Should I Build It Should I Build It
18 Jul 2025
Hiring Career

Every time we apply for a job, we fill the same details again and ...

...again. Instead of that, you create a profile in a website that has all commonly asked questions and you feed your answers. Then you just copy paste what you have written in the job applications. Makes the work faster

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Swamp

The market has seen several mediocre solutions that nobody loves. Unless you can offer something fundamentally different, you’ll likely struggle to stand out or make money.

Should You Build It?

Don't build it.

Your are here

Your idea falls into a crowded space where many have attempted to streamline the job application process. With 14 similar products already identified, the competition is significant. The general sentiment surrounding these tools suggests a 'Swamp' category, indicating that many existing solutions are perceived as mediocre. While there isn't a strong negative signal in terms of people explicitly saying they wouldn't use or buy similar products, the lack of positive signals (net use and net buy are neutral) suggests people aren't necessarily excited about these solutions either. The low engagement (average of 3 comments) across these similar products reinforces this lukewarm reception. Entering this market requires a fundamentally different approach to stand out.

Recommendations

  1. Before investing further, deeply investigate why existing job application solutions haven't resonated with users. Identify the pain points they consistently fail to address. Look closely at the criticisms leveled against similar products: data privacy concerns, lack of personalization, and ineffectiveness against Applicant Tracking Systems (ATS).
  2. If you decide to proceed, don't aim to be a general solution. Carve out a niche by focusing on a specific group of job seekers who are particularly underserved. For example, you could focus on a specific industry, experience level, or demographic group. Specialization could provide a competitive edge.
  3. Instead of building a direct competitor, consider developing tools or integrations for existing job platforms or ATS providers. This could involve creating plugins or extensions that enhance their functionality, addressing specific pain points in the job application process.
  4. Explore adjacent problems within the job search and career development space that might be more promising. Perhaps focus on interview preparation, skills training, or career coaching, where there may be less direct competition and more unmet needs.
  5. Instead of focusing on copy/pasting, explore AI-driven personalization. Many users of similar tools want assistance with Applicant Tracking System (ATS) optimization. Address this need by providing tailored guidance to improve job application materials and strategies.
  6. Develop a clear value proposition that differentiates your product from existing solutions. What unique benefit will users receive that they can't find elsewhere? Emphasize the benefits in your marketing materials and product messaging.

Questions

  1. What specific unmet needs or pain points within the job application process are you uniquely positioned to address that existing solutions have overlooked?
  2. How will you ensure that your platform prioritizes data privacy and security, addressing a key concern raised by users of similar services?
  3. Given the prevalence of Applicant Tracking Systems (ATS), how will your platform help users optimize their resumes and cover letters to increase their chances of getting noticed by recruiters?

Your are here

Your idea falls into a crowded space where many have attempted to streamline the job application process. With 14 similar products already identified, the competition is significant. The general sentiment surrounding these tools suggests a 'Swamp' category, indicating that many existing solutions are perceived as mediocre. While there isn't a strong negative signal in terms of people explicitly saying they wouldn't use or buy similar products, the lack of positive signals (net use and net buy are neutral) suggests people aren't necessarily excited about these solutions either. The low engagement (average of 3 comments) across these similar products reinforces this lukewarm reception. Entering this market requires a fundamentally different approach to stand out.

Recommendations

  1. Before investing further, deeply investigate why existing job application solutions haven't resonated with users. Identify the pain points they consistently fail to address. Look closely at the criticisms leveled against similar products: data privacy concerns, lack of personalization, and ineffectiveness against Applicant Tracking Systems (ATS).
  2. If you decide to proceed, don't aim to be a general solution. Carve out a niche by focusing on a specific group of job seekers who are particularly underserved. For example, you could focus on a specific industry, experience level, or demographic group. Specialization could provide a competitive edge.
  3. Instead of building a direct competitor, consider developing tools or integrations for existing job platforms or ATS providers. This could involve creating plugins or extensions that enhance their functionality, addressing specific pain points in the job application process.
  4. Explore adjacent problems within the job search and career development space that might be more promising. Perhaps focus on interview preparation, skills training, or career coaching, where there may be less direct competition and more unmet needs.
  5. Instead of focusing on copy/pasting, explore AI-driven personalization. Many users of similar tools want assistance with Applicant Tracking System (ATS) optimization. Address this need by providing tailored guidance to improve job application materials and strategies.
  6. Develop a clear value proposition that differentiates your product from existing solutions. What unique benefit will users receive that they can't find elsewhere? Emphasize the benefits in your marketing materials and product messaging.

Questions

  1. What specific unmet needs or pain points within the job application process are you uniquely positioned to address that existing solutions have overlooked?
  2. How will you ensure that your platform prioritizes data privacy and security, addressing a key concern raised by users of similar services?
  3. Given the prevalence of Applicant Tracking Systems (ATS), how will your platform help users optimize their resumes and cover letters to increase their chances of getting noticed by recruiters?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 14
  • Engagement: Low
    • Average number of comments: 3
  • Net use signal: 9.3%
    • Positive use signal: 13.6%
    • Negative use signal: 4.3%
  • Net buy signal: -4.3%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.0%
    • Negative buy signal: 4.3%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

OneApply - A smarter way to apply for jobs

14 Jun 2023 Artificial Intelligence Hiring Browser Extensions

Apply to any job on the internet with one click. Our browser extension will autofill the whole application, and can even fill out those tougher questions and cover letters using AI!

The AI responder for employers received positive feedback for automating communication and saving time. Users congratulated the launch and praised its impressive innovation. The product is considered amazing and one of the best for finding jobs and employees. It simplifies the job application process with AI-powered assistance, particularly the AI cover letters. Users appreciated the name and branding. One user highlighted its use for hiring in Uzbekistan. The tool aims to make job searching less painful.

The primary criticism revolves around concerns about the overuse of AI in automating communication, specifically fearing the implications for employers potentially misusing the technology.

Avatar
114
13
23.1%
13
114
23.1%
Relevance

A website that tailors your resume for each job you apply for

05 Jun 2024 Hiring Career

Hey HN,I'm excited to share a project I've been working on for the past few months. As someone who has spent countless hours tweaking my resume for different job applications, I wanted to find a way to make this process more efficient and effective. So, I built a website that tailors your resume for each job you apply for.You can check it out here: https://resume.inkLooking forward to your thoughts!Cheers, Sami

Users expressed concerns about data privacy and the handling of resumes. The job application interface was criticized, and comparisons were made with other services like Jobscan and Teal, with some users not impressed but others excited to try the new service. There were mixed reviews on the resume suggestions feature, and one user mentioned cancelling during the trial. A free resume download with a promo code and a JSON Resume option were highlighted. Feedback was given on user experience, a homepage example, and an upload bug. The development of a feature using GPTs for merging information was mentioned, as well as the potential for AI collaboration. There were sarcastic comments and encouragement for the author to continue improving the service.

Users expressed concerns about data retention and unwanted marketing emails, and found the job application interfaces confusing. The integration with Jobscan and Teal was not well-received. Technical issues included problems with editing, replacement, a missing next button, homepage example, and an upload bug. Users also faced challenges with additive synonyms and deletions. There was sarcasm regarding the importance of Hacker News, and criticism about the resume example not being tailored. Additionally, concerns were raised about the automation aspect of the resume processes.

Avatar
32
15
6.7%
-6.7%
15
32
13.3%
Relevance

BulkApply - Apply to hundreds of jobs in a single click

02 Apr 2024 LinkedIn Productivity Career

Discover and organize job listings effortlessly! Browse, bookmark jobs (Linkedin, Glassdoor, Workday). Apply to hundreds of jobs with one click. Track applications and connect seamlessly. Get set for job application magic with one click!

The Product Hunt launch received mixed feedback. One user reported an issue with the landing page, where signing up led to a 'not built yet' message. However, another user expressed appreciation for the app and its potential to help many people. A third user congratulated the launcher on the launch.

The primary criticism is that the product is not yet built, despite offering a sign-up option on the landing page. This creates a negative user experience as users expect a functional product when given the opportunity to register.

Avatar
99
3
0.0%
-33.3%
3
99
33.3%
Relevance

I built a Chrome extension to auto-apply to jobs

01 Aug 2024 Artificial Intelligence Hiring Productivity Career

I was laid of from a YC company last November and during my job search I got this idea to build an extension that would help me apply to jobs a lot faster. 2 months later, InstaApply was born.The extension really makes applying to jobs super easy. Usually, it takes applying to dozens of jobs to land something and requires filling out the same data over and over again. Which is pretty annoying.This is where InstaApply comes in, it automates all the boring parts of applying to jobs with Ai, condensing the process to just seconds.InstaApply will fill out all the form fields, tailor your cover letter and your resume, all in a flash.How it works: We ask some information from users, analyze their resumes and feed this data to our Ai (along with job description) which intelligently fills out answers with accuracy. Even things like "why work for our company", "what project are you most proud of", location preferences etc.My aim is to help job seekers focus on their skills and interviewing while we take care of the monotonous tasks.

Users suggest that experienced job seekers should focus on targeted applications rather than sending out numerous resumes. Additionally, they highlight that Applicant Tracking Systems (ATS) pose a significant challenge in the job application process.

Critics argue that shotgunning resumes is viewed negatively by experienced candidates and that ATS systems filter out most applications, making it difficult for candidates to get noticed.

Avatar
12
2
2
12
Relevance

AI tool to tailor resume and cover letter, and prepare for interviews

06 Nov 2023 Hiring Career

Hi HN Community! I'd really appreciate your feedback on my new web app for job seekers. What it can do:1. Help you optimize your resume for a specific job description.2. Write a personalized cover letter.3. Identify most likely interview questions for the role and provide real-time feedback during mock interviews.The backend is written in Python (Flask). It relies on an internal database and multiple external APIs (incl. ChatGPT). The frontend is HTML/CSS/JavaScript.I'm very curious: What do you like and dislike the most about it? Did you experience any weird issues as you were playing around with it? And what would you suggest to improve? Thanks!

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Shy Apply - Never fill out a job application again

16 Jul 2024 Career

A desktop app that automates the process of searching for jobs. It handles the searching and applying so you can focus on nailing interviews. Our search is organic all natural human-intelligence (not chatGPT!) to get accurate job matches!

Avatar
9
9
Relevance

Vitae - Let's you create resume and cover letter using AI

02 May 2024 Artificial Intelligence Hiring Career

Create custom resume and cover letter, specific to a job description in minutes if not seconds

The Product Hunt launch received positive feedback, with users congratulating the team. Several users inquired about the product's AI capabilities, specifically its adaptability and refinement. There was also interest in personalization features. One user expressed hope that the product would assist job seekers. Another user congratulated the team and asked about their waitlist number, while yet another upvoted, noting that the product helps to reduce resume tweaking time.

The primary criticism focuses on the need for a more personal touch and assistance with Applicant Tracking System (ATS) optimization. Users are looking for features that go beyond automated processes and provide tailored guidance to improve their job application materials and strategies.

Avatar
52
4
4
52
Relevance

Instant Job Cover Letters with AI - Speed up your job applications by 10x, just drop a resume

20 Jan 2023 Writing Hiring Career

Never write another cover letter. Just drop in your resume and paste the job description! AI will analyze your skills and experiences and write a tailored cover letter that meets the job description. Disclaimer: For entertainment only. Use at your own risk.

The product launch received enthusiastic approval, with users finding the concept amazing. There's a sentiment that AI is becoming increasingly prevalent. A specific pain point addressed is the difficulty of cover letters, with hope that the product will broadly assist job seekers in overcoming this challenge.

Avatar
91
3
3
91
Relevance

I made a site to create cover letters, simplifying job applications

05 Apr 2024 Artificial Intelligence Career

I am recently testing the job market and have noticed that when I send a cover letter I have more responses from companies. I thought it could be automated and perhaps be helpful to more people.I know anyone could do it with ChatGPT (I was doing it that way), but just pasting the job URL and having a perfect copy/paste ready cover letter has been very convenient and time-saving for me.Would love to get your feedback ;)

Avatar
1
1
Top