spreadsheet hunting down companies we'd be excited to work for, but the process is time-consuming! The goal is to have a place that's done the time consuming research for you.I'm eager for feedback. What is your process when you search for a job? Are some pain points/problems you face?

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Jobboardhub - All job boards in one place

10 Jul 2024 Remote Work Hiring Career

Explore top job boards for remote, design, and AI jobs. Find diverse roles on We Work Remotely, Dribbble, and AI Jobs. Our directory connects you with global opportunities in one place.

JobboardHub's launch on Product Hunt has been met with positive reception, with users describing it as an "excellent resource". One user expressed particular excitement and inquired about the availability of industry-specific job boards on the platform.

The primary criticism focuses on the need for more industry-specific boards to enhance the platform's relevance and utility for users in diverse sectors.

Avatar
16
2
2
16
Relevance

Job Scan Search Engine - Worldwide Jobs Curated In a Single Click

23 Dec 2024 Hiring Productivity Career

🌟 One Platform, Endless Opportunities 🌟 We've built this product to help job seekers 🌍 find all jobs posted across the internet 🖥️ from 150+ job boards 🎯—all in one single platform! 🚀✨ Founder by Borgfy venture studio

Users appreciate the tool for saving time by consolidating job postings and making job searching easier. There's excitement about using the platform to find dream jobs and expand job searches worldwide. One user requested a list of job boards with the countries/niches they cover.

Avatar
10
4
25.0%
4
10
25.0%
Relevance

A tech job board I've been building over the last 8 months

25 Jun 2024 Career

Hey HN! Quick TL; DR: I set up scrapers for the websites of ~20k tech companies, fed the results through GPT, spent some sleepless nights building a web app, and voilá.I started this after getting fed up with how slow LinkedIn felt. I finally got it working and easy to use, so I wanted to share it with you guys.The job list is free. But I’m currently paying a lot of money to OpenAI for all the data I’m passing through GPT, so I may end up eventually charging for some advanced features, or putting ads on it or something.Please let me know what you think!I’m actively developing this so I’m happy to add requested features.Some technical details you may be curious about: - I began gathering the career pages for each company manually, but I ended up hiring a few Filipino contractors to speed up the process. - I run the web scrapers once per day. - I do the web scraping with Node.js. I use cheerio for basic web pages, and puppeteer for more complicated ones. - My OpenAI API dashboard tells me I process 7 million characters per day. - The list doesn’t encompass every single tech company (yet). I have most of the major ones (~20k), but the process of adding new companies is pretty labour intensive so it’s still ongoing. - The web app is built with React, and I got the infinite scrolling to be so smooth using a great library called React Query.For feature requests, please leave a comment here or email me at dorfmanjames@gmail.com

Users suggest adding European companies, remote job options, email alerts, and detailed company information. One user finds the app cool and shares a related link.

The product lacks European companies, remote job options, email alerts, and detailed company information.

Avatar
3
2
2
3
Relevance

A simple tool to help with job search via Google (and why) – Joseef

24 Apr 2024 Hiring Career

TL;DR: Google has all the data and allows searching several companies job portals at once. That's how I've found my current position. This tool helps to manage queries.Some time ago it became apparent to me that most job boards I know became aggregators — most companies have their own job portals or at least pages on their sites, and those aggregators most of the time just collect postings. Of course they try to add value to it, but sometimes they try too much (adding complex interface), they choose what companies to show to you and postings become stale.So I tried searching on companies' job boards directly with Google excluding middleman, as those portals often don't have search features, and found my current position!At that time I stored queries in my notebook. But recently I've realized that Google is even more powerful — it allows searching on several portals at once. With this, complexity of queries starts to grow and managing queries in the notebook becomes difficult — queries are too long and hard to edit (add or exclude portals).Initially I thought that it was too simple to be shared with others (anyone can Google), but when complexity started to grow I made this page and it looks like now it may be useful to others.Hope it helps you!

Avatar
2
2
Relevance

I built a developer only job board

08 Dec 2023 Hiring

Hi everyone, So quick backstory: I was laid off from my job some time back and decided to embark on the journey to be an IndieHacker, my first 2 projects flopped miserably (whole other story) so I started looking for a new job. I've just noticed many job boards barely have new roles for days and many new openings are not development related roles, so stuff like marketing, sales, and management roles.The ones that did have new roles needed you to create an account to then apply, what happened to job boards just posting jobs and application links? Why do I have to be a user on 3 or 4 different platforms just to apply for new openings?Anyway I created mine which is pretty much that, see a job opening, read job description and go to application link.I'm actively adding new roles everyday, if your company is hiring, please consider posting the job on the site.Otherwise all your feedback is welcome!

Avatar
3
3
Relevance

jobdataapi.com - Simple Job Data API

27 Feb 2024 Data Hiring API

Backfill your job board or gather insights into the hiring market with our fast & simple API - access job post data in JSON format from thousands of companies hiring across many different industries.

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

jobdata - Simple job data API

21 Jun 2023 Data API Career

Backfill your job board with our fast & simple API and access job post data in JSON format from thousands of companies hiring in the tech space across many different industries.

Users expressed interest in the product's concept and API, with one user praising the API and its potential. Concerns were raised about the project's sustainability based on membership. Some users requested a trial or preview of listings, while another inquired about the data collection process, specifically whether it involves scraping or manual outreach. Another user requested the ability to add user-added filters to the API.

Users express concerns about the product's sustainability if paid memberships aren't enough. They also request user-added filters for better search functionality. A lack of a free trial or preview, especially for Indian internship listings, is also a point of criticism.

Avatar
79
5
5
79
Relevance

Simple Job Data API

27 Feb 2024 Data Hiring

Backfill your job board or gather insights into the hiring market with our fast & simple API - access job post data in JSON format from thousands of companies hiring across many different industries.For my PH launch this way please: https://www.producthunt.com/posts/jobdataapi-com-2

Love it, suggest naming sources.

Name the sources.

Avatar
3
1
1
3
Relevance

JobBoardBox - The largest directory of job boards on the internet.

13 Jul 2024 Search Remote Work Career

Job searching shouldn't be a full-time job itself. That's why we created JobBoardBox. We've gathered over 1000 job boards from around the world, neatly organized by country, language, and industry. No more wasted time or missed opportunities.

The Product Hunt launch received positive feedback with congratulations. Users noted the platform appears well-built and the timing is good, given recent layoffs in the industry. One user requested the addition of Calm Jobs to the platform.

Avatar
11
3
3
11
Relevance

I created an easy way to find new job postings

27 Mar 2024 Hiring Career

Hi everyone! During my layoff last year, I had a hard time finding jobs through LinkedIn, indeed, and other services. The listings were old and usually had hundreds of applicants. After a few months, I landed on a super simple process that I created in Notion that got me more interviews. Then, I converted it into a simple website.I hope it's a tool you can use every day to find your next opportunity. Please share this post if it's helpful!Pro tip: Use commas in the job title to search for multiple jobs like:qa engineer, engineering manager, data scientist

Users have requested adding the number of results next to links and a feature to exclude remote jobs by adding '-remote' to job titles. One user praised the site as a game changer, thanking Brian. There was also an unclear comment with no specific content.

The main criticisms are that most search results are empty and it is unclear if locations can be searched as keywords.

Avatar
3
4
25.0%
4
3
25.0%
Relevance

Find Visa Sponsorsip and Relocation Support Jobs

01 Jul 2024 Career

I built a job board focused on visa sponsorship and relocation support jobs

Users report issues with the 'Find Jobs' button, which seems unresponsive or doesn't scroll as expected, especially on Firefox. There's a call for more functionality like search and filters for location and technology. The site's job listings are limited, and there's a suggestion to reconsider the $99 fee. Positive feedback includes liking the website's design, but there are questions about job sourcing and the desire for more listings. One user specifically wants a location filter for relocation purposes. There are also flagged comments, indicating moderation may be needed.

Users reported issues with navigation, such as a non-functional button and a Jobs link that doesn't scroll. There were also calls to drop the $99 fee and manually vet postings. The lack of search, location, and tech filters was criticized, along with a 'Find jobs' button that is unresponsive on Firefox. Additionally, there's no location filter for relocation jobs.

Avatar
38
10
-10.0%
-10.0%
10
38
Relevance

A job board for remote jobs in Europe

19 Oct 2024 Remote Work Career

Hi all! I've been working remotely for many years. First as a customer support rep, then as a UX/UI Designer. I was frustrated with the landscape of remote job boards for people who live in Europe. Sometimes you find a great job opportunity only to discover that its geographical or time-zone restrictions exclude you.This was a huge waste of time, so I decided to do something about it and created this job board. After posting jobs into the abyss for a while, I decided to focus on SEO and getting backlinks. The website now gets about 3,000 unique visitors per month and has 350 newsletter subscribers.It's not much, but I'm happy to solve a problem that I had.I know most people here are americans, but I thought I would post just in case someone plans to move or travel to Europe :D

Created job board for remote jobs in Europe.

Geographical/time-zone restrictions waste time.

Avatar
3
1
1
3
Relevance

Job Boardly - Launch a fully-functional, SEO-friendly job board in minutes

02 May 2024 Website Builder SEO No-Code

Job Boardly allows anyone to launch a fully-functional, SEO-friendly job board in minutes. Easily customize your job board with a simple, no-code interface and tailor your board to meet the needs of your niche or industry. Pay once, own it forever.

JobBoardly's Product Hunt launch garnered overwhelmingly positive feedback, with users praising its ease of use, no-code interface, excellent customer support, and value for money. Many highlighted the potential for creating niche job boards and lauded the platform as a perfect solution for the job board business. Users appreciated the constant updates and agile job board creation capabilities. There were also inquiries regarding hosting and account limits. Several users congratulated the team on the launch and wished them success.

The primary criticism revolves around the extent of customization options. Users are inquiring about the depth and breadth of available settings and configurations.

Avatar
201
20
30.0%
10.0%
20
201
30.0%
10.0%
Relevance

Dropboard - Finally, a hiring platform anyone can use

21 Apr 2023 Human Resources No-Code Hiring

Add Dropboard to your /careers page and showcase open jobs. Candidates apply inline and hiring managers receive resumes, automatically converted to PDF, in their inbox.

Users appreciate the improved hiring process experience. However, it's important for lawyers to verify the name/brandmark due to its similarity to a Dropbox recruitment product.

The primary criticism is that the product's name and brandmark too closely resemble Dropbox's recruitment product. This similarity raises concerns about potential brand confusion and originality.

Avatar
78
2
2
78
Top