Should I Build It Should I Build It
22 Mar 2025
Artificial Intelligence Health Health & Fitness

An AI-powered tool that generates personalized affirmations and ...

...positive self-talk prompts, helping users build confidence and improve their mental health, for daily support.

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Swamp

The market has seen several mediocre solutions that nobody loves. Unless you can offer something fundamentally different, you’ll likely struggle to stand out or make money.

Should You Build It?

Don't build it.

Your are here

Your idea for an AI-powered affirmation and self-talk prompt generator places you in a crowded space. The "Swamp" category, where numerous similar solutions exist but fail to truly resonate with users, accurately describes this landscape. With 29 similar products already identified, competition is high. Engagement, measured by the average number of comments on these products, is low. This suggests that while many have attempted this, few have truly captured sustained user interest. The absence of net use and buy signals indicates a neutral sentiment; people aren't necessarily expressing a strong desire to use or pay for these types of products, but it is also not overtly negative. Therefore, differentiating your product is crucial to avoid getting lost in the swamp.

Recommendations

  1. Given the crowded market, deeply research why existing affirmation and self-talk apps haven't achieved widespread success. Analyze user reviews, identify unmet needs, and understand the limitations of current AI-driven solutions. Pay special attention to the criticism that users seek more clarity on how affirmations are personalized and the uncertainty around the final output of the tool, which are common threads across multiple similar products.
  2. If you choose to proceed, focus on a specific niche or underserved group within the mental health space. For example, tailor your affirmations to address the unique challenges faced by students, new parents, or individuals recovering from specific traumas. Specialization will make your product stand out and allow for more targeted and effective content.
  3. Consider offering your AI affirmation generation as a tool for existing mental health providers rather than directly to consumers. Therapists, coaches, and support groups could use your technology to personalize affirmations for their clients, integrating it into their existing practices. This approach sidesteps direct competition and taps into established distribution channels.
  4. Since several similar products faced criticism for potential legal and ethical concerns tied to AI and mental health, clearly communicate how your tool avoids harmful suggestions. For example, provide disclaimers that the AI is not a replacement for professional therapy and include safety guidelines for usage.
  5. Explore adjacent problems within the mental wellness domain. Perhaps instead of generating affirmations, focus on AI-powered journaling prompts, guided meditation scripts, or tools for tracking mood and identifying triggers. These related areas may present less competition and greater opportunities for innovation.
  6. Before investing significant time and resources, rigorously validate your core assumptions. Conduct user interviews, prototype your AI affirmation generator, and gather feedback on its perceived value. If the response is lukewarm, be prepared to pivot or explore alternative ideas. User curiosity about AI's ability to adapt to their progress is a recurring topic. Ensure your product delivers on this, to prove it is a cut above the rest!

Questions

  1. Considering the low engagement with existing affirmation apps, what specific features or approaches will you incorporate to foster consistent user engagement and make your product a daily habit rather than a fleeting novelty?
  2. Given the concerns around AI in mental health, how will you ensure ethical use, data privacy, and user safety while building trust and transparency with your target audience, to avoid some of the criticisms levelled against similar products?
  3. How will you measure and demonstrate the effectiveness of your AI-generated affirmations in improving users' mental well-being, and what metrics will you use to validate the impact of your product beyond simple user satisfaction scores?

Your are here

Your idea for an AI-powered affirmation and self-talk prompt generator places you in a crowded space. The "Swamp" category, where numerous similar solutions exist but fail to truly resonate with users, accurately describes this landscape. With 29 similar products already identified, competition is high. Engagement, measured by the average number of comments on these products, is low. This suggests that while many have attempted this, few have truly captured sustained user interest. The absence of net use and buy signals indicates a neutral sentiment; people aren't necessarily expressing a strong desire to use or pay for these types of products, but it is also not overtly negative. Therefore, differentiating your product is crucial to avoid getting lost in the swamp.

Recommendations

  1. Given the crowded market, deeply research why existing affirmation and self-talk apps haven't achieved widespread success. Analyze user reviews, identify unmet needs, and understand the limitations of current AI-driven solutions. Pay special attention to the criticism that users seek more clarity on how affirmations are personalized and the uncertainty around the final output of the tool, which are common threads across multiple similar products.
  2. If you choose to proceed, focus on a specific niche or underserved group within the mental health space. For example, tailor your affirmations to address the unique challenges faced by students, new parents, or individuals recovering from specific traumas. Specialization will make your product stand out and allow for more targeted and effective content.
  3. Consider offering your AI affirmation generation as a tool for existing mental health providers rather than directly to consumers. Therapists, coaches, and support groups could use your technology to personalize affirmations for their clients, integrating it into their existing practices. This approach sidesteps direct competition and taps into established distribution channels.
  4. Since several similar products faced criticism for potential legal and ethical concerns tied to AI and mental health, clearly communicate how your tool avoids harmful suggestions. For example, provide disclaimers that the AI is not a replacement for professional therapy and include safety guidelines for usage.
  5. Explore adjacent problems within the mental wellness domain. Perhaps instead of generating affirmations, focus on AI-powered journaling prompts, guided meditation scripts, or tools for tracking mood and identifying triggers. These related areas may present less competition and greater opportunities for innovation.
  6. Before investing significant time and resources, rigorously validate your core assumptions. Conduct user interviews, prototype your AI affirmation generator, and gather feedback on its perceived value. If the response is lukewarm, be prepared to pivot or explore alternative ideas. User curiosity about AI's ability to adapt to their progress is a recurring topic. Ensure your product delivers on this, to prove it is a cut above the rest!

Questions

  1. Considering the low engagement with existing affirmation apps, what specific features or approaches will you incorporate to foster consistent user engagement and make your product a daily habit rather than a fleeting novelty?
  2. Given the concerns around AI in mental health, how will you ensure ethical use, data privacy, and user safety while building trust and transparency with your target audience, to avoid some of the criticisms levelled against similar products?
  3. How will you measure and demonstrate the effectiveness of your AI-generated affirmations in improving users' mental well-being, and what metrics will you use to validate the impact of your product beyond simple user satisfaction scores?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 29
  • Engagement: Low
    • Average number of comments: 2
  • Net use signal: 10.6%
    • Positive use signal: 16.7%
    • Negative use signal: 6.2%
  • Net buy signal: -4.6%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.0%
    • Negative buy signal: 4.6%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Manifest AI - AI Powered Daily Affirmations

30 Dec 2024 Artificial Intelligence iOS Health & Fitness

Manifest AI merges AI-driven affirmations, daily typing or speaking practice, and progress tracking. Let AI adapt your routine and guide you through consistent positivity. Build the mindset you need to truly manifest your goals.

Users appreciate the product, highlighting its focus on positive practices and tracking over traditional to-do lists. One user suggested the addition of daily, AI-generated goals or challenges to further enhance the experience. Another user is curious about the AI's ability to adapt to their progress and improvements over time.

Avatar
16
4
75.0%
4
16
75.0%
Relevance

Affirm - AI-generated positive affirmations to make your life easier

06 Jun 2023 Artificial Intelligence Web App Health & Fitness

Rejections? Setbacks? Failure? Life-ing is hard. Affirm helps you power through life's hurdles by generating empowering affirmations. Affirm uses the latest NLP techniques to generate affirmations. Just type in your grievance and let Affirm work its magic!

Affirm received positive feedback for its empowering and helpful nature, particularly during difficult times. Users found it to be a quick and cool source of positivity, aiding daily life and mental health. One user specifically tried it and found it super helpful. There's also interest in the final product and questions about how affirmations adapt to grievances.

Users seek more clarity on how the tool personalizes affirmations. There is also uncertainty regarding the final output or deliverable of the tool, leaving users wondering what the ultimate result will be.

Avatar
79
7
14.3%
7
79
14.3%
Relevance

AtFirst - AI voice-guided daily affirmations to help you feel happier

18 Jul 2023 Android Meditation Health & Fitness

AtFirst is designed to bring a smile to your face with a curated affirmation experience. With the help of AI, the app offers a unique experience that combines the benefits of guided meditation with the power of affirmations.

The app launch received positive feedback, with users praising the idea and its potential to promote positivity and mindfulness. One user suggested "daily monkey affirmations" as a future evolution. Another user recommended listing the app on AI directories like wikigpt3.com for increased visibility. Several users congratulated the developers on the launch, and one expressed excitement about using the downloaded app, finding it beautiful.

Avatar
78
6
16.7%
6
78
16.7%
Relevance

Inspire AI - Feel better with AI crafted motivation

03 Sep 2023 Artificial Intelligence Productivity Health & Fitness

Inspire AI is your AI-powered personal motivator. Get an endless stream of personalized affirmations and daily motivations with each message designed to make you feel better, more motivated, and inspired. Offer link: https://apple.co/3DSdFm1

Users are congratulating the Product Hunt launch. One user is requesting a feature for the app to draft quotes in the style of famous authors. An offer was made to promote Inspire AI and provide discounts to members.

A user expressed a desire for the app to be able to draft quotes like favorite authors, although this was the only criticism presented.

Avatar
122
3
33.3%
3
122
33.3%
Relevance

My attempt creating an AI therapist

19 Feb 2024 Artificial Intelligence

Five months back, I started building Visioncast. Drawing inspiration from psychology-related books like "Psychocybernetics" and "What to Say When You Talk to Yourself", I've been fascinated by the power of affirmations and positive self-talk. This fascination was the seed for Visioncast, guiding users through personalized audio exercises including affirmations, meditations, motivational speeches, and visualizations, all tailored to their individual needs.I'm leveraging GPT-4 and TTS to deliver content that's not just personalized but deeply resonant with the challenges and aspirations of the user. Whether it's bolstering self-esteem or stopping procrastination, the app is aims to support mental and emotional well-being.Perfecting the user experience has been tricky. Right now I'm copying ChatGPT's suggestion cards to start you out, paired with a customization screen that offers extensive control over the final output. This level of personalization sets Visioncast from app like Calm, Headspace, and Waking Up, which offer no personalization.In the first version, it took 1m 20s to generate audio. I had to wait for the whole GPT4 response to come in. I've streamlined audio processing and streaming (with lots of fighting with AWS/Django/React Native and Nginx) And now, with the app inching ever closer to what I envisioned as an AI mentor, the validation from our first two paying users has been incredibly affirming.I'd love to hear your insights/feedback, as I'm still working out UX and some bugs.

Avatar
2
2
Relevance

An AI mental health assistant to help you feel better

01 Nov 2023 Artificial Intelligence Health Health & Fitness

Users referenced an Adam Curtis documentary and an 80s Carl Rogers chat bot. One user criticized ChatGPT 3.5 for being overly apologetic and verbose. Another user simply stated that 'Comment is dead.'

The main criticism is that the product or service involves excessive talking and frequent apologies, which users find unnecessary and potentially annoying.

Avatar
2
3
-33.3%
-33.3%
3
2
Relevance

ThoughtCoach: Helping to improve mental health with AI

10 Apr 2023 Artificial Intelligence Health Health & Fitness

Users expressed concerns about the mental health experience, legal compliance, and ethics of using GPT-4 for mental health purposes. There were suggestions for professional help options like NHS and BetterHelp. Some found the idea cool but needing refinement, while others were positive about the project's progress. Criticisms included the approach to using AI, the need for human oversight, and potential liability issues. There was interest in gamification but also concerns about the lack of human interaction and the risk of AI suggesting harmful actions. One comment was deleted.

Users expressed concerns about the product's potential for legal liability and harm, emphasizing that language models are not suitable for mental health applications. Criticisms include the risk of charlatans despite high qualifications, the product's poorly thought-out approach that could harm individuals, the issue of AI confidently providing incorrect answers, and the lack of human interaction in apps which may reduce effectiveness. Additionally, there are worries about how the product would handle liability in the event of psychiatric episodes and the danger of AI suggesting harmful actions.

Avatar
18
12
-25.0%
-16.7%
12
18
Relevance

Mind – Daily Affirmations - Positive motivation app

27 Jun 2023 Meditation

iPhone app to set you up for any life situation, from relaxing in the face of crazy news to finding confidence in yourself during a workout at the gym.

The general sentiment across all comments is congratulatory towards Mind's product launch. Users are expressing excitement and intent to try the product. One user specifically mentioned the positive impact of affirmations in addressing insecurities and achieving goals, also showing love for the design.

Avatar
104
4
25.0%
4
104
25.0%
Relevance

Receive tailored well-being assistance through personalized support

17 Mar 2023 Artificial Intelligence Health & Fitness Bots

Greetings, esteemed members of Hacker News community!I am thrilled to present my latest project - an innovative chatbot meticulously crafted to deliver tailored guidance and support for your mental well-being. Drawing from my in-depth research in psychology and self-help chatbots, I have spent several months actively training this bot to ensure it provides a truly exceptional experience.To experience it firsthand, please visit https://minds.ee. The chatbot will offer personalized guidance and support, tailored to your specific requirements in a user-friendly and welcoming format.As a strong proponent of providing access to resources that help prioritize mental well-being, I believe technology can play a pivotal role in achieving this goal. If you would like to learn more about my project or explore the chatbot further, please don't hesitate to reach out - I would be delighted to hear from you!

Avatar
3
3
Relevance

Personalized Chatbot Therapist

20 Mar 2023 Artificial Intelligence Health & Fitness Bots

Greetings, esteemed members of Hacker News community!I am thrilled to present my latest project - an innovative chatbot meticulously crafted to deliver tailored guidance and support for your mental well-being. Drawing from my in-depth research in psychology and self-help chatbots, I have spent several months actively training this bot to ensure it provides a truly exceptional experience.To experience it firsthand, please visit https://minds.ee. The chatbot will offer personalized guidance and support, tailored to your specific requirements in a user-friendly and welcoming format.As a strong proponent of providing access to resources that help prioritize mental well-being, I believe technology can play a pivotal role in achieving this goal. If you would like to learn more about my project or explore the chatbot further, please don't hesitate to reach out - I would be delighted to hear from you!

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Flourish - AI-powered self therapy

18 Apr 2023 Artificial Intelligence Health Health & Fitness

Flourish aims to improve access and affordability to mental health and wellness support by offering AI-Powered Self Therapy tools delivered through our mobile app for a fraction of the cost of traditional therapy.

Users praised the product's cool icon and its helpful concept. There's excitement around the launch, with users eager to try it out and describing it as an extraordinary creation. Good luck was wished for the launch.

Avatar
82
3
33.3%
3
82
33.3%
Relevance

Minds.ee – Enhanced Mental Health Chatbot with Memory and Improved AI

09 Nov 2023 Artificial Intelligence

HN Community,I’m here to share an evolution of Minds.ee, a project some of you might remember from its early days. Built on feedback and insights from diverse user bases, including tech professionals, we've rolled out significant updates: Persistent Memory: Incorporating chat history, Minds.ee now provides continuity in mental health support, allowing users to revisit past conversations and track progress over time. Advanced AI Understanding: We've refined the AI's ability to grasp and reflect on psychological intricacies, aiming for a nuanced, empathetic dialogue that resonates with human experiences. Faster Interaction: Response times are crucial, so we've optimized the chatbot for quicker exchanges, facilitating smoother and more efficient user support. This isn't just a product update—it's a step towards a more empathetic and accessible mental health resource. Minds.ee is an ongoing effort to blend technology with the human element of psychological support, and we're keen to see how it can further evolve with HN's astute feedback.Explore the updated experience at minds.ee and let’s discuss the intersections of AI, mental health, and how tech can be leveraged for greater good.Thank you for your time and thoughts.Alex-Andre Viik Founder and developer of MindSee

Minds.ee updates: persistent memory, advanced AI, faster interaction.

Avatar
1
1
1
1
Relevance

Emotional Support AI - Emotional support through empathetic AI, powered by ChatGPT

22 Jun 2023 Artificial Intelligence Health Health & Fitness

Experience accessible, personalized emotional support through empathetic artificial intelligence, powered by ChatGPT API.

The Product Hunt launch received positive feedback, with users praising its intuitive design and unique approach to addressing loneliness. There's support for its mission to promote positive AI. Suggestions included exploring WikiGPT3 and submitting the app to directories. Some concerns were raised about the utility of the voice feature in public settings. One user felt the project deserved more upvotes.

Users find the voice feature impractical for public use, favoring text chat. There is also concern about the long-term availability of free access, as it might be a limited-time offer.

Avatar
86
4
25.0%
4
86
25.0%
Relevance

My Chatbot-Assisted Mental Health Recovery

20 Nov 2024 Artificial Intelligence Health

Recently I had a mental breakdown for family related issues. I created the chatbot to have some support, and it helped me a lot. It was able to answer delicate questions and also gave me the advices that made me more calm and focus on myself as well. It's a simple chatbot, I used a prompt that gives support instead of judging. I will make it open-source if it gets enough interest.

Users appreciate the chatbot for providing support and advice during mental breakdowns. There are also inquiries about the hosting and the model used for the chatbot.

Avatar
8
2
50.0%
2
8
50.0%
Top